International administration is not a new phenomenon. It started as early as 1815 with the establishment of the independent republic of Cracow at the Congress of Vienna. However, this practice has occurred extensively and transformed gradually during past decades, mainly after the end of the Cold War. It is arguably a result of an evolution of the trust territory, mandate, and traditional peacekeeping mission. The complexity of international legal problems, as well as the expanding function of the United Nations (UN), has also contributed to the development of international administration. Despite its rapid development, the current international legal regime is deemed insufficient to deal with this particular matter, specifically on the legal status of the territory, legal obligations of international actors, and the accountability mechanism for foreign authorities.
Having significant qualifications in international law, specifically in the law of peace and security, and the laws of armed conflict, the author lays down some innovative propositions in the area of post-conflict administration. The highlight of these propositions is to create a distinct legal regime of “jus post bellum” to govern post-conflict administration specifically by foreign powers or international organizations.
There are specifically four cases analysed in this book, concerning the practices of Kosovo, East Timor, Afghanistan, and Iraq. These cases were all unique and different in nature. However, there appear to be rather similar problems in those administrations. These include a conflicting interest between local ownership and internationalization for effective governance, as well as an incomprehensive, or rather vague exit strategy. The author argues that a comprehensive approach thus needs to be made in the implementation of administration. It is very important to include economic rehabilitation as part of a comprehensive approach, as it is closely interrelated with other aspects of peacebuilding, such as security.
This book is divided into four parts. The first part describes the traditional purpose of international administration, which is peacebuilding and is reconstructive in nature. In early cases, namely the Free City of Danzig, the international administration was merely established to settle a territorial dispute following the end of World War II. There has been a continuous expansion of peacekeeping mandates. The shift from keeping peace to building peace has given authority to international administration to control the territory to the same extent as the occupying power. This entails the application of the rule of occupation in international law, as elaborated well in the second part of this book.
The second part of this book describes how international law governs post-conflict administration. Practices have shown that the international community has been more acceptant towards the UN’s ability to set up a mission. As such, there is hardly any question on the legality of a mission when it is based solely on a Security Council resolution, as derived from Chapter VII of the UN Charter. The Security Council is thus given an unlimited mandate to decide upon “measures not involving use of force” under Article 41 of the UN Charter, including establishing the administration of a territory.
The third part of this book mainly describes the current practices concerning the task of institution building and democracy. The author mainly focuses on the general approach and major difficulties encountered in the practices of Kosovo, East Timor, Afghanistan, and Iraq. In most cases, they seem to have a wide extension, if not interpretation, from their original mandates. In Kosovo, an extensive measure was taken when public companies were privatized. In Iraq, far-reaching measures, such as the order allowing for unlimited foreign investor participation aside from the oil sector, have been adopted to achieve the liberalization of the economy.
In this part, the author has given a very comprehensive analysis concerning each component of administration. Through his overview, we can see how complex the structure of international administration is. Each component has different functions, from essential governmental tasks such as civil administration and emergency relief, to more complex and long-term objectives such as institution building and democratic governance. The difficult task is how to co-ordinate them in order to achieve a common purpose.
Part four of this book contains the main proposal, which is to create a legal framework for comprehensive post-conflict reconstruction. This legal framework is crucial, because most of the time the missions are rather unclear on their objectives. As a result, they are faced with even more problems than before. In Kosovo, UNMIK is faced with uncertain final status. In Afghanistan and Iraq, elections and the completion of the transitional process turned out to be insufficient, as they now face more problems on security and stability, regardless of the “democratic” transitions.
Overall, this book lays out a thorough and comprehensive description on the facts and practices of current peacebuilding missions. However, despite his emphasis on building local capacity, the author has left an open question on how to resolve the conflict between having more international staff for the purpose of efficient and effective administration and involving more local personnel with a lack of capacity. The author has acknowledged, however, that the purpose of this book is not to establish a “model” post-conflict administration. He nevertheless points out that the main problem occurring in most missions is laid upon the intrusive nature of the powers, as well as lack of planning by the international organizations. Lack of knowledge about the local environment, including minority issues in Kosovo, for example, also contributes to the ineffectiveness of current missions. In conclusion, the author has proposed a need for an adequate exit strategy, a balance between internationalization and local ownership, as well as a new legal regime for post-conflict administration, which is the emerging “jus post bellum”. This could be a solution to regulate the peacebuilding missions in order to achieve their main objective, and actually solve the internal problems, rather than create them.
