In July 1890 Joseph Snell Wood, editor of the brand-new sixpenny weekly The Gentlewoman, announced an “audacious venture”: the serialization of a reader-authored collaborative novel. A ‘Novel Novel’ (1890) offered nineteen readers the opportunity to contribute three-thousand-word chapters to a story of a duchess who disappears on her wedding day.Footnote 1 The first chapter was written by Lady Constance Howard, a writer known for tales of marital discord; readers had five days to prepare the next entry, with chapters required by first post on Mondays.Footnote 2 The project drew substantial reader attention, and, by the time A ‘Novel Novel’ was complete, Wood was trumpeting a second collaborative venture: twenty-four already-published authors were invited to contribute to a new fiction of mysterious womanhood, this time entitled The Fate of Fenella (1891–92). Alternating female and male writers ranged from exciting up-and-comers (Arthur Conan Doyle, Bram Stoker) to those who'd established their reputations a generation ago (Florence Marryat, Helen Mathers); from authors with a reputation for the unexceptional (Emily Lovett Cameron) to those known for shocking (“Frank Danby,” aka Julia Frankau). The Fate of Fenella was subsequently published by Hutchinson in one volume and enthusiastically billed as “The Most Extraordinary Novel of Modern Times.”
Perhaps Fenella was not, in fact, the most extraordinary novel published in a year that also saw the release of Thomas Hardy's Tess of the D'Urbervilles (1891). Indeed, on the face of it, Wood's claims may seem like mere late-Victorian puffery, a hyperbolic effort to drum up publicity and sales. Wood was known by his peers as “a capital man at the turnstile,” and his interest in the collaborative novel may seem to suggest little more than—or was at least consistent with—a businessman's urge to treat writers as means to an end, as commodities rather than as artists.Footnote 3 Certainly Wood made explicit from the start that neither project was shaped by an expectation of literary excellence nor of enduring authorial achievement. A ‘Novel Novel’ was an endeavor “of a purely fantastic sort,” the editor told readers, adopting suggestively science fiction terminology: “we offer it as an experiment, perfectly conscious that it may turn out a very monster of fiction.”Footnote 4 Framing the collaborative text as a curiosity, Wood implicitly relates it to Frankenstein's creation, another corpus stitched from composite parts.
The Fate of Fenella is hardly well known today, though it has received modest scholarly attention; Andrew Maunder edited a useful new edition of the text with Valancourt Books in 2008. A ‘Novel Novel,’ on the other hand, is at best a footnote to a footnote. Collaborative literature in general remains underappreciated, often regarded as little more than an interesting “experiment”; we continue, for the most part, to elevate the “myth of solitary genius,” preferring our authors singular and seer-like.Footnote 5 As Melisa Klimaszewski has argued, at the start of a welcome investigation of collaboration in Dickens's Christmas numbers, even those scholars who have investigated collaborative literatures have tended to limit their focus to collaborative pairs rather than to more “pluralistic collaborative endeavours.”Footnote 6 The more people involved in the collaborative text, the more complicated and tangled the project, the harder scholars have found it to engage the material, with many struggling, as Holly Laird argues, “to sort out who contributed what and, moreover, who dominated whom in the relationship and in the writing.”Footnote 7 Scholarship on collaborations has thus tended to center either texts produced in mutually sustaining creative, erotic, and emotional relationships, such as those of “Michael Field” and Somerville and Ross, or those generated in more tense, adversarial partnerships, like that of Dickens and Collins. Wayne Koestenbaum, in an important investigation of male literary collaborations, expressly argues that the two-person literary partnership—with both parties clearly identified—is the most “satisfying” collaborative form. “A text is most precisely and satisfyingly collaborative if it is composed by two writers who admit the act by placing both of their names on the title page,” he contends, implying that more complex, entangled, polyvocal narratives offer few pleasures.Footnote 8
This article attempts a fresh approach to the multiauthored novel, concentrating on two texts from a period increasingly engaged by the possibilities of literary collaboration. The later part of the nineteenth century was, as Lorraine York argues, a time of especially “vigorous collaborative activity” in the serial world and beyond; other multiauthored works include the nine-authored Women Authors of Queen Victoria's Reign (1897) and the pornographic ensemble text Teleny; or The Reverse of the Medal (1893).Footnote 9 There is much still to learn about what happens when, as Klimaszewski puts it, “a cluster of people produce a text,” when many voices come together “in chorus but also ringing out in solos.”Footnote 10 John Sutherland imagines the highly collaborative work involved in the production of All the Year Round as a sort of “writing workshop. It is wonderful to think of the ferment of ideas about fiction that were current there at this period.”Footnote 11 Inspired by these formulations, the following analysis aims to respect and even savor the multiple voices in The Gentlewoman's two collaborative novels, exploring the rich possibilities of a textual form whose “workshops” involved writers, the editor, and even readers. It does not treat the narratives as failed attempts at single-author works, nor does it endeavor to identify a “real” author. Rather, it seeks to balance attention to the many individuals involved with investigation of the stories they collectively crafted and the collaborative communities they forged. It also seeks to answer why the multiauthored collaborative form was chosen and produced in the first place, what particular purpose it served to tell this story this way.
Both Gentlewoman narratives turn, as we shall see, on the plight of a mysterious heroine whose reputation, choices, and actions stand as the locus of investigation. Both are sensational romances, with familiar casts of characters, tropes, plot twists, and themes of virtue and vice. The genre of the two novels, and the arcs of the individual chapters, almost certainly evolved in dialogue with Wood; this kind of collaboration was common practice in Victorian serial literature, of course—indeed in all published work. Anthony Trollope reported, in an 1870 lecture, that “the web of complex interactions uniting the writer, the reader and his publisher will have inevitable effects on the finished product, repercussions which must be considered in any complete evaluation of the work.” Sutherland remarks that the Victorian novel is almost by definition “the outcome of collaboration, compromise or commission.”Footnote 12 Still, the two fictions in The Gentlewoman are also collaborative in a different sense, involving exchanges among dozens of writers who did not know one another nor, so far as we know, collaborate in person. The resulting texts are at once consistent in genre terms yet varied in point of view, the text's interpretation of the protagonists and their stories changing week by week. While all fictions evolve in dialogue with the market, with the editor, the publisher, and with readers, the multivocal collaborative text offers unusually robust opportunities for revising, speaking back, cross-referencing, even disagreeing. Laird has argued, in a “state of the field” piece in PMLA, that collaborative texts are for this reason, formally speaking, “self-disruptive.”Footnote 13 The Gentlewoman's two collaborative novels deploy this to particular and pertinent effect, disrupting not only their own reading of the heroines but staging, through their very form, that any fixed, stable, or unitary reading of womanhood is impossible.
The Gentlewoman : Forging Communities
Wood's flagship magazine worked, from its very first issues, to foster dialogues between the genders as well as among classes, professions, and geographical regions on complex, deeply contentious subjects of the day concerning women—issues like marriage, divorce and separation, sexual double standards, education, and how young women should be raised. The Gentlewoman burst with diverse features on these topics and more, covering politics to pleasure, court birthdays to everyday problems. Regular columns included “Money Making” (the first issue explained the national debt), “Plays and Players,” “Pretty Costumes,” “Ripples from the River” (on regattas and boating events), “Music and Musicians,” “Art and Artists,” and “Our Fair Critics,” a “novel feature” that invited readers “to form and offer their opinions upon some current, social, literary or artistic subject which we shall select for pleasant discussion.”Footnote 14 The first topic offered for discussion was Sarah Bernhardt's performance in Jules Barbier's Jeanne d'Arc.
Indeed, one of the most distinctive features of the new magazine was the space it gave over to reader voices, to individual opinions. Women who could not travel to see Bernhardt had plenty of opportunities to find themselves in print nonetheless: they could enter short-story competitions, write in with questions, or engage in contentious topics of the day—a reader named Helen Russell got the ball rolling by arguing provocatively in the first issue that children did not bring happiness. A column later that month invited readers to write in with “Grumbles and Grievances,” and the paper welcomed complaints of all sorts: “From the gentle sigh of disappointment to the honest growl of righteous indignation, no fair expression of protest . . . will be excluded.”Footnote 15 If debate and expressions of anger and frustration were hallmarks of The Gentlewoman, so too were opportunities for sharing life's challenges; births, marriages, and deaths columns concerned families from all across the nation, while “Our Exchange and Market” allowed women to navigate financial difficulties by bringing together supply and demand. Many papers offered similar pages, of course, but The Gentlewoman took things a step further, presenting itself not just as a paper but as interlocutor, personal assistant, even friend: “The Gentlewoman's Buying Bureau” offered to buy “anything that can be obtained at London shops” for any reader who lived out of the city, for the price of the goods and their carriage.Footnote 16
The Gentlewoman offered itself from the first as a community paper, then, though that community was not geographically bounded in an era of increasing mobility and house-moving. The Victorians were famously a people on the move, young Victorians especially heading from country toward city and suburb, searching out modernity and economic opportunity; a higher percentage of the nation's residents dwelt in urban than rural areas by the 1851 census, and, by the end of the century, nearly three-quarters lived in or around the fast-growing cities. In an era “without the present-day ideology of home-ownership,” as Helen Long points out, short-term rentals were commonplace; Jane Ellen Panton, a best-selling interior design writer, observed in 1896 that most residents took out “the usual three-year tentative lease”—which, she added, “is so rarely renewed.”Footnote 17 I've argued elsewhere that, in the face of this, new “middle-class residents from all over the nation found themselves separated from birth networks, inhabiting an architectural landscape in which regular moving was a fact of life, where migrants from other classes, nations, and communities found themselves in close proximity.”Footnote 18 The Gentlewoman brought readers together across geographical and class boundaries, speaking and giving voice to young women, married women, and spinsters alike, building an alluring identity of all readers, together, as an “imagined community” of “gentlewomen.”Footnote 19
The paper was undoubtedly also aspirational, as the genteel-sounding title indicates. Competition prize money was awarded in aristocratic guineas, not pounds, while Court News and birthday greetings to nobles suggested affinity and shared experience with the nation's elites. Yet the manageable sixpenny cover price, and the home addresses of contributors and prizewinners, listed on almost every page, indicated that readers hailed from all over the nation, from provincial, urban, and suburban locales—and that this was not something to hide. Readers were signaled that everyone, wherever they came from, was welcome. A young woman might live in Hendon and work in a hat shop, but The Gentlewoman spoke to her as if her opinion was worth hearing and placed her cheek-by-jowl with a duchess. The paper's first “monster of fiction,” then, was consonant with, even an expression of, the paper's broader mission and identity. Integrating writers from all walks of life, it offered diverse readers an opportunity to enter into a common dialogue about womanhood.
A ‘Novel Novel’
Inviting readers to join Lady Constance Howard in the first collaborative novel, The Gentlewoman brought together a range of women who were unlikely, in the normal course of events, to meet, still less to work together. A ‘Novel Novel’ passes the baton with apparent ease from schoolteacher to countess in its story of a disappeared duchess; all that was required for entry was a coupon from the paper, clipped and affixed to each entry.
The authors may, for the most part, be tracked down quite easily today in the census and other national archives, for their boroughs, streets, sometimes even house names and numbers are listed in the paper—and repeated, in the table of contents, each week. Chapter 2 was written by seventeen-year-old Amy Blanche Lane, for instance, daughter of a brewer, living in Hertfordshire; chapter 3 was penned by twenty-seven-year-old Maria Laughton, married to a retired naval officer four decades older than herself, residing in West Kensington Park.Footnote 20 Eighteen-year-old Eva Roos, who wrote chapter 9 and lived in Caterham in Surrey, was to became an illustrator in the early twentieth century, including for editions of East Lynne and The Water Babies. A “Mrs. Vallance” at The Deanery in Stratford wrote chapter 14; she was either fifty-seven-year-old Lucy Vallance, wife of a doctor, or her unmarried thirty-year-old daughter, Zona, deploying a thinly veiled identity. Zona Vallance would soon become a political activist who served as honorary secretary of the Union of Ethical Societies—now the Humanist Society—and founded the Moral Instruction League in 1897 (its goal was to replace religious instruction in schools); a writer and feminist, Zona contributed frequently to The Ethical World until her premature death in 1904, arguing—for instance—that women should be paid for their childcare.Footnote 21 Twenty-eight-year-old Minnie Laud, schoolmistress and daughter of a builder, wrote chapter 15 and lived in Camberwell, while the sixty-year-old Countess of Munster, natural granddaughter of William IV on the distaff side, produced chapter 17 and resided in Brighton. At nineteen, Edith Ostlere had a career as an actress, playwright, and short-story writer ahead of her: she wrote chapter 18 and lived on Neville Road, Waterloo, in Liverpool. Lena Hosford, who was to become her surgeon-brother's housekeeper, lived at The Grove, Stratford; daughter of a numerous family, she wrote chapter 19.Footnote 22 Other contributors hailed from Bath, Ireland (just outside Dublin), Cheltenham, Tunbridge Wells, Worcester, and Great Berkhamstead, as well as from all over London, and from addresses that hint at a wide range of class backgrounds: Wilhemina FitzClarence, Countess of Munster, dwelling on the balmy south coast, surely enjoyed a very different standard of living from that of teacher Minnie Laud in Camberwell (who would die, aged barely thirty, in 1892).
Not all this information was available to readers, obviously. But a surprising amount of it was: the full address of Mrs. [Rosa] Bull, for instance, author of chapter 9, was blazoned at the top of her chapter as 158 Elgin Avenue, Maida Vale. When a contributor forgot or failed to send in her address with her chapter, or attempted an obvious pseudonym, Wood demanded a real name and address the following week.Footnote 23 Far from erasing the identity of the author-contributors, then—as one might expect in an era often charged with reducing writers to cogs in a wheel—and far from ignoring place in an era of increasing migration, the paper meticulously identified and situated each author. Place-names served to remind readers, vividly and weekly, of the paper's national reach; cutting across cities, boroughs, suburbs, towns, villages, and hamlets, even crossing the Irish Sea, author locations signaled the expansiveness of The Gentlewoman's readership, offering a geographical framing to the paper's “imagined community” of “gentlewomen.” Though not quite a political community in Benedict Anderson's sense, The Gentlewoman's community is imagined to be coterminous with the nation and offers something of the “deep, horizontal comradeship” that Anderson sees as fundamental to a nation's “imagined community.”Footnote 24 This community, however, is populated mostly by women and only by those men concerned with debating matters of interest to women. In this way, the woman-centered community The Gentlewoman projects is at once like, and importantly unlike, the nation itself.
Listed addresses also reminded readers that the writers were real—and readers themselves. Framing the novel in this way, as the product of ordinary people, from in-this-world places, the pleasure of reading the text becomes partly the pleasurable belief that they are like me, and I might be next. The editor made the intimate relationship of readers and writers even clearer each week by selecting a handful of so-far unsuccessful contributors to name and encourage; some of these went on to pen later chapters.Footnote 25 Rather as social media today offers the alluring possibility of access to a national, even global audience, The Gentlewoman offered its readers the thrilling opportunity to see their names in print, too—cracking “open the narrative to readers,” as Laird has put it of another collaborative novel, “allowing readers and writers to wrestle and interchange [their] roles.”Footnote 26
A large part of what made this exchanging of roles so enticingly possible was the predictability of the stories—or, to put it another way, a shared understanding of the literary conventions of a serial romantic novel in 1890. A ‘Novel Novel’ centers on romantic misunderstandings with sensational and melodramatic plot twists that suggest a strong debt to writers like Mary Elizabeth Braddon, Ellen Wood, and Wilkie Collins as well as a grasp of more contemporary sensation-infused adventure and detective narratives. Crime is punished, evil found out, moral boundaries restored after a narrative in which, as David Glover puts it of fin de siècle genre fiction generally, “crime, passion, sensation and a generous dose of the Gothic, [are] all part of a chaotically melodramatic series of adventures whose sole rationale [is] to carry the reader from one point of suspense to another.”Footnote 27 This loose yet reliable set of generic characteristics were so commonly established, so very well understood, that readers of The Gentlewoman were able to deploy them individually and collectively.
The woman who disappears on her wedding day is a young widow. The new Duchess of Mowbray's identity, past, choices, friends, actions, and possibly location are thereby offered to readers/potential authors as the mysterious locus around which the rest of the tale pivots: the text effectively signals, in other words, its location in the genre of women's sensation fiction. Such novels, Lyn Pykett argues, typically center on a “woman with a secret,” thereby putting
female characters at their center, focusing closely on women's experiences, the particular circumstances of their lives, and the relationship of these particularities to contemporary generalizations or beliefs about woman's nature and the way it shaped women's role in the family and society.Footnote 28
A plot integrating “secrecy, mystery, suspense, horror, duplicity, disguise, and crime and its detection” ensues. Authors draw from a familiar stock of sensational plot devices to uncover the reasons for the duchess's disappearance—“[b]lackmail, forged wills, bigamy, adultery, and other crimes within or against the family”—with familiar characters like probing doctors and insightful detectives contributing to a drama in which female complexity calls for male deductive skills, attentive care, and constant watchfulness.Footnote 29
A brief summary of the plot serves to round out the point. Early authors foreground the desolation of the husband, establishing his virtue and his urge to seek out his wife and look into the “truth” of her life, assisted by friends. Maria Laughton in chapter 3 brings in a slight yet perceptive detective to assist: Laughton's depiction of Mr. Bolton hints at a possible familiarity with either “The Sign of the Four,” published in the February 1890 issue of Lippincott's Monthly Magazine, or the 1887 “A Study in Scarlet” from Beeton's Christmas Annual. Bolton—whose “grey eyes seemed to take in the whole room in one rapid glance”—misses the duchess by seconds at Charing Cross station, courtesy of south London–dwelling Ernestine Tate, then follows the trail all over the continent, gradually realizing the duchess's father is involved.Footnote 30 But the father is shown by Minnie Laud to be the dupe of a childhood friend, mysteriously like him in features, and the man the duchess believes to be her father is actually the criminal father of her maid. Later writers give increasing agency to the duke and his sister, while the detective is for many chapters humiliated in his failure to bring home the wife. Lena Hosford brings about resolution by revealing that the duchess’ first husband is safely dead by suicide, thus releasing the heroine from her fear that her new marriage is bigamous; the couple is reunited by Daisy Moutray Read, from Sandford Dene, Cheltenham, in chapter 20 (eighteen years old at the time, Rose H. Moutray Read was a future horticulturalist and writer). Their connubial happiness is crowned by the arrival of a baby: “the past darkness only enhances the present brightness,” opines the ecstatic husband, “and together, dear, our love will lighten every sorrow, and increase every joy that the future may bring.”Footnote 31
Constance Howard's account of the novel she would have written, published the following week, suggests a story at once quite different—the former husband is the evil genius at work—and remarkably similar. Both require the duchess to be manipulated by a Machiavelli. Both insist on the duchess's virtue and reunite her with her husband. Both integrate a range of male surveillance figures. Both require skills in costuming and disguise, on the part of women especially—Howard's duchess, for instance, when she realizes her husband intends to blackmail her, heads to a wig shop, “buys a white wig, saying she wants it for some theatricals; then she buys some blue spectacles, and finally a black dress and bonnet” (the blue spectacles surely indicate a quiet nod to Isabel in Ellen Wood's East Lynne). In Vallance's chapter, the duchess is delighted when an elderly visitor “removed her glasses and wig of grey hair with the cap, and Seringa [the heroine] saw, through her cleverly painted face, it was indeed her dear friend Cecilia.Footnote 32 The similarity of Constance Howard's imagined story and the tale that was actually written suggests how fully readers understood and were themselves able to deploy genre conventions—the arc as well as the symbols, tropes, scenes, themes, and moral lessons—of popular sensational romance.
Wood presented himself, in his editorial commentaries, as also contributing to the arc of the story, constructing his role as that of stern taskmaster with a bird's-eye view of the plot. He warned contributors not to resolve dramatic moments too quickly, for instance, so that a writer who attempted to bring the main characters back from the continent in late August was firmly rebuked: “it is hardly time to go back to England yet. Try again.”Footnote 33 He also complained about the language and style of some contributions, critiquing “frothy” language on July 26. Yet we should be cautious before assuming that Wood was indeed a Machiavelli, an oppressive text-manipulator—a figure, one might say, out of the pages of a sensational novel. What we may read as domineering or dictatorial was fully consistent with the era's expectations of the “celebrity-editor” figure, one who surveilled every page and engaged in fierce quality and content control. This figure, forged earlier in the century, was deployed to especially great advantage by Charles Dickens—who, as Beth Palmer notes, projected himself in periodicals as “an editorial persona who seemed in charge of every syllable . . . highly invested in his magazine's production because it was a weekly representation, or performance of himself.”Footnote 34 Many editors, including women, adopted and adapted Dickens's strategies in the second half of the century, Palmer explains, recognizing that the development of a coherent editorial identity was a highly effective means of connecting with readers, building a brand, and growing a fee-paying public. How much Wood's weekly editorial comments reflect his “real” role in the development of A ‘Novel Novel’ is hard to determine, then, even if they clue us in on what Wood believed his readers expected. Part of the purpose of the collaborative novel, the very reason for its inclusion in the magazine, may have been that it allowed Wood to stage himself as an engaged editor-with-a-vision. By terming the first collaborative novel a “monster of fiction,” Wood positions himself as the brilliant Victor Frankenstein, stitching the body parts together.Footnote 35
Wood and his contributors surely understood their role in a larger matrix, grasping the value of acceding to the norms and tropes of contemporary periodical culture both within the frame of the story and outside it, in characters who disguise and in authors and editorial figures who perform an identity. Yet beyond a shared commitment to be bound by certain formal, cultural, and literary tropes, the text still allows for difference and disagreement, making space for “solos” as well as the swelling “chorus.” Palmer notes—in her analysis of the “matrix of press production”—that one particular part of that matrix, the readership, is often especially hard for us to recover, but A ‘Novel Novel’ intriguingly gives voice to the paper's own readers, offering them a turn at center stage.Footnote 36 A writer with intimate knowledge of Berlin takes characters under the lampposts of Unter den Linden; Lena Hosford, doctor's daughter, dwells on the medical treatment afforded the Duchess's wounded father. Different authors bring new characters to the fore and push out the ones they dislike—Vallance, for instance, treats Bolton the detective as something of a failure: “he has allowed himself to be outwitted on each occasion. . . . We should have done better if we had depended on our own discretion.” Perhaps there is a hint of the voice of woman's rights activist Zona Vallance in a character who observes, “I wish Cecilia were here now, her wit is better than that of a dozen detectives,” and who allows Lady Cecilia Allonby—the duke's sister—to first find the duchess.Footnote 37 Hilda Somers from Moyvalley in Ireland also plays up the role of women in resolving the mystery and points out the duke's comparative and frustrating passivity: when the duke declares his intention to follow a suspicious character, for instance, Lady Allonby observes bracingly: “I am glad to see you take that active view of the matter. . . . You know I always urged you on, when you appeared so hopeless and despondent.”Footnote 38 The story that results, the narrative that evolves, is one that allows reader-authors to express individuality and difference of opinion within a managed community bonded and bounded by the confines of genre and the serial form.
Palmer notes that fierce differences of opinion on gender were virtually integral to woman-centered magazines of the 1890s; writers routinely offered different visions of women's lives on every page, in different features and in commentaries, so that “‘femininity’ is repeatedly enacted but its meaning is never conclusively settled.”Footnote 39 Many periodicals are polyvocal on gender matters, in other words, yet the collaborative novel stages difference with particular acuity, bringing writers into a common story whose very form demands weekly reframings. Staging weekly that stories are constructed, that even facts may be contingent, A ‘Novel Novel’ presses reader-authors—and readers at home—to probe and question the politics that shape interpretations of women's identities, lifestyles, and choices. Indeed, the decision by Wood and Howard to make a missing duchess the focus of the text positively drives readers—even more provocatively than the writer who argued that children do not bring happiness, perhaps—to take an active role in not just questioning gender roles but in affirming their constructedness. The polyvocal collaborative form facilitates a dynamic, evolving conversation in which interpretations of gender are fundamentally unfixed—for it is integral to the genre that they will be contested and re-presented next week.
The Fate of Fenella
Wood's next collaborative project continued its dynamic explorations of gender roles the following year, with male authors this time fully part of the conversation. Opening with a chapter by Helen Mathers for the Christmas 1891 issue, The Fate of Fenella steps into even racier territory, for a woman's sexual choices and actions are placed front and center in the text.Footnote 40 The Duchess of Mowbray is never seriously presented as anything but virtuous, but Fenella's chastity is in question from the start, for she lives (and flirts) apart from Sir Francis Onslow, her husband. Her romantic partnerships lead, moreover, to chaos and death. After abortive attempts at reconciliation, Frank kills, in a trance state, one of Fenella's partners. Horrified, Fenella takes responsibility for the act, claiming she believed she was about to be raped, and she stands trial for murder. Later chapters concern the misdeeds of a rival, the coming-to-consciousness of Frank, and Fenella's longing for her son, whom she's persuaded to give up and who is subsequently kidnapped.
If the authors of Fenella were given explicit guidance by Wood, this time he did not reveal it. Instead, he took a rather respectful tone when describing the “well-known novelists” he had lined up to write, implying that, this time, his role was the facilitator of “big names.” Still, even if it is true (as Adeline Sergeant would later recall) that Wood stayed out of the way and did not dictate the plot, the story hardly strode into surprising territory: plot elements remain strikingly familiar. A sharp-eyed sister, a brace of male friends who set about surveilling the wife and resolving the mystery, extended travels abroad, variously loyal retainers, periods of terrible illness, life-saving doctors, a dangerous woman, meetings with Scotland Yard, and a romantic heterosexual resolution are key elements of both Fenella and A ‘Novel Novel.’ Both texts are discernibly and familiarly sensational romances of the period, in other words, clear products of the moment and of broader serial culture.
Still, as in the first collaborative novel, the twenty-four writers brought a range of diverse experiences and backgrounds to the narrative. Speaking in subtly different voices, they were known for different kinds of writing. Ably described by Andrew Maunder, the twenty-four ranged from the once-daring Mathers to the hunting, “horsey” novelist Mary Kennard; from the sensational Florence Marryat to crime writer and journalist Richard Dowling; from editor and journalist Arthur à Beckett, to playwright Clotilde Graves, and to names we know far better today, above all Bram Stoker and Arthur Conan Doyle. The twenty-four Fenella writers also came, like the readers of A ‘Novel Novel,’ from all over the country and were known for speaking about and to slightly different communities: a number were immigrants or migrants to London, six Irish-born, two Scottish. Two spent substantial portions of their lives in Australia; one lived many of her adult years in India. Julia Frankau was Anglo-Jewish and had written (sensationally) about the lives and experiences of Jewish minorities in London.
Many also faced intense economic uncertainty; indeed, a number were fighting tooth and nail to survive by the pen at the time of Fenella's serialization, so that money likely played a role in their decisions to contribute and in the tales that they told. This was, by any measure, an astonishingly hardworking group: Adeline Sergeant wrote up to six thousand words a day, Maunder notes, producing over ninety novels in the course of her career; she had a nervous breakdown, partly due to exhaustion, shortly after completing her Fenella chapter. “Marcus Fall” (Richard Dowling), who started out life as a ship-broker's clerk, also wore himself out through hard graft, churning out sixty volumes in the last two decades of his life and dying prematurely in 1898. “Rita” (Margaret Humphreys) produced over sixty books to help support her invalid husband; Marryat wrote an astonishing forty novels between 1885 and 1897 alone. May Crommelin struggled to make ends meet and was forced to apply to the Royal Literary Fund for support in 1891. (Mathers would later apply to the same fund and died almost penniless.) Margaret Hungerford wrote thirty-five novels of Irish life in just over two decades to support her family, dying of typhus in 1897; George Manville Fenn produced, by 1907, an almost unimaginable 161 novels, plus journalism, short fiction, biographies, plays, works for children, and more.
Each of these writers was not only well versed in the sensational demands of the moment but also, and unlike the contributors to A ‘Novel Novel,’ already actively deploying their grasp of genre to sell fiction (and live). Fenn's novels were of “the blood and thunder type,” one reviewer remarked of an 1886 novel; “Love, murder, suicide, poison, shooting, madhouses, strait-jackets, snake-like aristocratic villains, unscrupulous Yankee rogues, gambling, night watches, horrible discoveries—these are the heterogeneous, but attractive elements of which this novel is composed.”Footnote 41 The editor of The Gentlewoman must have known what he was getting when he asked these authors to contribute: urgently needing to please their editor, the writers were fully conscious of market demands and intensely motivated to meet them. Maunder reads Fenella, finally, as rather a disappointment precisely because it is so familiar, so “clichéd”—“implausible and sentimental,” he remarks, it reeks of “heavy-handed morality, [with] its conventional emphasis on its heroine who needs rescuing.”Footnote 42
And yet, as in A ‘Novel Novel,’ the Fenella writers deploy familiar “heterogeneous” elements of sensational serial fiction while reframing and contesting interpretations of gender raised in this narrative of sexual misconduct. They divert and detour and write back, following individual interests and introducing new locations while shining new lights on protagonists, their choices and actions. Male and female writers alike—and Frankau, writing under a male pseudonym—offer a range of interpretations of Fenella's behavior, her character, and past; in Mathers's initial chapter, for instance, Fenella appears a silly coquette who has broken up her marriage on a whim. Irish nationalist MP Justin McCarthy dwells on the emotions and characters of the men who watch and admire her. But Frances Eleanor Trollope paints in a difficult childhood for Fenella in chapter 3, and so begins a sea change in the text: as two characters discuss the collapse of Fenella's marriage, Trollope suggests that double standards are decidedly at play in the public's view of the breakup. Frank flirted with other women and even began an affair during the marriage himself, she explains, so that only the very stuffiest observers can blame her: “It couldn't be supposed that because Lord Francis Onslow kicked up his heels rather more than was exactly pretty, Lady Francis Onslow was to be allowed to follow suit,” the dull Lord Castleton huffs, leaving open the very loud and obvious question, why not? Footnote 43 Trollope allows these kinds of loose threads to trail suggestively throughout her chapter, provoking questions and offering quiet alternative views: when Lord Castleton asserts, for instance, that “very few of those who saw the little drama being acted before their eyes take a lenient view of Fenella's conduct. . . . The woman is as dangerous as a rattlesnake,” the more sympathetic character Jacynth Clitheroe reflects, “there are depths of feeling in that girl of which old Castleton is about as well able to judge as a mole of the solar system.”Footnote 44
Some authors seem unable to agree, even with themselves, quite how to read Fenella. Arthur Conan Doyle in particular equivocates between presenting the heroine as “capricious and beautiful” and a woman more sinned against than sinning. Doyle is explicit that Frank “fell” first: Frank, becoming gradually more self-aware under Doyle's pen, recalls guiltily “how patient she had been at first. Then how her patience had gradually changed to surprise, surprise to suspicion, suspicion to anger, and anger to revenge in the shape of the flirtation which had brought about the separation. Who was he, to blame her? He had himself been the first to sin” (my emphasis).Footnote 45 Chapter 6, written by Frank Charles (F. C.) Phillips, swings back to a dismissive evaluation of Fenella by the sister of Jacynth: “I consider her unladylike, wanting in savoir vivre and tact, and quite the last person with whom I should have any sympathy,” she declaims, though the narrator also gives space to a counterargument: Jacynth protests, “She has been cruelly treated.” Still, the sister is ultimately unimpressed, and her perspective is given some narrative support: “So have thousands of other women,” she replies crisply to the claim about cruel treatment, “but they manage to bear their cruel treatment and behave with better taste than Lady Francis.” The narrator—channeling the sympathetic Jacynth—reflects that there is “a certain worldly wisdom” in her remarks.Footnote 46
Fenella lacks a unitary perspective or consistent authorial voice, in other words; this is at once what makes the novel not “good” in a conventional sense—critics panned it as a “patchwork,” a “crazy quilt”—and distinctive.Footnote 47 Even before Fenella's arrest for murder, the protagonist's character, as it stands revealed in her choices, is posed as a puzzle that demands interpretation, that provokes fierce and ongoing disagreement. Do you blame Fenella? For what, exactly? Should she have left her husband or put up with his philandering? Is Frank more or less guilty than Fenella? Does it make a difference if a husband or wife falls first? Is a woman's flirting better or worse than a man's affair outside marriage? Does it make a woman more guilty—or less—if she is flighty, given the high value the culture places on female whimsicality and charm? Questions like these are implicitly and at times explicitly framed as Fenella's and Frank's choices and actions are assessed and compared. The form of the novel again allows such questions to emerge with unusual vigor, and authors take advantage of the opportunity, working to shut down plotlines they dislike, readings of behaviors they wish overturned, through authorial commentary and in “revelations” that work to recast and reframe previous events. Others introduce new themes and topics, ranging from mesmerism to the law to American culture, in ways that either advance or hurt their pet characters’ interests. Perhaps the Fenella authors grasped that the genre of the collaborative text—at least, as it had evolved in A ‘Novel Novel’—not only allowed for but positively demanded this polyvocality, this chorus of disagreement. When Fenella's case finally comes to trial, what is never in doubt is her innocence of the murder itself, since we see her husband committed the act.Footnote 48 What remains in flux is any fixed or final reading of Fenella's character, identity, and motivations, for this is a text that “self-disrupts” on every page.
Conclusions
Bringing professional male and female writers into an energetic discussion about womanhood, Fenella is, in some sense, a continuation of A ‘Novel Novel,’ the twenty-four chapters an extension of its earlier dialogue about women, their identities, choices, and social roles; about sexual double standards, marriage, separation, and family demands. Both A ‘Novel Novel’ and The Fate of Fenella fundamentally turn on a mystery whose resolution requires assessing a woman in the light of uncertain facts and by attempting to deploy contemporary norms; both texts, like the magazine itself, encourage and make space for disagreement within managed parameters. Both allow contributors to speak back and disagree, to converse and disrupt, testing while also acceding to the limits of genre. Even elements that do not repeat between the two—Joseph Hatton, editor of the Gentleman's Magazine, sends Frank into a mesmeric trance from which he rises “as an anaconda might” to murder a count in the middle of the night—are carefully connected to other sensational fictions; Hatton explicitly mentions Robert Louis Stevenson's famous dreams as precursor.Footnote 49 Both A ‘Novel Novel’ and The Fate of Fenella are at once rooted in and deviations from the literary traditions they inherit; both are collaborations founded on a bedrock of agreement—about the tropes, themes, arcs, and endings of popular sensational romance. Both stage ongoing disagreements about gender, allowing for the loose, uneven evolution of fictional characters in the pursuit of dialogue and conversation. Both bond readers—like the magazine itself—into a larger community of “gentlewomen” anchored in common understandings of genre that allows for the expression of political difference and disagreement.
Wood's commitment to forging communities, and communities of vociferous writing women especially, was a key part of his professional life; he is perhaps best known for founding the Society of Women Journalists in 1894, which still exists, as the Society of Women Writers and Journalists.Footnote 50 Still, Wood was no bold feminist. His paper's vision of womanhood did not entail wholesale overthrow of gender hierarchies, and the fiction he nurtured (collaborative and single-authored) still cleaved to romantic arcs. The community Wood sought to foster remained founded on a familiar bedrock set of Victorian beliefs about the importance of marriage and the value of wifely obedience. But his decision to run two collaborative novels in the paper's first year speaks, nonetheless, to a determination to make space for the voices of women across the nation, forged into a community of invited, managed disagreement. Wood opened his paper with novels that asked writers—who were readers—to articulate their opinions and ambitions in relation to those of others. This was not a model of creativity that rewarded or encouraged the brilliant lone star, the rebel; still, it was a model that encouraged dialogue, disagreement, negotiation, reflection. Long before the internet facilitated today's waves of collaborative and fan fiction, The Gentlewoman brought authors together on common projects. The texts that evolved are polyvocal and dialogic, narratives founded not so much on character development or linear plotlines as on the articulation of multiple perspectives on matters central to women's lives.
