This is an ideal textbook for those pursuing Latin American studies and wishing to understand the developments of the region since the debt crisis of the 1980s. It explores the rise of the neoliberal economic policies of the so-called Washington Consensus as well as their subsequent contestation and the rise of centre-left and left-wing governments at the turn of the century. While discussing the commonalities of the linkages between the economic reforms and the political changes for the region as a whole, Francisco Panizza also emphasises the particularities of individual countries. The country analysis focuses mainly on Argentina, Brazil, Mexico, Venezuela, Uruguay, Peru, Ecuador, Bolivia and Chile. This is a well-argued and nuanced text which stands out for its questioning of several assumptions and dogmatic statements about the transformations that have taken place in the region over the last three decades. Perhaps this is because Panizza is not wedded to one particular theoretical perspective and holds an open-minded and balanced approach to contentious issues. He shows great respect for the reader in trying not to impose a particular viewpoint but always arguing his case carefully. This book was ten years in the making, and is the outcome of Panizza's teaching on democracy and development at the London School of Economics and Political Science. Panizza dedicates the book to his students, which I find notable in view of the downgrading of teaching in comparison to research over the last few decades in many British universities. In turn, I know from a close source that students regard his teaching very highly and are much inspired by it.
It is often argued that the shift in the 1980s from state-led development strategies to neoliberal or free market development strategies was imposed by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. While the international financial institutions undoubtedly promoted neoliberal policies aggressively, Panizza argues that several democratic governments embraced, to a greater or lesser extent, such prescriptions. Furthermore, the ascent of free market economics had a remarkable degree of popular support, at least at the beginning, when the debt crisis and hyperinflation affected many countries in the region and neoliberal policies managed to stabilise those economies. Panizza's analysis reveals the social bases of support for neoliberal policies and how these arose mainly within a formally democratic context. The author is careful to stress the complex politics underlying these processes, involving negotiation, compromise, resistance and agreement by social forces within the country as well as with external agents. The main exception is, of course, Chile, where neoliberal policies were imposed by the Pinochet dictatorship. Even in this case, however, social and political forces cannot be completely ignored – Chile had already pioneered free market reforms in the mid-1970s and implemented them in a most comprehensive manner.
Panizza interestingly discusses the emergence of the Washington Consensus and the role played by its ‘organic intellectuals’, but surprisingly he does not explore the specific influence that neoliberal ‘organic intellectuals’ from the region might have had on its emergence and, in particular, on its implementation. Several institutions, think-tanks and ‘technopols’ in the region were already espousing such ideas before the Washington Consensus emerged. The book would have benefited from including such an analysis, especially of the Chicago Boys in Chile, by using, for example, the detailed study of Chilean economists by Juan Gabriel Valdés. As Panizza points out, it is indeed an ironic twist that the free market neoliberals introduced more radical structural changes, although in the opposite direction, than the ‘structuralists’ who promoted the state-led developmentalist agenda of the 1950s and 1960s.
Panizza discusses how the expectations raised by the democratic transition and the Washington Consensus remained unfulfilled. The class structure became more polarised, income inequalities and poverty increased, working conditions deteriorated with the shift from stable to casual employment, and social conditions worsened. The increasing contestation of the neoliberal model and the demands for a more inclusive democracy led to the post-Washington Consensus and, in several countries, eventually to the election of left-wing and centre-left governments, starting in 1998 with Hugo Chávez in Venezuela and followed by Brazil, Chile, Argentina, Bolivia, Uruguay, Ecuador, Guatemala, Paraguay and El Salvador. Besides worsening socio-economic conditions, other factors must be considered when explaining the political revival of the Left. It might come as a surprise to readers to learn that, according to Panizza, this turn to left-of-centre governments does not mean that people have significantly shifted to the left or embraced the socialist cause.
The author notes the social democratisation of the parties of the Left, especially in Uruguay, Brazil and Chile, and mentions several contributing factors, among them political learning. Left-wing parties had learned lessons from their past mistakes, electoral defeats, the traumatic events of the dictatorships, the abuse of human rights, the dangers of political radicalism, the collapse of ‘real existing socialism’ in the former communist countries of Eastern Europe, and so on, and this led to a new evaluation of ‘bourgeois’ democracy, to pragmatism, and to a politics of consensus instead of confrontation. This shift to the centre by formerly radical left-wing parties facilitated their electoral victory, which, of course, also had its costs. In my view, this term, ‘political learning’, has explanatory value, and it would be good to see Panizza and other political scientists develop it further (although the index is very comprehensive, it does not include this promising term). In this context, Panizza makes an interesting contrast between Chávez's Venezuela, which he characterises as the politics of polarisation, and Lula da Silva's Brazil, which he refers to as the politics of accommodation.
In an intriguing chapter, Panizza traces the development of the post-Washington Consensus, the ‘second generation’ reforms, and how the World Bank has skilfully adopted a new rhetoric incorporating signifiers of progressive political discourse such as ‘empowerment’, ‘pro-poor’, ‘participation’, ‘the voice of the poor and marginalised’, ‘equitable development’, ‘socially inclusive’ and ‘institutions matter’. He contrasts this new World Bank discourse with that of the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, whose discourse has also changed, but from structuralist or developmentalist to neo-structuralist or neo-developmentalist. The discussion of the contrast is rather thin, however, and the analysis of the neo-structuralist perspective could have been developed further, especially as it influenced the policies of several left-of-centre governments.
The book ends on a cautious and sceptical note as Panizza is unsure whether the left-of-centre governments are able to deliver equitable development as well as deepening the process of democratisation and hence become a sustainable alternative to neoliberalism. In short, I strongly recommend this outstanding book to all those interested in the political economy of contemporary Latin America.
