The literature on globalization has come a long way. The first-generation scholarship debated the “decline of the nation-state” thesis. Globalization critics predicted widespread regulatory races to the bottom. They blamed technological innovations that allow firms to decouple various stages of the production processes for privileging capital over other societal actors. While the globalization optimists agree with the causal story of the critics, they welcomed the emergence of a “borderless world.” For them, capital mobility leads to good governance because it privileges economic efficiency over rent-seeking politics.
The second-generation globalization literature adopted a more expansive view by recognizing the interplay between economic globalization (that is, increased cross-border integration of factor, intermediate, and final product markets) and noneconomic globalization. Technological innovations that facilitate capital mobility also enable global diffusion of (Western) norms and the emergence of the global civil society whose transnational networks challenge transnational capital.
The third-generation scholarship examines the “democracy and equity deficits” in institutions and policies adopted to cope with globalization. While such deficits are likely to be pervasive in intergovernmental and private authority regimes, scholars suggest that the global civil society might accentuate these deficits as well.
As an important addition to the third-generation scholarship, Contesting Globalization argues for situating the globalization discourse in concrete locations. For Andre Drainville, global cities provide the appropriate terrain to investigate globalization politics for they constitute the sites of encounter among social forces. The foreword by Saskia Sassen, the leading proponent of the global cities perspective, is illuminating. She notes approvingly that “the global city is a site where global corporate capital and multitudes of disadvantaged can engage with each other, where place-based politics (e.g. gentrification struggles) becomes a form of global politics” (p. xiii).
The introduction and the first chapters are well written and lay out the book's main argument. Drainville is critical of the second-generation literature for it masks the politics and struggles of the disadvantaged. However, he is equally critical of the sociological and the Marxian approaches for they focus on abstract subjects functioning in abstract spaces. As he rightly notes, “Holy ghosts of all sorts are haunting global politics: ‘global civil society’, ‘international public opinion’, ‘the people of the earth’” (p. 1). Emphasizing the importance of specific locations in structuring the political economy, he notes the role of Amsterdam during the Dutch hegemony, London during the Pax Britannica, New York during the Pax Americana. He goes on to suggest that in the age of Pax Planeta, “we will imagine the world economy as a city, to help us think critically about the making of the world order” (p. 7).
The second chapter, the most interesting part of the book, presents “three moments in urban history when the movement of urban social forces highlighted the very different modes of relation to cities at the core of the world economy” (p. 17). These moments are the dockworkers' strike in London (1989), the defeat of the Tammany Hall political machine in New York (1894), and the protests in the city of Quebec against the Summits of America (2001). London and New York constituted the central nodes of the world economy and therefore became the central locations for political struggles. I found these cases very illuminating. They successfully articulated the main purpose of this book: an examination of how social actors get created in concrete locations and the opportunities cities present in this regard. The third case, Quebec, was less compelling. This city hosted two rival “global summits” of actors who visited for a short duration of time, but its substantive importance in global capitalism was not clearly explained. Further, unlike the London and New York cases where social forces rooted in concrete places interacted and contested over a period of time, the rootedness of such forces in Quebec was not apparent. It seems that the abstract global actors whom Drainville criticizes assembled in Quebec to undertake decontextualized political action.
Chapter 3 first examines the politics of leftist internationalism from the 1840s (Pax Britannica) to the 1970s (the crisis of Pax Americana) and then the protest politics of the 1980s and the 1990s in terms of campaign-centered oppositional movements. Chapter 4 examines how over time, civil society has been incorporated in global and regional policymaking. Drainville argues that global capital responded initially to the Bretton Wood crisis by promoting universalist programs such as monetarism. When such global solutions failed, global capital advocated “global governance” as a way to ensure a reliable political and social order. The strategy was to co-opt its critics, elevate them to the status of global citizens, and arrive at nonradical solutions. The newly anointed global citizens, as the author suggests, become agents of order, not soldiers in political struggles. He finds the global governance projects problematic because they deradicalize politics. The global civil society creates fictitious, decontextualized citizens who owe their globality to forces that control the world order. I found the argument to be quite compelling. Indeed, scholars of NGO politics have been less attentive to the structural forces that have led to the emergence and the co-option of such organizations. Chapter 5 seeks to present new concepts for the critical articulation of global political economy. I found this less interesting and often difficult to understand. However, the concluding chapter is well written and carefully pulls together the key arguments made in the book. Drainville's point about the “unreal universality of the cosmopolitan ideology” (p. 160) is well taken.
Overall, Contesting Globalization is an ambitious book that I recommend to scholars interested in the study of globalization. In particular, I believe, it will be helpful to NGO politics scholars precisely because it identifies the limitations of their approach. One might argue, however, that global capitalism is taking a gamble by creating a global civil society that may become radicalized in the future. It follows, therefore, that a radical agenda might be to infiltrate and capture such groups with the objective of socializing them in the politics of protest instead of the politics of acquiescence.
