Several studies have been written about the guilds of Istanbul. Eunjeong Yi's work stands high among them. Using a multidisciplinary approach, the author views the guilds of Istanbul before and after the 17th century in a wider than usual perspective, comparing them to guilds in other Ottoman cities and raising a series of new ideas regarding their structure and functions. The book is made up of an introduction, four chapters, a general conclusion, six appendices, a bibliography, and an index. The appendices give lists of trades and guilds in Istanbul in the 17th century from different sources.
This book is the outgrowth of a 2000 Harvard University doctoral dissertation, “The Istanbul Guilds in the Seventeenth Century: Leverage in Changing Times.” Eunjeong Yi states in the preface that her aim was to question the works that tended to judge that “Ottoman guilds in general, and the Istanbul guilds in particular, were tradition-bound and/or closely controlled by the government” (p. ix). The author, however, acknowledges that, even though the original sources she explored were of the early to mid-17th century, she was, nevertheless, able to discover some patterns of behavior applying to many guilds that would seriously modify conventional wisdom. This admission reflects the transparency and caution with which the author approaches her interpretation of guild dynamics in Istanbul. Comparisons with the dynamics of guilds in other Ottoman cities support her conclusions.
Among the issues explored by the author is the ethnoreligious composition of guilds. Of fifty guilds whose delegations are described in the Islamic court registers, thirty-five consisted of Muslim and non-Muslim members. Although almost all the ketkhudas (heads) of those guilds were Muslim, the heads of subgroups within major guilds with mixed membership could be nominated from among non-Muslim members. Guilds composed solely of Christians or Jews frequently had ketkhudas from the same denomination. This was exactly the situation in the Syrian guilds at the time. Yi's explanation that the appointment of Muslim members as heads over guilds with mixed membership was because they could more effectively engage with the government is supported by evidence from Syrian guilds. To interpret the appointment of heads of mixed guilds from among Muslims as stemming out of fanaticism, which could be a tempting interpretation, would be a gross mistake. The guilds upheld with rigidity a work ethic that evaluated members based on their expertise, not on religious affiliation. Guilds in societies and cities with mixed religious population under Ottoman rule applied this rule in work ethic to the full.
Another major issue that the author explores is the interguild relationship whereby a guild was attached, as assistant (yamak), to a major, related guild for the purpose of retailing the products of the major guild and contributing to the payment of its taxes. Such a relationship existed, for example, among the guilds in Syria and Albania (for the latter, see the work of Zija Shkodra). A case in point is the guild of slaughterers, which was yamak to the guild of butchers. This relationship was intended to compensate for the rigidity of traditional regulations that restricted the expansion of businesses by imposing a quota on supplies provided to guilds and also by discouraging partnerships among producing guilds to keep prices under control.
Guild Dynamics also deals with the role custom and tradition played in resolving disputes among guilds outside the court. The distribution of raw materials among guild members, attempts by outsiders to join the guilds, the quality of work done by production guilds, and the amount of taxes each guild member had to pay toward the total amount of taxes collectively imposed on the guild were some of the problems the head of the guild and its elders had to deal with, guided by custom and tradition. The author emphasizes the role precedent had played in resolving differences within and among the guilds and in maintaining law and order among craftsmen away from the authority of the Muslim court. The court simply took notice of the decisions of guilds.
The right to practice a trade through the ownership of gedik, the tools of a trade, meant in effect, as the author rightly argues, a license to practice a trade. Yi, however, like others who have studied gedik, did not find conclusive evidence as to whether or not there were fixed numbers of licenses in each trade. In addition, the relationship between gedik and khilu, which is the right to use the premises, seems rather blurred and differs from one city to another.
The relationship between the government and the guilds is amply addressed here. The government role, according to the author, was crucial in the building of infrastructure, provisioning, mediating, price fixing, and market supervision through the mühtasip (market inspector), but this did not amount to absolute state control of the guilds. When necessary, the guilds appealed to the government through petitions against heavy taxation. When grievances were not addressed to satisfaction, guilds were ready to rise in revolt, as in the rebellion of 1651 in Istanbul, treated by the author, and there are ample examples in other Ottoman cities.
Guild Dynamics in Seventeenth-Century Istanbul is a well-researched work, accurate and thorough, engaging and enlightening, and a pleasure to read. Its contribution to the field is immeasurable. It raises multiple issues for comparison with guilds in other Ottoman cities. The publication of this solid work prepares the ground for comparative studies of guilds in the various regions of the Ottoman Empire. There is much to compare, for instance, between guilds in Syria and in Albania, and between guilds in these two countries and those in Palestine, Egypt, Anatolia, Istanbul, and the rest of the Balkans. The excellent research done by Eunjeong Yi and other scholars in those countries makes such a comparison possible.
