This work represents an unusual collaboration between an anthropologist (Gelya Frank) and a legal scholar (Carole Goldberg). Of the two authors, it is Frank who might best be considered the originator of the project, as she possesses the most prolonged experience with the Tule Lake Tribe, with whom she has worked in various capacities for twenty-five years. Over time, Frank compiled a wealth of historical data on the Tribe, much of it relating to United States v. Whaley, an 1888 legal case touching on the question of law enforcement on Indian reservations. In 2004, Frank invited Goldberg to join her on a law review article relating to the Whaley case, and the partnership blossomed into their co-authorship of Defying the Odds.
Despite its unusual genesis, Defying the Odds nonetheless reads less like a hybrid project and more like a traditional work of legal scholarship. The analysis, after all, is anchored in one of the fundamental issues of Indian law: tribal sovereignty; and the authors carefully trace the ebbs and flows in this issue across several centuries, as the Yokuts peoples confronted first the Mexican and then the U.S. colonial projects. This broad chronological sweep has the virtue of avoiding the segmented periodization that often besets histories of Native America, and demonstrates the way the Tule River Tribe attempted to control its destiny at many different times and in many different settings, from the genocidal wars of the California Gold Rush, to the Indian Reorganization Act, to its recent involvement in casino gambling.
The hinge of Defying the Odds, however, remains the Whaley case, in which four Tribe members were arrested in the 1880s for killing a tribal healer in keeping with customary norms of Yokuts justice. The federal government prosecuted the defendants under the recently passed Major Crimes Act, which had removed murder and other “serious” crimes from tribal jurisdiction and made them a federal concern. This criminalization of what had previously been tribal custom represented, the authors argue, not only an assault on the Tule River Tribe's sovereignty but also established an unfortunate precedent for Indian country as a whole by undercutting the possibility of concurrent tribal jurisdiction. Thanks to the wealth of court records generated by this incident, the authors are able to explore the event's facets in considerable detail, from the tensions between the Tribe's chief and shaman to the character of the varied Euro-American administrators and lawyers involved in the case.
It can feel a bit ungenerous to critique a book as well intentioned as this one, with its ambitious collaborative approach and its sympathetic view of Native American sovereignty. But there are moments when the marriage of anthropology and legal studies in Defying the Odds seem to result less in an advanced new composite model of scholarship, but rather to reinscribe some of the liabilities of each field. Frank and Goldberg, for example, seem unwilling to question the Tribe's oral testimony about the incident that triggered the Whaley case. Tribe members maintain that a tribal healer, Watisti, poisoned one of their chiefs rather than healing him; afterwards, Tribe members decided, in keeping with Yokuts norms of justice, to execute Watisti for his misdeed. The authors do not entertain the equally plausible possibility that Watisti was not a premeditated murderer, but may in fact have simply been an unsuccessful healer, blamed for an illness beyond his control or, as often happened to those perceived to be spiritually powerful, caught up in accusations of “witchcraft.” Casting the incident in this light could have raised provocative questions about the trade-offs involved in moving between tribal customs of justice and the Western legal tradition, which now go unexamined, not to mention raising important issues about the functioning of historical memory.
Similarly, the authors build such a conclusive case for the primacy of sovereignty in the history of the Tule River Tribe that this issue at times almost functions as the end point of their analysis rather than its point of departure. If, however, one takes sovereignty as a given, the key interpretive question is not its mere existence but rather how it was refashioned across time by the Tule River Tribe (itself, of course, a historical creation). Yet Frank and Goldberg spend little time on internal debates within the Tribe about membership, gaming, land distribution, or other controversial issues that would have demonstrated the extent to which there existed competing notions in the Tule River community about how the tribe should best exercise its sovereignty.
Nonetheless, for those interested in the Whaley case or in gaining a longue durée portrait of California's Native American life, Defying the Odds represents an invaluable contribution, one that will raise important further discussions about Native American law and the nature of sovereignty, for years to come.
