Crawford Gribben makes a valuable contribution to the debate about the alleged globalization of American evangelicalism in this short book examining transatlantic ideas regarding the Millennium. As his useful glossary explains, this term refers to a “utopian period” in history which fulfills the “prophecies of the renewal of the natural world in the Hebrew prophets” (xiii). Gribben's earlier work analyzed modern apocalyptic fiction in America, most notoriously by examining the Left Behind series. Now he traces these ideas back to earlier times. In so doing, he joins recent historical works which extend the sources of evangelicalism beyond the Anglo-Saxon world and its denominations. While he confirms that the First Great Awakening of the 1730s defined the new movement of evangelicalism on the grounds that at this time a general popular piety connected believers from different denominations, he digs even deeper to identify connections with earlier Protestants. The result is a broad survey in six chapters in which he shows waves of pessimism and optimism, passivism and activism from the sixteenth century on through to the twenty-first.
Widespread hope regarding an approaching Millennium emerged in the sixteenth century, when religious and political turmoil raised anxiety and a longing for the end of time. The political actions of the radical reformation discredited these expectations. The confirmation of the canonicity of the crucial text, the Book of Revelation, by magisterial reformers stimulated new interpretations which were disseminated across Europe by waves of religious refugees. The best example in this regard was the annotation in the Geneva Bible which claimed that the Millennium had already begun. This optimism gained momentum when the expectation regarding the conversion of the Jews took root. However, since few Jews became Christians, the period of the end times needed to be extended. This delay encouraged reflection about the in-between time preceding the final showdown. This timetable approach tried to fit past events and projected future ones into a chronology and printed those in Bible commentaries. Slowly an assortment of millennial ideas became acceptable and multiplied across diverse nations and societies. Of fundamental importance in this regard is the Millennium's shift in focus to the future.
The historical research emerging in the seventeenth century made it increasingly difficult to pinpoint or trace the Millennium in a past period. A new international, multiconfessional generation of scholars pushed the Millennium to the future. Puritans embraced these ideas even though there were great variations as to the timing of the Millennium. In powerful ways, the political events of the English Civil War and the Restoration period have important consequences regarding the specific political expectations of the Millennium. The First Great Awakening connected benevolence to rational order, thereby strengthening optimism regarding millennialism more generally.
In the nineteenth century, two dominant modes competed with each other – post- and pre-millennialism – as each contended for the place of the Millennium as in the past or in the future.
The advance of political and religious liberalism through the French and American Revolutions strengthened secular hopes that further stimulated post-millennial expectations. At the same time, a pessimistic undercurrent of antiradicalism, anti-Catholicism and antirationalism combined with a strong biblicism to take hold in American popular culture. New religious formations such as the Millerites, Seventh-Day Adventists and Jehovah's Witnesses dared to predict the exact day of Christ's return. The failures of these predictions weakened the method of post-millennialism even more by projecting the period further in the future. This new road map included a series of dispensations, or periods in the past, with each concluding epoch marked by the rapture of the true believers. These gloomy ideas gained plausibility by events such as the American Civil War, and serious social tensions caused by immigration and industrialization, in addition to the spread of cholera. According to the perspective of staunch advocates, these trends all served as signs of an approaching Dark Epoch, preceding the Millennium.
At the beginning of the twentieth century, American fundamentalists seemed to lose the battle for cultural authority. It was again a bible with footnotes, this time the Scofield Reference Bible (1909), that inculcated generations of evangelicals with dispensational notions about the Millennium and strengthened their literal interpretation of the Bible to decipher its clues. The founding of the state of Israel (1948) strongly stimulated pre-millennialist theories as it was taken as evidence of the fulfillment of biblical prophesies. The effect of this victory of dispensationalism in the USA caused a growing rift with European evangelicals who rejected these ideas as too speculative. The book closes with the use of theological dispensational rhetoric regarding Bush Jr.'s formulation of foreign-policy goals which caused fears regarding a self-fulfilling prophecy of doom.
The great value of this book arises from Gribben's demonstration of the fact that the idea of an actual Millennium came in many different garbs and gained respectability among believers despite the periodic setbacks caused by radical and often heretical outbursts in times of persecution. As a result, this volume should be required reading for alarmist journalists who take the biblical language of some American politicians as a new phenomenon. Gribben's genealogy of millennial thought assuages these anxieties by revealing their continuing circulation and ongoing shifts in emphasis.
Scholars might long for more explanations as to the differences in speed, causes, support groups, and effects of millennialism, however. The author is careful in raising realistic expectations regarding the scope and remit of the volume: it is not a sociological analysis, nor is it underwritten with strong quantitative data. Yet even the great variety and many differences call for further explanations and a clarification of the transatlantic issues. The author quotes from British, Irish, Dutch, French, German and American sources, but does not show how these patterns of influence and exchange functioned. Who read and believed these books? Did a foreign authorship support or challenge specific Millennial claims? A final word of caution: Gribben stretches the definition of evangelical evangelism to include the early reformers and many other Protestants, with the result that he is able to follow the acceptance of Millennialist ideas in broad perspective but with the consequence of losing evangelical distinctiveness.
