Peter Ratcliffe and Ines Newman's edited book, Promoting Social Cohesion: Implications for Policy and Evaluation provides a well-rounded and comprehensive analysis of social cohesion, examining its definition, measurement, policy implementation and evaluation. Throughout its chapters, this book builds on the historical roots of social cohesion, relating academic and policy discourses to current and past governmental ideologies.
The books first task is to argue, in Peter Ratcliffe's chapter 1, for the use of social, rather than community cohesion, given the latter construct's disregard for the role that material inequalities, deprivation and endemic racism have on mediating social cohesiveness. This approach to highlighting the influence of material inequalities and racism on social cohesion underlies all book chapters, which strongly argue that it is these factors, as well as residential instability, that are the key drivers of social cohesion − and not ethnicity or ethnic residential concentration. Given that racialised discourses of social cohesion have largely problematised ethnic diversity as the main driver of reduced social cohesion, a stronger case for the positives of diversity, in addition to the focus placed on the corrosive influence of deprivation and racism on social solidarity, would strengthen the authors’ argument. By challenging previous conceptualisations of community cohesion, delineating the construct of social cohesion, and demonstrating the importance of local knowledge, the first part of the book aims to achieve conceptual clarity that can later guide policy implementation and evaluation.
Methodological limitations in measuring and evaluating social cohesion policies are addressed in part two, stressing the need for a detailed operationalisation of social cohesion, a correct use data sources and adequate analytical methods. The book's Theory of Change, as argued in chapters 2, 6, 9 and 10, emphasises the need to engage all stakeholders when defining, monitoring and evaluating interventions, a process that will in itself empower and promote a better understanding among communities.
Grounded by the book's focus on structural inequalities, housing (chapter 8, by Peter Ratcliffe), education (chapter 9, by Audrey Osler) and the labour force market (chapter 10, by Ines Newman), are considered key policy components to promote social cohesion. These chapters complement the book's fundamental focus on social justice by highlighting the influence of income, social class, structural racism and racial discrimination in driving housing position and spatial patterns, educational and employment outcomes. Policy chapters also emphasise the need to address tensions between and across community groups, including generations and settled and new migrant groups.
The book's conclusion critiques the current coalition government's ‘Big Society’ agenda, as it is ‘likely to increase inequalities, which in turn will make “good relations” between different groups in society harder to achieve’ (p. 269). Peter Ratcliffe has argued elsewhere (Ratcliffe, Reference Ratcliffe2012) that the combination of current public sector cuts, changes in housing benefits and the ‘Big Society’ will result in increased social inequalities and in an expected decline in prospects for an ‘integrated and cohesive society’. In the face of the current socio-political climate, and the challenges that this poses for social cohesion, the book tries to end on a positive note, suggesting that progress on equality can be achieved at the local level. Although a welcomed approach, this seems like an arduous responsibility without the help of the national government.
Promoting Social Cohesion: Implications for Policy and Evaluation was published ten years after the civil unrest that occurred in the northern towns of Bradford, Burnley and Oldham in 2001 − events that catapulted the concept of community cohesion to the forefront of political, academic and media debates. The book's social cohesion approach remains highly relevant today, especially when considering the roots of last summer's civil disturbances. The first paragraph in chapter 10 states that, ‘any attempt to achieve good relations between people from different backgrounds in the absence of a serious push on equality is destined to fail’ (p. 207), and this book's focus on addressing structural inequality and endemic racism is key to understanding and promoting social cohesion.
