This important volume challenges prospective reviewers with the sheer range and depth of its contributions. Divided into three principal parts – ‘Geography and scientific revolution’, ‘Geography and technical revolution’ and ‘Geography and political revolution’ – it consists of some dozen papers from scholars in several disciplines including history of science, cultural history and historical geography. Each section is admirably prefaced by a short synoptic piece by the editors, who also, in Chapter 1, explore the theme of geography and revolution from a number of perspectives. Their primary aim is ‘to raise questions about the difference that space makes in understanding revolutionary phenomena and to consider, in different geographical and historical contexts, how people [as historical actors] looked to geography and to geographical insights for an explanation of what they took to be “revolution”’ (p. 16). The volume closes with a reflective afterword from the distinguished cultural historian Peter Burke.
As one might expect, geography and, especially, revolution both come in for historiographic analysis. Awareness of the predicament of HSTM within history, where scholarship tends to be much more tightly tied to conventional ‘periods’ and geographical area studies, has undoubtedly stimulated our field's great sensitivity to historiography over several decades. In contrast, it is noteworthy that, when challenged, many practising general historians still tend to think of ‘historiography’ in terms of the revisionist history whereby a new generation of practitioners challenges orthodox explanations and paves the way for an incremental approach to ‘truth’. Thus when such historians speak of ‘historiography’ to their students, they see it less as a matter of historical methodology and more as a survey of the secondary literature presented chronologically. Historians of science, on the other hand, have Thomas Kuhn (among others) to thank for triggering that tradition of critical reflection which challenges any simple notions of accretion of knowledge, historical as well as scientific. Significantly, Peter Dear notes in his chapter on ‘Space, revolution, and science’ that in American universities the ‘use of Kuhn's book in history courses seems to be evidence … that historians are unsure of what they mean by the term “revolution” and thus have to resort to anything that can help them to conceptualize it more clearly’ (p. 27).
Dear's chapter, which opens Part One, does much to highlight the post-Kuhnian problems of ‘revolution’ as an analytical category. He points, however, to ‘revolutions’ as historical actors' categories as well as to ‘revolutions’ ‘that receive that label some time after the fact, but in a way that becomes historically significant in later periods’ (p. 30). The rest of the chapter offers a series of illuminating case studies to demonstrate the ways in which space and place matter to such ‘revolutions’ in knowledge. A compelling illustration of parallel issues with respect to ‘revolution’ is to be found in James Moore's chapter. It begins tellingly with a quote from Charles Darwin himself, who wrote in 1857 that the ‘immigration of a few new forms, or even a single one, may well cause a revolution in the relations of a multitude of old occupants’ (p. 106, my italics). Here Darwin depicted organic nature as just as prone to revolution as human society. Writing in his inimitable style with reference to more contemporary ‘alien invasions’, Moore dispels the once-pervasive myth that there can be no politics in scientific knowledge. He thereafter demonstrates persuasively the significance of spatial language: for Darwin, who represented ‘Englishmen as invasive organisms, multiplying, spreading across the earth, keeping evolution on the march’ (p. 126), but also for Wallace, who portrayed human beings as having the capacity to refuse to join what he viewed ‘as a corrupting rather than a civilizing influence’ (p. 126). By implication, any ‘Darwinian revolution’ has to be a later construction by specific groups of historical actors, intent on reinventing Darwin for a different set of audiences.
Dear's and Moore's chapters are joined in Part One by chapters by John Henry and co-editor Charles W. J. Withers on geography and the changes formerly known as the Scientific Revolution, and it is undoubtedly to these that BJHS readers will gravitate. But the rest of the book also deserves exploration. Part Two offers studies of geography and maps, clocks and photography. In Part Three geography in revolution is exemplified especially vividly in co-editor David Livingstone's chapter ‘“Risen into empire”: moral geographies of the American Republic’. Here he provides a study of the role of geography in the service of the new nation after the ‘Revolution’. Jedidiah Morse's American Geography (1789), which sold over twenty thousand copies in its first five years, aimed to counter European misrepresentations and to forge out of local differences a unified nation under God. Author of Annals of the American Revolution (1824), Morse supplied a vision that, Livingstone shows, provided a moral geography of the nation modelled on New England values (as distinct from the one offered in Thomas Jefferson's Notes on the State of Virginia (1787)). Also of considerable interest to historians of science is Nicolaas Rupke's chapter in this part on Alexander von Humboldt and the ‘geography of reception’.
Geography and Revolution serves its purpose well. No longer taking as a given the grand narratives and ‘big-picture’ histories of revolutions, it successfully puts ‘revolutions’ (scientific, technical and sociopolitical) in their respective places and spaces. On the one hand, the price to be paid for so doing is that the disappearance of the grand narrative makes it much harder to see the wood for the trees. The wood, indeed, may no longer exist. On the other hand, locating human action in space as well as in time yields spectacular returns for the historian, whether of knowledge or of politics. It is a message that deserves to be more widely heard throughout the communities of historical practitioners, wherever located.
