The 1996 Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC) Directive remains, more than ten years after its creation, one of the cornerstones of EU environmental law. In short, the Directive sets up a system of applications and permits for a long list of industrial activities, with the aim of reducing emission to air, water and land from such activities. In 2008, the Directive was codified as a result of subsequent changes.
Notwithstanding the fact that the IPPC Directive is, as a regulatory instrument, interesting enough in itself, Implementing EU Pollution Control: Law and Integration, by Bettina Lange, is about much more than just the Directive. This book sets out to examine the role that law plays in facilitating EU integration. In this venture, the IPPC Directive serves as a case-study. More specifically, the promulgation of so-called best available technique (BAT) norms, which form a central part of the Directive, is examined in detail in order to assess the role of law in facilitating integration in the EU. Moreover, the subsequent implementation and application of such BAT norms at Member State level is examined (Lange focuses on the UK and Germany for these purposes).
From the outset, it is evident that this book is very well written, thoroughly researched and well thought through. Although it spans rather wide in dealing with the IPPC Directive and integration in the EU – in the process relying on socio-legal and law in action approaches, while touching upon issues of enforcement of national environmental law and cost/benefit as well as legal theory – the book is concise yet clear, and Lange shows an admirable command of a wide range of disciplines.
In Chapters 1 and 2, Lange sets out the premise of the book. Here she deals with the role that law might play in EU integration. Moreover, Lange explains the central approach followed throughout the book, namely that in assessing the role of law in integration, focusing merely on traditional perceptions of law, or ‘law in the books’ as Lange refers to it, is a mistake. Instead, Lange advocates a ‘law in action’ approach, which sees law in the context of the technical, political and economic discourses through which it is applied. Lange makes a strong case for such an approach which, as we will see later, turns out to be more than apt to the IPPC Directive and its reliance on BAT. This is contrasted with traditional conceptions of law in EU action, which, in Lange’s eyes, rely on rationalist perspectives of favouring a state emphasis while maintaining an instrumental bend. It is in part these ideas which Lange sets out to challenge through her empirical research into the promulgation and application of BAT norms under the IPPC Directive. In so doing, Lange both relies on and criticises the works of Teubner, Parsons and Tamanaha in a masterly fashion.
In Chapter 3, Lange discusses critical perspectives towards the role of law in EU integration more generally. Here Lange relies on a constructivist approach which is not only less state-centred but also moves away from official legal actors, instead emphasising interactions between a wider range of social actors such as, for instance, private individuals, industry associations and scientists (with reference to the way in which a series of non-legal actors have gained significant input in EU law through the comitology procedure). Interestingly, in an attempt to challenge the notion that law really does lead to integration, Lange ponders what is actually meant by ‘EU integration’. In this analysis, she points out that, at the EU level, law may equally lead to disintegration, as for instance witnessed where Member State opt-outs are facilitated through law.
In Chapter 4, Lange addresses the question of what is actually meant by ‘EU law in action’. She points out that ‘law in action’ is best understood with reference to a social connection and suggests that discourse theory may help shed light on this. Lange argues that traditional ‘law in action’ research, in its criticism of black letter law, has often itself reified the definition of ‘social’. More to the point, Lange argues that the implementation of the IPPC Directive and its debates on what constitutes BAT, with input from numerous actors, represents a good example of a discourse-based approach. In addition, Lange examines the role of power in such discourses, relying on Foucault’s work. While this reviewer remains somewhat sceptical about the utility of some of Foucault’s work, Lange aptly uses it as a springboard for the next, empirical, part of the book.
Thus, in Chapter 5, Lange analyses the political discourse of deciding what constitutes BAT in the drafting of so-called Best Available Technique Reference Documents (BREFs), which are produced by the European IPPC Bureau. In essence, the European IPPC Bureau was set up to exchange information about BAT techniques between Member States and industrial actors. Despite the rather technical and bureaucratic nature of this chapter, it is, at least to this reviewer, one of the most interesting parts of the book. Lange skilfully manages to uncover the often intricate and tactical games which are played when Member States, industry and trade associations get together to try to decide what actually constitutes BAT. For instance, in this chapter, which is based on interviews with the relevant parties, Lange portrays the way in which the division between industry representations and authors of BREF reports can become strained due to conflicts between political and technical discourses, as some industry inputs are, in the eyes of the technocrat, seen as overly political, leaving the technocrat with the job of ‘cutting out the crap’ (p. 128). Not surprisingly, Lange observes that control of information, which may itself have power implications, is central to determining BAT. More worrying perhaps is Lange’s observation that there is no one procedure for determining BAT and that it is, at times, difficult to identify who actually decides what constitutes BAT.
If Lange’s main focus on a discourse-based ‘law in action’ becomes stronger and more persuasive during the portrait of the intricate nature of BAT determination and BREF writing painted in Chapter 5, this is even more so as one progresses through Chapter 6. Chapter 6 focuses on ‘open’ and ‘closed’ BAT norms, ‘open’ BAT norms being where no final definition is made in the applicable documents thereby leaving some leeway for application, and ‘closed’ BAT norms being altogether more definitive in that they prescribe a particular pollution abatement measure. Thus, Lange describes how certain applications of BAT standards at UK level are ‘open’, in that the Environment Agency considers certain BAT requirements flexibly as more of a long-term target. While this may be sound practice, it further underlines the strong role that discourses, in this case those of domestic agencies and actors, play in defining legal BAT standards. Added to this is the traditional UK approach to enforcement of environmental law which is overall less confrontational than other European countries at least, preferring amicable solutions to, for instance, court enforcement. Lange’s work in general and her emphasis on ‘open’ norms in particular to some extent echo findings from the work on legal pluralism (see Tamanaha, Reference Tamanaha2001, pp. 116–17) in that they question the perception of BAT standards as prescriptive, ‘hard law’, norms. In this light, Lange argues that these findings challenge traditional ideas of EU law as being only ‘formal law in the books’. Although this is a matter on which this reviewer, as an environmental lawyer, is not qualified to comment, it is evident that Lange’s research has made a very strong case for such a challenge.
The final chapters of the book examine the role of costs in relation to BAT decisions for both specific installations and whole sectors (Chapter 7) and further develop the role of law in integration through an examination of licensing for coke ovens in Germany and the UK (Chapter 8). In particular, Chapter 7 adds to the overall discourse argument, through an economic discourse, while highlighting some interesting aspects of the role that cost considerations play in relation to BAT. For instance, Lange finds that cost considerations are multifaceted in that they feature at numerous stages: both when deciding BREF norms, where trade associations and industry actors often put forward arguments about costs, and at the implementation and enforcement stages, where regulatory authorities occasionally rely on cost considerations out of empathy with industry, as a result of high levels of competition from other markets in what perhaps resembles ‘capture theory’ (Posner, Reference Posner1974). As a neat rounding off, Chapter 8 considers the way in which the licensing of coke ovens under the IPPC Directive represents an example where the many economic, political and technical discourses play out, further challenging the perception that a strict law-only focus on integration is sustainable. Instead, Lange argues that the economic, political and technical discourses are embedded in the law.
While this book has been reviewed here mainly through the eyes of an environmental lawyer, this reviewer is confident that the book has wider application and relevance. Its critical approach to the role of law in EU integration ought to make it relevant for EU lawyers. Moreover, the author’s powerful command and knowledge of legal and sociological theory and strong socio-legal analysis should secure this book a place on the shelves of non-lawyers as well. Although critics might be hesitant to put too much emphasis on an examination of the IPPC Directive and its implementation in only two Member States, the sheer quality and rigour of the book leaves this reviewer with the firm impression that Lange has put forward a very strong argument for her critical approach to the role of law in integration.
