No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
The 11 September 2001 attacks and subsequent events brought not only almost daily coverage of Islam in newspapers and magazines throughout the world but also a continuous flow of scholarly books and articles about Islam in the world. One of the main issues, not surprisingly, is the position of Muslims in the United States and Europe. Muslims in the West, by Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh, fits within this category. Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh, a scholar of Islamic law based at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland, analyzes the position of Muslims in Swiss society (numbering a little more than 150,000 in a total Swiss population of almost 7 million).
The 11 September 2001 attacks and subsequent events brought not only almost daily coverage of Islam in newspapers and magazines throughout the world but also a continuous flow of scholarly books and articles about Islam in the world. One of the main issues, not surprisingly, is the position of Muslims in the United States and Europe. Muslims in the West, by Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh, fits within this category. Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh, a scholar of Islamic law based at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland, analyzes the position of Muslims in Swiss society (numbering a little more than 150,000 in a total Swiss population of almost 7 million).
The book starts with an analysis of Islamic theological sources concerning the position of Muslims living outside the so-called dār al-Islām (land of Islam), the area where Islam is the dominant religion—or, rather, where rulers rule according to Islamic principles. The author argues that according to classical Islamic sources, living outside the dār al-Islām poses a problem for a Muslim because it implies living in dār al-Kufr (land of the infidels). Muslims have to cope with a variety of problems and dilemmas implicit in living in a non–Islamic society. There are roughly two strategies to cope with such problems. One is to strive to turn the host country into part of dār al-Islām; the other is avoiding dār al-Kufr as much as possible. Since this is often impossible in practice, Muslims have to create an “autonomous Islamic space.” This is in itself not a new theme: dozens of publications, mainly by Islamic scholars, address this issue. These publications often contain a message to host societies: give Muslims a certain degree of religious autonomy so they can live according to their faith as much as possible. The message of Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh is also addressed to host societies, but it is of a very different nature: “This is a new problematic challenge to the separation of Church and State. The current and increasing presence of Muslims in non–Muslim countries does not satisfy Muslims themselves, who live constantly in a conflict between their religious norms and national norms. Nor does it please host countries that do not know how to integrate them, without endangering secularism and faith diversity. The separation of Church and State as a principle is opposed to the ultimate aim of the Muslim…. [O]ne cannot be very optimistic when considering Christian and Muslim communities in the Balkans who, after having cohabited for centuries, remain separate” (p. 64). The author then continues to warn politicians that when the number of Muslims reaches a “critical mass,” they may demand ever more religious autonomy. When they understand “the Islamic system and worldview” (p. 66), the author argues, it will become clear that integration of Muslims is not viable. But he maintains that the situation might even become worse. The very separation of church and state will be put in jeopardy if Islam acquires too much operational space. It is this warning that sets the tone for the rest of the book, and it is restated again and again. By taking this position, the author joins the recently growing number of voices in Western European countries that consider the presence of Muslims a serious integration problem. It is not only attitudes and opinions of individual Muslims, but also agendas and programs of Islamic associations, that are assessed along these lines. The second part of the book concerns the situation of Muslims in Switzerland. It contains a listing of normative Islamic principles on freedom of religion, schooling, family law, food prescriptions, and burial regulations that are juxtaposed with Swiss legislation, secular principles, and Christian traditions.
Although the author is apparently well informed with respect to Islamic law, and although the first part is instructive, the book on the whole is rather disappointing for several reasons. My main critique concerns the author's heavy emphasis on normative Islamic principles. This in itself is not a problem so long as one is very clear about the implications and the questions asked. If one intends to analyze written Islamic sources on issues such as formal Islamic family law, Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh's method is adequate, but when one wants to learn more about actual marriage practices of Muslims in concrete circumstances, a description of norms is insufficient, static, and essentializing. This is even more the case with such crucial matters as the separation of church and state. The author fails to make the essential distinction between Islam and Muslims and to contextualize written theological principles. An assessment of the status of normative systems must always be accompanied by at least rudimentary social mapping and an analysis of prevailing power relations. Talal Asad has made the crucial distinction between liturgical utterance and religious discourse. Theological principles must always be embedded in actual societal or political context. To understand the place of religion in the lives of migrants from Muslim backgrounds, it is absolutely necessary to collect empirical data, to speak with people, and to analyze their position in the host society. With his rather legalist description of Islamic tradition, Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh seems to completely ignore the sociological and political aspects of the presence of Muslims in Europe.
That brings us to my second point. Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh promises to give an account of the position of Muslims in Switzerland. Instead of meticulously analyzing the various contentious fields concerning the integration of Muslims in Swiss society, he again, without a bit of empirical evidence, presents an overview of Islamic theology and apparently assumes that this will cause problems. Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh fails to give a clue about how these clashes are resolved. Besides that, his account of the Swiss situation is so superficial that the country could easily be replaced by any other country. There is, however, a growing body of publications about Islam in Western Europe based on cross-national research that convincingly shows that the legal, political, and social arrangements in European countries differ considerably from one country to the other. Western European countries may all have freedom of religion in their constitutions, but it makes quite a bit of difference when Muslims live in a country that does not officially recognize religious denominations (i.e., France and the Netherlands), or in one that links religious groups to the state through a system of public institutions (i.e., Germany). These contextual aspects constitute the structure of political opportunity and thus not only influence the agendas of Islamic public actors but also largely shape the discourses about Islam. It is a pity that the author has hardly taken notice of this literature.
The most fundamental critique, however, concerns the debatable implications of Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh's analysis—notably, his suggestion that the presence of Muslims jeopardizes the separation between church and state, which he apparently assumes to be complete and thorough in Western Europe. This in itself is a rather uncertain statement, but it becomes even more doubtful when the author refers to the situation in the former, war-ridden Yugoslavia as a possible future for Western Europe. Supporters of the “clash of civilization” thesis will probably agree with Aldeed Abu-Sahlieh that Islam is the antithesis of all that has been accomplished in Europe in the past 300 years. I do not want to ignore that there are “hot spots” concerning the integration of Muslims in European societies, but it is at best a sweeping statement to argue that Europe—in this case, Switzerland—will become a religious battlefield in the near-future. That is an unscientific rousing of public sentiments that can in no way be substantiated.