Lisa Urkevich has written an impressive introductory source for those who wish to explore the musical genres of the Arabian Peninsula. The book is based on the author's fieldwork and personal experiences, and presented in a semi-textbook format for wider readership. Written in an approachable language, one may simply turn to any specific chapter of interest. The book is based on specific communities, Bedouin, urban dwellers, and seafarers, and includes music performed by women as well. It contains a useful core of readings, commentary, images, lyrics, musical examples in the accompanying CD, a helpful glossary, and covers sizable geo-musical areas. Music and Traditions of the Arabian Peninsula is divided into two parts: Part I: The Najd and Upper Gulf Region, and Part II: The Hijaz and Southwest Region. Each chapter contains a brief background section and several recorded musical examples followed by detailed information about specific genres, performance practices, context, rhythms and sung poetry, typically in nabati, the vernacular poetic expression typical of Bedouin communities. The introductory chapter outlines how the book is organized in terms of the musical connections, similarities, and influences.
The author articulates how the term “traditional” in no way suggests that the musical practices or dances discussed in the book are obsolete. A distinction that kept reoccurring throughout the book is to show how musical practices often move freely between various genres and settings, and constantly evolve within the realms of Gulf societies. The accompanying CD contains 31 musical examples, and each chapter contains references to other recordings that can be obtained or purchased separately. Although discussions seem to be Saudi-centric, the examples are contextualized and supported with useful analysis of the musical forms and structures. The author purposely focuses on folk and traditional urban musical forms rather than the commercial, but often refers to certain musical practices and genres that evolve in the public sphere and impact current commercial trends.
While many of these chapters can be read on their own by a student or researcher already familiar with the basic literature of music in the Middle East, the many cross references to genres and practices means that a student with no previous exposure to this music could struggle to comprehend Urkevich's work. This may leave readers somewhat confused and potentially miss the particularities of each individual genre. Also, given the fact that Urkevich touches upon so many genres over a widely diverse region, additional recorded selections would have been helpful. In this regard, some chapters were more successful than others. Chapter 9, for example, didn't have any audio examples, which left this important portion of the book without aural support. The author mentioned at the end of the chapter that more audio tracks could be found in a previously published CD (2004).
While the recorded examples and rhythmic transcriptions were indeed helpful, due to the vocal orientation of the music I believe it would have been necessary (and of tremendous help to readers and researchers alike) to include melodic transcriptions. Apart from the children's song on page 119, none of the songs are transcribed melodically. In Chapter 6, the author uses an example from the art of najdi/raddadi (call and response from influenced by the region of Najd in Saudi Arabia), track 8. The audio track seems to have some arpeggios, harmonies, a bass line, and vocal harmonies. Given the context, I was hoping for the author to say a few words about her selection of this modernized version of the genre, and potentially include associated transcriptions.
Since general and encompassing approaches do not always provide in-depth anthropological narratives, some of Urkevich's claims were left unsupported or fell short of full description. An example of this occurs in two statements: one on pages 232–4 about the origins of maqamat (system of melodic modes) and their structure and influences; and the second on page 220 on the claim that the musical life of Mecca and Medina rivaled or surpassed those of Cairo, Damascus, and Baghdad. Although it is indeed true that much older versions of maqamat existed early on in the Peninsula and that the two cities were indeed vibrant cultural centers, these statements are controversial and not founded on sufficient historical evidence. Also, in the introduction Urkevich argues that the Islamic Awakening movement (Sahwa movement in Saudi Arabia) was spurred by oil wealth, urban expansion, and the decrease in semi-private “space.” This is partially true, given that the region was directly impacted by other events that instigated the Awakening movement such as the Arab defeat in the 1967 Six-Day War and the subsequent failure of a pan-Arab ideology. In fact, the ramifications of the energy crisis of 1973 increased the wealth of petroleum producing countries exponentially, subsequently offering Saudis the means to expand the Islamic Awakening movement locally and globally. In illustrating the region's vast geographic and cultural diversity of styles and contexts, Urkevich may want to explore how musicians and performers in modern contexts negotiate issues of cultural policy, geopolitics, and identity.
The book would serve as a good foundation for a two- or three-semester course, however, instructors of ethnomusicology may want to offer additional listening and reading assignments, in-class demonstrations, concert attendance, transcriptions, in-depth analysis of melodies, and films to fill out and enrich the course material.
