Unless ranch-raised, most people make little, if any, distinction between a cowboy and a rancher, but the difference is pronounced, and it is fundamental. The rancher is the cattleman, the capitalist businessman who (by himself or with a loan from the bank) owns the land and the livestock. Much as he might love the land, his main concern is, must be, profitability. The chief concern of the cowboy, on the other hand, is the lifestyle. He might also love the land, but he loves being on horseback working with cattle more. The skills required to handle cattle, master the art of the lariat, or train a cowhorse are much more important to him than his pittance of a salary.
Some cowboys become ranchers and either evolve out of their cowboyness or else retain their cowboy skills and indulge them as necessary. Conversely, many who start as ranchers, not as cowboys, never acquire, or even aspire to, the skilled roping and riding techniques of the cowboy. Exceptions can always be found to these generalizations, but there is no doubt that cowboys and cattlemen have from the beginning occupied discrete and distinctive niches in the world of ranching.
Jacqueline Moore's book thoroughly examines these niches through what she calls the “new prism” of manhood, a term that both distinguishes men from boys and also “defines the qualities of being a man,” that is, differences in the meaning of manliness. Through this prism she examines the different meanings of “manly” as viewed by cowboys and cattlemen, and she points out how these differences helped to maintain social hierarchies. Moore's premise, as exemplified in her title, is that in terms of social maturity the ranchers are men whereas their employees are boys.
The task of determining what is manly is not an easy one, for the term is nebulous and greatly dependent on how gender roles have been seen by different cultures and at different times. The survival needs of nomadic hunter-gatherers require physical actions that are seen as brutal and cruel by civilized standards, which value business acumen or intellectual prowess over physical force. In the ranching world that developed on the Great Plains in the nineteenth century, certainly the physical hardships faced by the mounted men who herded or drove cattle on the open range required courage and endurance of a different kind than was needed by the cattlemen whose world was populated by the wolves of financiers, market men, and lawyers.
Cow Boys and Cattle Men is laid out in two parts, corresponding to the activities of work and of leisure involved in the cattle business. Moore's strength, and it is a great one, is her extensive and thorough research and the impressive detail of the myriad examples she supplies in support of her thesis. Moore acknowledges the inherent problem of credibility in her heavy reliance on first-hand accounts, although her credulity is occasionally apparent. Maturity, or the lack thereof, is an important distinction; the cowboy attitude toward life seems inherently less mature than that of the cattleman. On the whole, however, Moore's theoretical framework of masculinity is less relevant (and even somewhat annoying) compared to the role of social class in distinguishing between cowboys and cattlemen.
Several factors, varying in their degree of seriousness, interfere with the usefulness of this book. Good editing and proofreading would have caught and corrected the many typos and grammatical errors: run-on sentences, singular nouns that should be plural (such as steer for steers), and misused words (reticence for reluctance, for example). Greater familiarity with the vernacular of ranch work would have resulted in the consistent use of “bronc,” not “bronco.” Moreover, there is no such thing as an “old heifer”; a heifer, by definition, is a young cow that has not had a calf. Other errors show a lack of historical knowledge. Milo was developed in the twentieth century and would not have been available as cattle feed in the nineteenth century. Also, the Santa Gertrudis breed of cattle for which the King Ranch (established in 1852) is justly famous was not developed by ranch founder Richard King by cross-breeding “Indian Brahman bulls with Texas longhorn cattle.” Rather, the breed was created in the twentieth century by crossing Brahmans with English Shorthorns.
The above problems, although distracting, do not detract from the overall value of the book, but the lack of a bibliography is more egregious. One of the most useful tools for both serious scholars and general readers is a bibliography, especially where the author has done such an admirable job of locating and citing sources. Such an omission mars what is otherwise a solid, well researched, and useful study.
