Mustafa Kabha has taken up an ambitious project in The Palestinian Press as Shaper of Public Opinion 1929–1939. He tells us that he intends “to lay an important foundation in the study of the history of the Palestinian Arabic press and the development of the written Palestinian Arabic culture in its entirety during the first half of the twentieth century” (p. x). Kabha thus raises the reader's hopes that his book will complement the important recent study of Palestinian Arab print culture by Ami Ayalon (Reading Palestine: Printing and Literacy, 1900–1948, 2004). It is unfortunate that The Palestinian Press as Shaper of Public Opinion does not realize such high expectations.
Although its title promises that the book will explain how newspapers influenced Palestinian Arab public opinion during a period of political mobilization, the author has chosen to emphasize description over analysis and consequently leads us to few clear or well-supported conclusions. The introduction, in which one might expect the author to frame the questions that he has endeavored to answer, instead catalogs the newspapers that appeared in Palestine from the last quarter of the 19th century until the Western Wall riots and uprising of 1929. The first of the five subsequent chapters briefly addresses important social and political aspects of newspapers, journalists, and their readership from 1929 to 1939. These aspects include relations between the Palestinian Arab intelligentsia and popular classes, participation of journalists in nationalist institutions, newspaper circulation rates, literacy among Palestinian Arabs, and the age and gender of readers. The chapter's mere twenty pages, however, are insufficient to explore thoroughly such crucial topics. The succeeding chapters relate developments in the press during four periods—from 1929 to 1932, from 1932 until the beginning of the general strike of 1936, the period of the strike, and the time of the revolt of 1936 to 1939. These sections rarely rise above the descriptive level. The book's final section is tellingly titled “Summary” rather than “Conclusions.”
Nowhere in the book does the author engage the existing literature on the public sphere, communications theory, or the role of media in independence or revolutionary movements. He also does not respond to the interpretation of the role of print media in the emergence of nationalism proposed by Benedict Anderson in his seminal work, Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism (1991). One might anticipate that, because Kabha has eschewed any overarching conceptual framework, he would have chosen to deliver a driving narrative. However, on that level, too, the reader is disappointed to find that even the book's smaller narrative units are characterized more by drift than drive.
Much of what one encounters in the book is description of newspaper content, including editorials, letters to the editor, advertisements, and more rarely, news stories. In addition, there are anecdotes about journalists, newspaper owners, vendors, and readers. Descriptive elements and anecdotes can be telling, and many of those that Kabha provides do yield significant revelations about the Palestinian Arab media, politics, and society during the 1920s and 1930s. Especially noteworthy is his effective use of interviews and some previously underused or unexploited documentary sources. Among these are the unpublished memoirs of one Muhammad Hijaz, an educated resident of the village of ʿInabta. Kabha, basing his account on such sources, relates how newspapers were delivered to mukhtars of remote rural communities, who in turn organized public readings of the news. The author tells us of specialized readers who traveled rural areas informing people of events reported in the press. One such reader in the environs of Nablus, we learn, acquired the nickname “Reuter.” Also fascinating are Kabha's accounts of cooperation among Jewish and Arab journalists and newspaper owners. His descriptions of Arabic press articles that depicted Jews or that discussed sectarianism, relations among Palestinian Arab social classes, and Anglo–Arab relations suggest how scholars of these topics might utilize the Arabic press in the future.
The book's weaknesses, though, overshadow its strengths. The weaknesses include the author's preference for generalizations over compelling conclusions. For instance, neither Kabha's evidence nor the existing scholarship supports his assertion that Hajj Amin al-Husayni “became recognized as the exclusive leader of the Palestinian Arabs following his part in the events of August 1929” (p. 33). The author supports some of the conclusions that he does draw about the press with such a thin documentary base that they might be at best considered working hypotheses for future research. This is the case with his claim that the Pan-Arab political orientation, which he facilely contrasts against Palestinian nationalism, intensified in the press in 1932 and reached its peak in 1934 and 1935 (p. 263). In a similar vein, he marshals little evidence to prove his assertion that Hajj Amin al-Husayni exercised decisive financial control over much of the press (p. 262).
Kabha tells us with suspicious certainty that there were exactly “233 acting Palestinian journalists” in the 1929–39 period, of whom “187 were politically active.” He further professes to be able to identify the “proportion of journalists among contemporary political activists” and, in a table, lists the percentage of journalists in the memberships of seven political parties or organizations (p. 17). I can think of no other scholar who claims to have such complete information about the membership of these organizations. He cites as his source Bayan Nuwayhid al-Hut's 1984 The Political Leadership and Institutions in Palestine 1917–1948 (in Arabic) (p. 688). I have access only to a 1986 edition of that book. In that edition there is a table on the page cited by Kabha that includes the same organizations and parties listed in his table. However, al-Hut does not purport to represent the total membership of these parties and organizations. Instead, her table displays only information she compiled on 100 members of the Palestinian political elite. It is odd that the proportion of journalists in the parties or organizations based upon that sample of political activists is exactly (within 0.5%) the same proportion that Kabha claims is the proportion of journalists in the organizations' total memberships. Suffice it to say, I find Kabha's documentation less than sufficient.
Finally, it must be pointed out that the book is poorly edited, containing an extraordinarily high frequency of typographical, stylistic, and grammatical lapses. Vallentine Mitchell publishers have served neither author nor readers well by allowing the book to go into production in this state.
In summary, this is a flawed book that nevertheless offers some important information and suggests how the press might be further exploited as a source for the history of the early Palestinian national movement. Anyone conducting research on that subject should consult this book—but with the greatest caution.
