This attractively produced book, with a cover of an early sixteenth-century representation of the economic Trinity, has as its ostensive purpose the tracing of the effect of Hellenism upon the trinitarian theology of Basil. The first chapter is particularly helpful, offering as it does an account of the problem of assessing Basil's attitude in general. Despite Basil's Address to Young Men, it is hard to date the work and even harder to decide how far this moderately positive approach to Hellenism entered deeply into Basil's whole vision. Other writings, like letter 223/2, as Hildebrand points out, manifest a barely concealed contempt for classical learning. The underlying tension, as distinct from the actual practice, is illustrated in his first homily In Hexaemeron.
The remainder of the work is devoted to exploring in great detail how far Basil employs Greek learning in his defence of the doctrine of the Trinity, more precisely of the full deity of the Son. The material is divided into four neatly distinguished stages in the course of which the exploration of the central theme is to take place. Stage 1 deals with the so called homoiousian years, when Basil was probably influenced by Basil of Ancyra from 360 to 365; stage 2 explores the movement from homoi to homoousios from 365 to 372; stage 3 discusses the use of prosopon for God; and in the third chapter, stage 4 deals with the emergence of the language of hypostasis between 375 and 379.
Hildebrand brings out some useful points in his account of Basil's gradual emergence as a defender of the creed of Nicaea. Above all, in encountering the views of Eunomius and his assertion that the divine nature is capable of being defined as ‘ingenerate’ – a definition which effectively excluded the Son from any share in the divine nature – Basil insists that the divine nature is beyond definition and that what we know about it is channelled by means of ejuvoiai or conceptions. This idea was apparently used in this sense for the first time in Basil's Contra Eunomium 1. 6 and 7. Another interesting point made by the author is that at the heart of Basil's approach lies his insistence less on consubtantiality of the Son with the Father than on the divine incomprehensibility, though Basil has less to say about infinity. It was left to his younger brother, Gregory of Nyssa, to exploit this idea. It is worth noting that Hildebrand has much less to say about the contributions of the other two Cappadocian Fathers and their dependence on and difference from Basil.
One particular point of view against which Basil defines his own position is his insistence, against ‘Sabellianism’ and in particular against Marcellus of Ancyra, on a flexible meaning for homousios. For Basil (see p. 80 of the book and Basil's letter 236) consubstantial means ‘like in every possible way’ rather than identical.
It is only in the final two chapters (5 and 6, pp. 150 ff.), that Hildebrand addresses the problem he set himself in the title of his book. But there he speaks more about the rhetorical movement known as Second Sophistic than about philosophical influences, and in chapter 6 he argues that Basil, in his account of the treatment of the Holy Spirit, it is the understanding of the meaning of salvation which expresses Basil's Hellenism rather, presumably, than his actual doctrinal treatment.
He had indeed argued, rather unconvincingly, that Basil's distinction of ousia and hypostasis owes more to Stoicism than, as is often assumed, to Aristotle – see the discussion on page 48 ff. and also note 31 on page 84, in this following Ritter. Ritter may be correct, but it would have helped to establish his case, and that of Hildebrand, if the actual passages from Aristotle's Categories and the relevant texts from the Stoic corpus had been exploited more fully. As it is, the argument as presented depends on secondary rather than on primary sources.
On the whole, therefore, this is a useful book, though it may disappoint those who want to know the extent to which Basil's use of Greek modes of thought actually affected less his style and his expression of the Christian moral and spiritual calling than his whole theological outlook. Again, why did Basil both defend and deplore the use of classical culture in his general outlook? Of the extent to which Basil, during his student days at Athens, may have encountered the current philosophy nothing is said.
Finally, therefore, this book is a little disappointing, in so far as it addresses on its title-page the problem of the influence of Hellenism on the trinitarian theology of Basil, but touches the central issue in a slightly unsatisfactory manner.
