The inseparable relationship between rhetoric and Roman poetry has long been under-studied, presumably due to the negative connotations that used to come with rhetoric. Critics of classical literature used to regard rhetoric as a mendacious and shallow art, and any possible affinity with poetry as an affront. Attempts were made to rescue some poets — Virgil and Ovid are perhaps the most famous examples — from depreciation by exonerating them of any supposed influence from rhetoric. The Romantic era, with its ideal of the isolated creative genius, is often identified as the root of this begrudging view of rhetoric. However, its origins can already be seen in ancient texts, which condemn declamation as the catalyst of an alleged decline in poetry and oratory in the early Imperial period.
In Persuasion, Rhetoric and Roman Poetry, Irene Peirano Garrison, Professor of Classics at Yale University, revisits this long-standing debate with the aim of exploring the relationship between rhetorical theory and the production and reception of Imperial Roman poetry. Her book is divided into three parts comprising six essays, so-called ‘case studies’.
The first part discusses the works of Seneca the Elder and Quintilian. These works, P. argues, are responses to the contemporary debate about oratorical decline, aiming to reestablish the value of rhetoric and rhetorical education. P. reads the Institutio Oratoria as a complex and emulative text which, in its struggle to restore rhetoric as an authority, competes with and distances itself from the poetic medium.
Similarly, the second part suggests, the Roman poets were aware of, and responded to, the narratives found in rhetorical texts. P. reads epic as responding to rhetoric, partly through the metaphor of the storm, which occurs in many epics and is associated with the grand style in rhetorical handbooks, partly through the representation of the ‘demagogue’, which engages in an ongoing debate about the nature of the bonus orator.
The third part addresses the late antique reception of Virgil's Aeneid. Commentators read the Aeneid as an instantiation of rhetorical principles with the overarching goal of persuasion. To Macrobius, Virgil is ‘non minus orator quam poeta’, ‘no less an orator than a poet’. In Macrobius’ conception, the two genres of rhetoric and epic are amalgamated and belong together. Virgil's epic text is rhetorical in its entirety, not only in certain elements.
What is especially invigorating about this book is the way it challenges the conception of the impact of rhetoric on poetry as one-sided. P. rejects the traditional view of rhetoric as somehow debasing or colonising literature. Instead, she prefers to speak of a mutual ‘ongoing traffic’ between the two genres in a generic interaction. The poets can be seen to play with the expectations and rules of rhetoric. On the other hand, rhetorical theory can be read as ‘a powerful cultural lens through which poetry is viewed, read and sometimes disowned as a rhetorically constructed genre’. This approach is a long way from the conception of rhetoric as a system of rules which the poets followed or departed from.
I read Persuasion, Rhetoric and Roman Poetry as opening a broader perspective onto intertextuality. The literary game was not restricted to poetry. Poets and rhetoricians participated together, commenting on and competing with each other, not by direct allusion but on a more general — and generic — level. P's profound and insightful study provides its reader with a new lens, which will henceforth shape my view of ancient rhetorical theory and epic.
