The tradition of literary utopias provides reports from well-equipped laboratories for imagined social experiments marked by idealisation and advocacy. These fictional case-studies often display the potential for a dystopian dark side, where the experiments make the world worse rather than better. The most poignant and best-known works in this tradition − narratives like Zamyatin's We, Huxley's Brave New World, or Orwell's 1984, known as ‘anti-utopias’, but also their precursors like Swift's Gulliver's Travels, in the absurdist image of the sterile ‘projectors’ of science at the Academy at Lagado, or their successors, like Piercy's Woman on the Edge of Time, in the terrifying image of the medical utopia of surgical adjustment and improvement − take dystopian speculation one step further: they report that the worst dystopias can be anticipated not where practical reality merely falls short of utopian ideals, but rather where utopian idealisation is made to succeed in practice.
The global enforcement of ideals, the comprehensive rule of the conceptual, the abstract and the schematic over the complexities of life, turns out to be ipso facto totalitarian, and ultimately the very process of enacting the idealisations exacts a terrible toll, to the detriment of cherished (likewise utopian) values like freedom, dignity, justice, variety, complexity, emotional depth, vitality and even human evolutionary capacity. What does this imply for the expansion and pervasive transformation of Western universities in our own time, when the organisation of knowledge is restlessly recast under the cross-disciplinary impact on the academy of a variety of reformist advocacy programmes, such as feminist studies, aboriginal studies, race studies, environmental studies, health studies and the like? Arguably, both the experiences arising from such academic idealisation and the possible consequences, should the academy be fully totalised in the light of one or more programmatic advocacy disciplines aimed at setting the world right, can be meaningfully interrogated with reference to the questions posed and the cautionary lessons learned from the narrative utopian laboratory.
Perhaps no other reformist intervention has carried utopian advocacy into the academy more noticeably in recent years than feminism (in general) and the women's studies programmes arising everywhere from the 1970s. Daphne Patai, herself a feminist scholar of utopian fiction, is well known for having brought a self-critical dimension to the discourse around academic feminism in her two most significant critiques of feminist malpractice, Professing Feminism: Cautionary Tales from the Strange World of Women's Studies (co-authored with Noretta Koertge, 1994) and Heterophobia: Sexual Harassment and the Future of Feminism (1998). In both books, as a self-professed ‘utopian junkie’ (p. 28), she provides ample anecdotal and analytic evidence of the gap between feminist utopian aspirations and the twisted educational practices which have come to be part and parcel of the empirical realisation of feminist ideals.
In addition to showing how feminism has not lived up to its ideals, on the one side, she also argues, on the other, that the spectacular successes of academic feminism have entailed perhaps an even deeper problem, most intelligible through a reflection on the damage to evidence-based inquiry and knowledge wrought by the politicisation of education. I should add immediately that, in exploring this situation in the academy, Patai has not given up on the modernising feminist/humanist programme which promotes the unrestricted participation of women in all aspects of the human universe. Rather, her particular critical focus is generally restricted to the kind of feminism that is based on identity politics, on the primary filtering of experience and the primary construction of knowledge and political activism through the lens of gender identification.
Written at the high watermark of identity-based feminist excess in 1990s USA, Patai's work challenges the underpinning sectarianism of feminist identity politics, its intolerance and dogmatism, its ideological righteousness, its growing truculence towards men. She focuses on the anti-utopian blindness which has come to accompany the insight into gender: the overarching preoccupation with ‘gender’, as the driver of sociological events and cultural attitudes, tends to become increasingly anti-humanist, illiberal and totalitarian, much like any other obsession with privileged engines of theory and behaviour such as ‘class' or ‘race’ or the ‘ever-growing list of politically charged identities’ (p. 108). In the mirror of her writing, the outcomes of such idealisations are ‘pious frauds’ (p. 111), making things worse.
What Price Utopia? is a collection of twenty-five occasional essays dated between 1988 and 2007. One third were contributions to the Chronicle of Higher Education; others were produced for journals like Academe, Academic Questions, Gender Issues, Human Rights Review, or newsletters like the Women's Freedom Network Newsletter, or were published in topical essay collections, like the Handbook of Feminist Research edited by Sharlene Nagy Hesse-Biber for Sage in 2006. Only one essay is entirely new in this volume: ‘MacKinnon as Bully’ details the lengthy process of legal preliminaries in 2003–2004 around Catharine A. MacKinnon's threatened lawsuit against Patai for allegedly mischaracterising the argument of MacKinnon's work on intercourse and rape.
As a whole, the collection provides the reader with the detailed work process that underpinned the production of the two notable books cited above, including numerous exchanges on WMST-L, the women's studies email list. The selection and organisation of these essays, however, also embeds an integrated double narrative. The first, through occasional remarks scattered throughout the text, delineates the changes and growth of the author's mind as her journey leads her to deconstruct the house of feminism that she herself had helped to build as a committed feminist academic, working in the fields of utopian literature, women's studies and Latin American studies. With distress, and the restrained irony of a scholar who eventually came to be assaulted as an ‘anti-feminist supporter of white male supremacists’ (p. 68), Patai lists herself among a generation which had caricatured the Western tradition as the ‘ethnocentric’, ‘Eurocentric’ work of ‘dead white men’, and which had attacked the view that science and reason are the foundations of a good life as mere prejudices of a bankrupt Enlightenment project (pp. 159–60). The reader also comes into contact with Patai's growing allergies to the Left, as in ‘Speak Freely, Professor − Within the Speech Code’, where she notes with disappointment the Left's ambivalence about academic freedom and protests the advocacy of politically correct censorship (p. 216). At the dark end of this arc of remorse, in ‘Letter to a Friend: On Islamic Fundamentalism’ (2006–2007), Patai confronts the threatening politics of radical Islam and her milieu's reluctance to defend Western values, and raises ‘the possibility that we are watching our society commit suicide, with “the best and the brightest” lighting the way’ (p. 68).
This first embedded narrative has both autobiographical and intellectual interest, as it resonates with major issues still completely unresolved in the so-called ‘progressive’ alignment. It connects intrinsically with the sharpening attention of Patai's work to legal or paralegal matters, evident in the emphasis that the subtitle of this volume places on ideological policing, and also evident in the new subtitle to the revised edition in 2003 of Professing Feminism: Education and Indoctrination in Women's Studies. On this account, indoctrination and policing, the control of minds and expressions through education, re-education, propaganda, speech codes and penal codes, can be seen as the Orwellian side of contemporary feminism's quarter-century-long drive to institutionalise its utopian mission in what amounts to a dystopian ensemble of university policies, and judicial and quasi-judicial regulations.
Although the issues ramify to wider social and legal systems, Patai keeps her focus on the ‘sexual harassment industry’ (pp. 94, 168, 170) that developed in the academic arena in the form of a variety of illiberal control programmes operated by ‘feminist activists, lawyers, counselors, trainers, policy advisors, and enforcement officers’ whose mission was to ‘micromanage men's behavior and attitudes and to promote women's “comfort”' (p. 168), and whose targets were frequently (previously protected) speech acts that offended the ever-evolving ensemble of feminist norms.Footnote 1 In ‘There Ought to Be a Law’, ‘Women on Top’ and shorter pieces, Patai returns again and again to these unsavoury regulatory developments. These aspects of her concerns may be of particular interest to readers of the IJLC. So too may be her vigorous disagreement with the ‘critical legal studies’ argument on behalf of exercising double standards in the constitutional protection of speech rights and freedoms for different groups according to their identities (pp. 4–5). In a dissenting view, in the essay on ‘Academic Affairs’, where Patai's reading of Philip Roth, Nicholas Delbanco, Francine Prose and Eric Tarloff offers a particularly fine counterpoint to the inhumane narrowness of the argument for regulation and its damaging implementation, Patai ultimately announces a fragile reason for hope (p. 247), supported by the examples of how novelists deal with sex, lust, asymmetrical relations and other forms of human expression and complexity scorned by censors and regulators.
The second embedded narrative implicitly permeating the volume connects the discussion of feminist goals and practices with what Patai presents as a fundamental, underlying concern about the academy. Underpinning the pervasive policing is the pervasive politicisation of education, which defines the mission of feminist (and, Patai argues, also ‘post-modernist’) teaching and scholarship, directs their strategies, and regulates their activities. The major essays, from ‘Feminism and the Future’ (1995) to ‘Feminist Pedagogy Reconsidered’ (2006), reveal the presence of this concern as a central issue. The last essay in What Price Utopia? is devoted to the project of Theory's Empire: An Anthology of Dissent (2005), the collection of scholarly essays that she co-edited with Will H. Corral. Theory's Empire was designed to challenge the pre-eminence of politicised scholarship in literary studies (flying under the flag of ‘Theory’).
In ‘Feminist Pedagogy Reconsidered’, Patai calls into question a pedagogic innovation which she construes as a nasty mixture of three elements: identity theory, the post-modern destabilisation of identity and a political opportunism which guides the strategic shifting of ground between the two in service of political objectives. In ‘On Writing Theory's Empire’, Patai draws material from humanist colleagues who lament the vogue of theory: the attachment to fashionable ‘designer’ theorists, the pose of political radicalism at some remove from fact and scholarship, and the promotion of protocols of literary discourse which highlight uncertainty, indeterminacy, relativity of meaning, situatedness of value, standpoint epistemology, or intertextuality and contextualization, often performed with an eye on non-literary goals, at the expense of the love of literature and scrupulous scholarship.
Here, Patai's critique of the advocacy scholarship practised in women's studies programmes, using the university as a ‘political staging ground’ (p. 93) converges with her critique of what she presents as objectionable literary practices that foreground theory to such an extent that the objects under study disappear from view. Patai champions the values of truth, rationality and objectivity in scholarship, and finds these jettisoned, violated or crushed by what she sees as, in effect, the deliberate prioritisation of anti-authoritarian methodological scepticism in the humanist academy, in both feminist pedagogy and speculative theory, politically deployed against existing or inherited social, gender or literary norms and authorities. In this regard, Patai attacks ‘social constructionism’ (pp. 4, 6, 49, 161, 256–57), which she takes to be the underlying premise of both feminist advocacy and post-modern deconstruction, as tantamount to undermining logic, empirical evidence, rational scholarly inquiry and even ‘reason as a characteristic of the species’ (p. 4). If I may offer a small variation in an otherwise sympathetic review, I would note that many readers may feel uneasy with the sharpness of Patai's agonistic formulation.
On the one side, there is no shortage of evidence of a malaise in the academy which haunts the energetic burgeoning of critical methods the primary commitment of which is not to the objects of study − at least, not in the traditional way. In any event, the politicisation and theorisation of humanist study have in common an abstraction from the object (indeed, frequently from the subject as well), and its over-determination by schemata that are external to it and prior to it. In this respect, both lend themselves readily to the propagation of particular doctrines, which is one of Patai's concerns. Inasmuch as the dividing line between education and indoctrination is a fundamental issue for liberal education, and inasmuch as where we draw the line that defines the boundary between these will impact deeply on the kind of academy and the kind of culture that we find acceptable, Patai is addressing questions that are not only central to the utopian/dystopian tradition, with its idealised schematics, but are also properly urgent to address today − for the sake of pedagogy, education, scholarship and the place of the university in contemporary culture and society.
Patai is right, moreover, that recent turns in humanities education will not accomplish the job of classical literary scholarship and will not measure up to its expectations. This would be true even if so much of what she describes as going on were not actually sub-intellectual. On the other side, however, a large volume of high-quality work has in fact been produced by academics energised by the new approaches to knowledge over the past several decades, including work emblematic of widely divergent models for ‘post-modern’ inquiry, to some extent called into being by a certain exhaustion of traditional inquiry in the humanities and social sciences. The job of literary scholarship, and the corresponding standards of value, themselves appear to be undergoing re-articulation.
It would seem that, from Patai's point of view, the conflict in which she is taking sides is an epistemological conflict between truth and falsehood, between reason and the dangerous substitution of political values, identities and interests in place of reason. However, from the points of view of post-Kantian, rhetorical, performative or pragmatist theories of knowledge, the conflict in which Patai is taking sides may well look like a methodological conflict for which there could not be an ultimate referee. Framed this way, her readers may find that her stories and anecdotes are indeed convincing, her arguments have merit, and her humanism is compelling, but also that her conclusions rest on a particular approach to which it would be premature, if not actually problematic, for everyone to (re)turn. It is, therefore, not taking away anything from the value of Patai's criticism of particular acts and purposes of feminism, political activism, theoreticism, or anti-intellectualism to want to suspend judgment about how the currents swirling in the academy should settle their accounts.
For anyone who has been a participant or an attentive observer of the academic culture wars of the last couple of decades, or who has kept up with the development of Patai's work from Professing Feminism to Theory's Empire, this book will contain few surprises. It would be good to have a current, statistically reliable picture, for example, of whether women's studies and identity-based activism in the academy are still on the rise or now on the wane, particularly as cultural priorities shake out under the pressures of economic trouble. Writing as recently as four years ago, Patai sees no sign of decline as yet (p. 287). Are the circles of feminism, or theory, for that matter, still widening, and do academics within these circles have credibility outside? Do the institutionalised regulatory codes of the last generation, or the speculative paradigms of recent theory, continue to hold sway, or are they becoming vulnerable to disuse or challenge by new generations?
The book does not do everything; nor can it be expected to. The essays we have in What Price of Utopia? stand up well and are very readable; as an ensemble, the volume provides a comprehensive and interesting picture of Patai's work, and an excellent overview for new readers. In sum, the book offers lively examples, intelligent analyses, courageous, well-reasoned, humane arguments, and the calm, wit and charm of a mature scholarly and intellectual voice.
