In the present climate of political and social change in North Africa, studying music offers exciting new possibilities for enhancing our understanding of the region. Scholars in ethnomusicology and related disciplines are conducting archival and ethnographic research on music, often integrating sound and video recordings, transcriptions, and musical and textual analysis into their studies. Their work highlights how music not only reflects cultural change but also predicts and creates it.
Many foundational studies in this field focused on Andalusian classical music genres or on sacred music practices and oral traditions in rural regions. More recent scholarship on Andalusian genres has offered careful examinations of the relationship between colonialism, nationalism, and music. Much of this work reveals how music has played an important role in the construction of national identity and how studying music—particularly when oral traditions have adapted written notation and theoretical systems—opens onto questions about modernity, authenticity, and heritage preservation. These studies have also demonstrated how encounters with colonialism, and values connected to genealogy and oral transmission, have been reconsidered and readapted in the 21st century.Footnote 1 Current research on sacred music continues to investigate the permissibility of music and the politics of listening in Islamic cultures, the status of music and musicians in different historical and geographical contexts, the role of music in various Sufi practices, and rituals involving trance, possession, and healing.Footnote 2 Such research has demonstrated the importance of spiritual practices involving “sound-art expression” (not always described as “music”) for many North Africans.Footnote 3
Research on music and gender in North Africa has shed new light on questions of honor, shame, and the gendering of public and private space. Although many female performers have been socially marginalized, several studies have illustrated how certain musicians challenge social assumptions and stereotypes about gender in North Africa. Much of this scholarship adds to broader research on gender by examining how participants can affirm and subvert social norms in performance; by exploring the relationship between music and sexuality; and by investigating the identification of certain performers as symbols of regional and national identity or as bearers of cultural memory.Footnote 4
Musical studies in North Africa have also highlighted how constructions of ethnic or linguistic identity are articulated through music. Music performances have offered some Berber communities the opportunity to fashion their cultural identity, assert their linguistic identity in national and global political contexts, and connect with diaspora communities.Footnote 5 In many cases, aesthetic values attached to musical techniques serve to differentiate social groups. But while music can serve as a marker of otherness, it can also become a site of encounter for different groups, beliefs, and aesthetics.Footnote 6 Many studies of Jewish music and musicians explore the connections between Jewish and Muslim musical practices in North Africa and the diaspora, including the important roles Jewish musicians played in North African music scenes during the early 20th century.Footnote 7 Researchers studying healing trance musics such as Stambeli in Tunisia and Gnawa in Morocco have joined a larger scholarly movement examining connections across the Sahara and challenging the division of North and Sub-Saharan Africa as separate areas of study.
Many researchers have also examined how spiritual or folk musics are increasingly taken out of their ritual or local contexts as they are performed on festival stages and/or marketed as world music. Such scholarship contributes to discussions of hybridity, syncretism, and identity in North Africa and in diaspora communities, raising important questions about representation, circulation, and power. Along with careful studies of transnational music practices, including collaborations between North African and European musicians, this literature encourages new ways of thinking about “world music.”Footnote 8 An overlapping area of research focuses on new media technologies and popular music, including genres such as rai, shaʿbī, mizwid, hip hop, rap, rock, and heavy metal. These scholars have similarly examined issues relating to transnationalism while highlighting the local struggles of marginalized populations such as unemployed youth. Such work has investigated how these popular music genres have often been denigrated by local elites, in part because they incorporate specific linguistic registers and aesthetic techniques as well as political dissent and socially taboo topics.Footnote 9
Yet more research is needed on popular music, including emerging practices associated with the Arab Spring. Scholars have started to address the overlapping trajectories of music, youth, and new media technologies in these social protests, including the work of politically engaged artists and the effects of censorship. Music researchers could also investigate the nuanced relationships between music, religion, and politics so as reevaluate previous conceptual frameworks, and they could explore how changing cultural policies might lead to a decentralization of musical activities, education, and scholarship. To this end we might ask: what is the role of music and musicians in creating more democratic societies, and how can musicians and music scholars contribute to reconsidering histories of nationalism, politics, and power in North Africa?
The present climate could open new frontiers for music research, because scholars in North Africa might have greater opportunities to study topics that were previously neglected or considered taboo. Scholars in Tunisia, for example, have expressed a need for more research on regional folk musics, new policies on intellectual property, and improved access to the national television and radio archives. Tunisian musicologists are contributing to a broader fluorescence of vibrant scholarly activity, holding regular meetings and recently creating doctoral studies for musicology in Tunis. This will certainly affect the future of North African music scholarship. Other current lacunae in this field include studies of music in Libya and the relationships between music and other performing arts, especially dance, across the region.
Research on music in North Africa could be developed by increasing the opportunities for collaboration among researchers across disciplines and regions. While Tunisian musicologists have called for more dialogue with Arabic-speaking scholars in the Middle East and North Africa, there is also a need for translating scholarly works to and from Arabic and other local languages. In addition, scholars could work more on dialogic ethnographies and collaborative writing projects, raising important questions of ethics, power, and knowledge. Finally, echoing Jonathan Shannon's contribution to this roundtable, more scholars from other disciplines could join music researchers in focusing on the sounds of North Africa as a primary method for discovering new insights about the region.
