Volk's Manilius and his Intellectual Background helpfully elucidates many aspects of the Astronomica. In seven chapters that focus on topics such as Manilius’ life (primarily what little we know about it), the workings of Manilius’ cosmos, the place of horoscopes in Roman society, and Manilius’ place in the philosophical and literary traditions, V. offers a well-written, intellectually rigorous, and accessible introduction to the poem and the cultural context in which it was produced. This study will surely be a fundamental point of entry for those wishing to read and study Manilius’ challenging poem about the workings of the cosmos.
Though the book is divided into coherent chapters, arguments about Manilius’ life and the production of his poem surface throughout the book. For instance, in the chapter entitled ‘Horoscopes and Emperors’, V. discusses nine passages from the poem that bear upon the question of the date of the poem, and while she herself recognizes that internal evidence for dating the poem is often ‘vague’ (160), she concludes that Manilius was an Augustan poet (139–60) writing between a.d. 9 and 14; the argument that he was an easterner writing in a non-native language is dismissed (162–3), and, reasonably enough, the Astronomica is seen as incomplete (though the suggestion that the poet may not have wanted to write anything more (171) seems rather weak). In terms of Manilius’ view of the Roman political scene, V. concludes that there is a tension between the idea that heaven determines everything on earth and the fact that, when it comes to apotheosis, earth (i.e. the Roman emperor) had been trying to control the heavens (170). However, rather than seeing Manilius as one who engages, as do other Roman poets, with the problematic discourse of apotheosis, V. is content to leave this tension as an example of self-contradiction stemming from the fact that the nature of the link between Manilius’ heaven and earth is not obvious (258). V.'s Manilius, then, is engaged in ‘politics’ to the extent that he replicates Roman paradigms of power, but where his thinking may come into conflict with those paradigms, his ‘real’ attitude towards the imperial house is not revealed. All in all, V. offers a thorough analysis of the state of fundamental questions concerning Manilius’ life, but, understandably, there is not much substantial progress in our understanding of the poet's life and circumstances. Interpreting and assessing the poet's words will remain a central task of any critic.
V.'s overall aim is to situate the poem within its intellectual background, and in this regard she is successful. The pre-Socratics, Plato, Hellenistic philosophy, Aratus, Lucretius, and others are fruitfully discussed in relation to Manilius’ poem. However, rather than discussing many of the instances in which V. excellently relates the Astronomica to the intellectual tradition, I will here focus on a larger conceptual difficulty. Many of the analyses about philosophy or philosophical schools end in abstract generalities that create uncertainty as to what to make of Manilius’ intellectual background. For example, Pythagoreanism is ‘less an influence … than an ideal’ (246); Manlius was not ‘some sort of Platonist … but rather … many details of his world view can ultimately be traced back to the thought of the man who … had become the fountainhead of subsequent Western philosophy’ (242); the extent to which Hermetic sources mattered for Manilius remains ‘unresolved’ (239); ‘it cannot be proved that Manilius really used De natura deorum’ (234). Such sober and honest assessments of the ancient texts (and of modern interpretations of them) may be of benefit (though is it surprising that Plato's conception of the cosmos was influential in antiquity?), but the fact remains that concrete points are often wanting.
By way of contrast, V. is able to demonstrate the clear importance of any number of ancient poets for the Astronomica. The Vergilian ‘conscia fati | sidera’ (Aen. 4.519–20), for example, was significantly reworked by Manilius to produce a sense of the cosmos that is alien to the Aeneid (185–6); indeed, this example of Manilius’ variation of Virgilian language clearly illustrates the brand of ‘hard’ astrology that V. sees in the Astronomica. Given the aporetic results that emerge from the discussion of philosophy and the quite different outcomes of her discussions of the poets, it seems unfortunate that more was not made of the poets and the poetic vision of astronomy. Indeed, V.'s discussion, for example, of Aratus is largely a negative one (188–9), designed to show that Aratus’ own poem may have been influential only through the extensive intermediary tradition at Rome. And while I was convinced by her demonstration that Manilius’ treatment of the Engonasin looks more generally to Roman discourse about astronomy than it looks specifically to Aratus, it seemed that the problem of Aratus at Rome is quite similar to that of the pre-Socratics or Stoic philosophy at Rome: there had been so many incarnations of the antecedent material that it may be puzzling to assess the intellectual framework and to pinpoint precise intellectual interests on Manilius’ part. Yet, V. seems quite comfortable with the indirect nature of the influence of philosophy on Manilius, but not so with poetic influence. The result is an admittedly blurry ‘history of ideas’ and ‘larger picture’ at the expense of concrete examples of intellectual history (10), which in some cases would be the relation between poetic texts. Moreover, V.'s strategy seems predicated upon her ambivalence about intertextuality, which she claims may be arbitrary (9). This is a salutary warning, but surely a view such as ‘the study of intertextuality and source criticism are … concerned with the individual — the specific intertext, the particular source — and thus tend to lose sight of the general’ (9–10) is unfair in many cases, and at the least demands a closer engagement. Indeed, terms such as ‘code’ could offer a productive, intertextual approach to think about both Aratus’ reception at Rome and the indirect tradition. A similarly rich discussion of Roman engagements with Hermetism is unlikely.
In terms of V.'s big-picture view of Manilius and his intellectual world, however, the argument is an overall success. She cogently addresses the crucial role of Greek thought, literature, and science in Roman Imperial culture, and, in turn, the transformation of that culture for Manilius’ (and, more generally, Roman) ends.
