Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T15:52:32.097Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Shear stress-driven flow: the state space of near-wall turbulence as $Re_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}}\rightarrow \infty$

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 July 2019

Patrick Doohan*
Affiliation:
Department of Aeronautics, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, UK
Ashley P. Willis
Affiliation:
School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Sheffield, Sheffield S3 7RH, UK
Yongyun Hwang
Affiliation:
Department of Aeronautics, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: patrick.doohan15@imperial.ac.uk

Abstract

An inner-scaled, shear stress-driven flow is considered as a model of independent near-wall turbulence as the friction Reynolds number $Re_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}}\rightarrow \infty$. In this limit, the model is applicable to the near-wall region and the lower part of the logarithmic layer of various parallel shear flows, including turbulent Couette flow, Poiseuille flow and Hagen–Poiseuille flow. The model is validated against damped Couette flow and there is excellent agreement between the velocity statistics and spectra for the wall-normal height $y^{+}<40$. A near-wall flow domain of similar size to the minimal unit is analysed from a dynamical systems perspective. The edge and fifteen invariant solutions are computed, the first discovered for this flow configuration. Through continuation in the spanwise width $L_{z}^{+}$, the bifurcation behaviour of the solutions over the domain size is investigated. The physical properties of the solutions are explored through phase portraits, including the energy input and dissipation plane, and streak, roll and wave energy space. Finally, a Reynolds number is defined in outer units and the high-$Re$ asymptotic behaviour of the equilibria is studied. Three lower branch solutions are found to scale consistently with vortex–wave interaction (VWI) theory, with wave forcing localising around the critical layer.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Flow geometry of the shear stress-driven model.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Mean streamwise velocity, $U^{+}(y^{+})$, of the shear stress-driven flow model (red dashed line), plotted against that of damped Couette flow (black solid line).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Root mean squared velocity of the shear stress-driven flow model; (a) $u_{rms}^{+}$ (red dashed line), (b) $v_{rms}^{+}$ (green solid line) and (c) $w_{rms}^{+}$ (blue dash-dotted line), plotted against that of damped Couette flow (black solid lines).

Figure 3

Table 1.Simulation parameters of the shear stress-driven flow model and damped Couette flow.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Premultiplied one-dimensional streamwise (a,c,e,g) and spanwise (b,d,f,h) wavenumber spectra of the shear stress-driven flow model; (a,b) streamwise velocity, (c,d) wall-normal velocity, (e,f) spanwise velocity and (g,h) Reynolds stress. Isocontours of damped Couette flow are superimposed in black.

Figure 5

Table 2.Simulation parameters of the reference domain, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}$.

Figure 6

Figure 5.The edge of the reference domain $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}$ (black solid line), separating initial conditions that relaminarise (blue dash-dotted lines) from those that become fully turbulent (red dash-dotted lines). $E_{u}^{+}$ is the streamwise turbulent fluctuation energy and $t_{0}^{+}$ is the time by which the initial transient behaviour of the edge has decayed sufficiently. The inset shows the relative periodic orbit embedded in the edge.

Figure 7

Table 3.Properties of the invariant solutions in $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}$: $T^{+}$, the time period; $c_{x}^{+}$, the phase speed; $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E5}^{+}$, the wall shear rate; $I/I_{l}$, the energy input normalised by that of the laminar state; $E_{p}$, the kinetic energy deviation from the laminar state; $\dim (W^{u})$, the dimension of the unstable manifold. The $c_{x}^{+}$, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E5}^{+}$, $I/I_{l}$ and $E_{p}$ values of $PO_{A0L}$ and $PO_{C0U}$ are averages over the period $T^{+}$.

Figure 8

Figure 6.Velocity field visualisation and root mean squared velocity profiles of the Group A relative periodic orbit and relative equilibrium solutions, henceforth titled $PO_{A0L}$, $EQ_{A1L}$, $EQ_{A2}$, $EQ_{A3L}$ and $EQ_{A4L}$, respectively. The red and blue surfaces represent high- and low-speed streaks; (a,b,d) $u^{+}-\langle u^{+}\rangle _{x^{+},z^{+}}=\pm 3$, (c,e) $u^{+}-\langle u^{+}\rangle _{x^{+},z^{+}}=\pm 1.5$. The yellow and green surfaces are iso-surfaces of wall-normal velocity; $v^{+}=\pm 0.12$. Red dashed lines, $u_{rms}^{+}$; green solid lines, $v_{rms}^{+}$; blue dash-dotted lines, $w_{rms}^{+}$. The root mean squared velocity profile of $PO_{A0L}$ is an average over the period $T^{+}$.

Figure 9

Figure 7.Velocity field visualisation and root mean squared velocity profiles of the Group B relative equilibrium solutions, henceforth titled $EQ_{B5L}$, $EQ_{B3U}$, $EQ_{B4U}$, $EQ_{B6L}$ and $EQ_{B6U}$, respectively. The red and blue surfaces represent high and low speed streaks; (a,d,e) $u^{+}-\langle u^{+}\rangle _{x^{+},z^{+}}=\pm 3$, (b,c) $u^{+}-\langle u^{+}\rangle _{x^{+},z^{+}}=\pm 2$. The yellow and green surfaces are isosurfaces of wall-normal velocity; (a,d,e) $v^{+}=\pm 0.9$, (b,c) $v^{+}=\pm 0.35$. Red dashed lines, $u_{rms}^{+}$; green solid lines, $v_{rms}^{+}$; blue dash-dotted lines, $w_{rms}^{+}$.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Velocity field visualisation and root mean squared velocity profiles of the Group C relative periodic orbit and relative equilibrium solutions, henceforth titled $PO_{C0U}$, $EQ_{C1U}$, $EQ_{C5U}$, $EQ_{C7L}$ and $EQ_{C7U}$, respectively. The red and blue surfaces represent high- and low-speed streaks; $u^{+}-\langle u^{+}\rangle _{x^{+},z^{+}}=\pm 3.75$. The yellow and green surfaces are iso-surfaces of wall-normal velocity; (a,d) $v^{+}=\pm 1.4$, (b,c,e) $v^{+}=\pm 1.9$. Red dashed lines, $u_{rms}^{+}$; green solid lines, $v_{rms}^{+}$; blue dash-dotted lines, $w_{rms}^{+}$. The root mean squared velocity profile of $PO_{C0U}$ is an average over the period $T^{+}$.

Figure 11

Figure 9.Wall shear rate of the invariant solutions, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E5}^{+}$, as a function of the spanwise width; (a) $L_{z}^{+}$ normalised by $u_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F},r}$, (b) $L_{z}^{\ast }$ normalised by $u_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F},e}$. The grey dashed line represents the width of the reference domain $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}$. Brown line, $PO_{A0L}$ & $PO_{C0U}$; black line, $EQ_{A1L}$ & $EQ_{C1U}$; gold line, $EQ_{A2}$; blue line, $EQ_{A3L}$ & $EQ_{B3U}$; red line, $EQ_{A4L}$ & $EQ_{B4U}$; green line, $EQ_{B5L}$ & $EQ_{C5U}$; cyan line, $EQ_{B6L}$ & $EQ_{B6U}$; pink line, $EQ_{C7L}$ & $EQ_{C7U}$. The $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E5}^{+}$ values of $PO_{A0L}$ and $PO_{C0U}$ are averages over the period $T^{+}$. The inset shows the subcritical Hopf bifurcation of $EQ_{A1L}$.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Phase portraits of a turbulent trajectory and the invariant solutions: (a) the $(I/I_{l},D/D_{l})$ plane, where $I_{l}$ and $D_{l}$ represent the energy input and dissipation of the laminar state; (b) the $(I/I_{l},E_{p})$ plane, where $E_{p}$ is the kinetic energy deviation from the laminar state. Brown square & line, $PO_{A0L}$ & $PO_{C0U}$; black square & triangle, $EQ_{A1L}$ & $EQ_{C1U}$; gold square, $EQ_{A2}$; blue square & circle, $EQ_{A3L}$ & $EQ_{B3U}$; red square & circle, $EQ_{A4L}$ & $EQ_{B4U}$; green circle & triangle, $EQ_{B5L}$ & $EQ_{C5U}$; cyan unfilled & filled circles, $EQ_{B6L}$ & $EQ_{B6U}$; pink unfilled & filled triangles, $EQ_{C7L}$ & $EQ_{C7U}$. The $I/I_{l}$, $D/D_{l}$ and $E_{p}$ values of $PO_{A0L}$ are averages over the period $T^{+}$.

Figure 13

Figure 11.Phase portraits of a turbulent trajectory and the invariant solutions: (a) $(E_{s}/\bar{E}_{s},E_{r}/\bar{E}_{r},E_{w}/\bar{E}_{w})$ space, where $E_{s}$, $E_{r}$ and $E_{w}$ represent the streak, roll and wave energy respectively, and $\overline{~\cdot ~}$ denotes the average in time while the flow remains turbulent; (b) the $(E_{r}/\bar{E}_{r},E_{w}/\bar{E}_{w})$ plane; (c) the $(E_{s}/\bar{E}_{s},E_{r}/\bar{E}_{r})$ plane. The symbols are identical to those used in figure 10.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Scaling of (a,b) $EQ_{A1L}$, (c,d) $EQ_{A2}$, (e,f) $EQ_{A3L}$ and (g,h) $EQ_{A4L}$ with $Re$; (a,c,e,g) solid lines, $E_{s}$, dash-dotted lines, $E_{r}$; (b,d,f,h) solid lines, $E_{w1}$, dash-dotted lines, $E_{w2}$. The grey dotted lines represent the VWI scaling; $E_{s}\sim Re^{0}$, $E_{r}\sim Re^{-2}$, $E_{w1}\sim Re^{-2}$ and $E_{w2}\sim Re^{-3}$.

Figure 15

Figure 13.Wave-induced forcing, $F(y,z)$, of (a,b) $EQ_{A1L}$, (c,d) $EQ_{A2}$, (e,f) $EQ_{A3L}$ and (g,h) $EQ_{A4L}$; (a,c,e,g) $Re=1250$; (b,d,f,h) $Re=12\,500$. The white line represents the critical layer position, $U(y,z)=c_{x}$.