When Forde, longtime professor of systematic theology at Luther Seminary, St. Paul, passed away in 2005, North American Lutheranism lost one of its most distinctive theological voices. Forde was well-known in academic and ecumenical circles as a possessor of a pastor's heart, a razor-sharp wit and a keen theological mind. A provocateur of sorts, he excelled, particularly in his essays and sermons, in employing clear, compelling language to communicate a relentlessly Lutheran set of dogmatic convictions. A More Radical Gospel, the third in the Lutheran Quarterly Books series and the first of a projected three volumes of selections from Forde's shorter writings, captures this late giant at his best and most provocative.
The volume contains fourteen essays and seven sermons. The essays are divided by topic into four theological loci: three each on eschatology, authority and ecumenism; five on atonement. The selections are taken from across Forde's career and thus exhibit the remarkable continuity and consistency of his theological thinking. Forde persistently emphasised the inseparability of theology and preaching – Theology is for Proclamation is the title of what is perhaps his best and most well-known monograph and the sermons that conclude A More Radical Gospel demonstrate the theoretician putting his master thesis into practice.
Readers new to Forde's work will benefit from the handy introduction by volume editors Mattes and Paulson. Both formerly students of Forde, they manage lucidly to convey the ethos of their late teacher's theology. Here Forde's work is presented above all as a rigorous and permeating theologia crucis, as reflection that begins and ends with the event of Jesus’ crucifixion and the public proclamation of this event in the ‘word of the cross’. According to the editors, Forde unceasingly laboured to allow the event of the cross and its enduring publicity to guide all of his theological thinking and it is hard not to notice the ascendancy of this theme in these collected shorter writings.
It is also difficult to miss those emphases which are the normal stuff of Lutheran theology: the centrality of the doctrine of justification for all other dogmatic categories and concepts; an anthropology marked by the notion that Christians are ‘simultaneously sinner and saint while the world continues’ (p. xii); a robust doctrine of divine communicative action and an iterative employment of ‘Word of God’ to solve such riddles as sacramental presence and ecclesial ontology; etc. Perhaps what is most significant for the current milieu of theological inquiry is Forde's sophisticated use of the law/gospel distinction, a matter which is of considerable debate in contemporary Lutheran circles. Some will undoubtedly argue that Forde's employment of the distinction, as exemplified in these writings, is too categorical and far-reaching.
There is also the controversial issue of Forde's persistent emphasis on the disruptive character of the event of the cross and its public proclamation. As the title suggests, Forde indeed has in mind a ‘more radical gospel’ – a life-shattering communication of an event which was itself a crisis of all earthly actualities. Because the message preached is subversive, Forde somewhat surprisingly asserts that the mediating office of public proclamation ‘seeks to remove itself once it has done the mediation’ (p. 198). One wonders how much ecumenical mileage can in fact be gained from such a discontinuous account of the message preached and the ministerial office.
These hesitations aside, it is the hope of this reviewer that the publication of these essays will allow Forde's distinctive voice to speak once again on such issues and to a new generation of readers.
