In 2003 the Boston Archdiocese announced a “reconfiguration” of its resources that would lead to the closing of eighty parishes and nine schools. Many Boston Catholics, still reeling from the latest revelations of clerical sexual abuse, were bitterly disappointed at the prospect of seeing their churches forced to shut. Indeed, some Catholics were so upset that they decided to occupy their parishes to prevent their closure. In No Closure, John Seitz, a theology professor at Fordham University, chronicles the efforts made by resisters to occupy seven parishes of the archdiocese.
Seitz, who was a doctoral student at Harvard Divinity School from 2004 to 2008, spent many hours with the protesters, whom he refers to as “vigilers.” He interviewed them, he sat with them on their shifts, and at times he filled in for them when no vigiler could be present in a church. Seitz stressed that his goal was “not a lionization of resistance or popular Catholicism” (16). Instead, he said that he was seeking insight into the “inner histories” of the vigilers so as to understand what motivated them to take over the churches and continue occupying them month after month (17).
Most of the churches selected by the archdiocese for closure had been struggling for years. Some were ethnic parishes like Sacred Heart in Boston's North End and Our Lady of Mount Carmel in East Boston. Both parishes had been founded to minister to Italian immigrants decades earlier and no longer had many communicants. A few suburban parishes were ailing as well. St. Albert the Great in Weymouth, for example, depended on gaming in its church hall to stay solvent.
Despite the problems facing these churches, Boston's archbishop Seán O'Malley knew that many people would be deeply pained to see their churches close. Consequently, he urged them to remember the sacrifices their ancestors had made for the good of the church and to adopt a similar sacrificial spirit in support of the church's present mission. Archdiocesan officials also prepared a detailed “closing manual” which they distributed to the pastors of the affected parishes. The book included suggestions about celebrating the parish's Last Mass and helping parishioners make the move to their receiving parishes. It also stressed that the community members should see themselves as “living stones” (1 Pet. 2:5) who embody the church.
As Seitz notes, the vigilers were not persuaded by these arguments. When O'Malley spoke of sacrifice, the vigilers recalled all the sacrifices their parents and grandparents had made to establish and maintain their parishes. Nor would they agree that the churches were just buildings; they were sacred spaces. “Annetta,” a vigiler at Mt. Carmel—Seitz has changed all of their names—brought him to the main altar to show him the saints’ relics that had been placed in it by a bishop at its consecration. Other vigilers had similarly traditional ideas about Catholic architecture and liturgy. “Gerard,” another vigiler at Mt. Carmel, made it his mission to rebuild niches for statues of saints which had been removed in the years after Vatican II. He also restored a large crucifix to its former place above the main altar.
Seitz points out that many of the vigilers combined their fondness for statues and grottoes and novenas with a very postconciliar understanding of the nature of the church. Several emphasized that they saw themselves as the “People of God” and did not need to be beholden to the hierarchy in any way. Seitz points out that some vigilers sensed that arguments about democratizing the church would gain them the most support from the media and the general public. Thus, they emphasized those points rather than their attachments to the buildings.
While trying to assert their independence from the bishops, the vigilers were careful not to be too defiant. Every day they prayed the rosary in their churches and every Sunday a vigiler would lead a communion service and distribute the Eucharist to the congregation. The parishes were able to obtain a steady supply of consecrated Hosts from sympathetic priests. The Sunday services were technically illicit because they are only permitted in remote areas where no priests are available. Still, the vigilers took pains to follow the rubrics for these services. And when approached by a group of laicized priests—whose website is rentapriest.com—they decided not to grant them access to their churches.
Seitz is right to see the vigilers as complicated Catholics. Many have embraced the most liberal possible perspectives on church governance while pining for Latin liturgies and Marian processions. They are pious and old-fashioned and rebellious and sometimes irreverent. Seitz argues that the Boston vigilers are in many respects representative of most American Catholics who cannot be neatly classified as “progressives” or “restorationists” (226).
While this is an intriguing claim, it is not clear that the vigilers have much in common with most other Catholics in Boston or anywhere else in America. Despite Seitz's efforts to empathize with them, they still seem very quirky. Several such as “Annetta” were not practicing their faith before the closings were announced. “Annetta” acknowledged that her sister had rebuked her, telling her that if she and others like her had actively supported Mt. Carmel, it would never have been slated for closure. Another vigiler, “Sam,” a retired mechanic, was also an infrequent attendee at Mt. Carmel when it was open. Seitz remarks that “Sam” now “loved to be in the church alone, tinkering” (167). The vigilers at St. Albert's seem equally idiosyncratic. They decided to put a large picture of their former pastor on the celebrant's chair in the sanctuary. One of the leading vigilers at St. Albert's, “Abigail,” chooses to sleep in the priest's chair in the Reconciliation Room.
Eccentric or not, the vigilers were determined. They filed suits in American courts and appeals with the Vatican. And they have continued to occupy their churches for years. In some cases, their persistence has paid off. St. Albert's has been allowed to remain open as a full-fledged parish and Sacred Heart has been turned into a chapel under the auspices of a neighboring parish.
Seitz's work has some shortcomings. It is unfortunate that he did not interview any of the archdiocese's officials or any laypersons who accepted the closures. His work would have benefited from their perspectives. It would also have benefited from some stylistic editing. Seitz's writing is dense throughout and he lapses into jargon at times. For instance, in describing the vigilers’ practice of sleeping in the churches, he says it “remained a polyvalent emblem of the architectonic resisters sought to create in these remade church buildings” (230).
These difficulties notwithstanding, Seitz deserves credit for what he has accomplished. He has provided keenly insightful portraits of the vigilers and has given readers a thorough account of the crisis that erupted in Boston over the closure announcements. In the winter of 2004, Archbishop O'Malley admitted: “At times, I ask God to call me home and let someone else finish this job, but I keep waking up in the morning to face another day of reconfiguration” (145). After reading No Closure, one can well understand why O'Malley and so many other Boston Catholics have found the “reconfiguration” process so terribly painful.
