This is an important new monograph on the city of Rome in Late Antiquity. Few are more qualified to produce such a work than Michele Salzman, given her seminal works on the Christianisation of the Roman senate, the so-called Calendar of 354 and Symmachus’ letters. S. consciously positions her latest work in a debate that has been dominated by the influence of Edward Gibbon's Decline and Fall (ch. 1). In an original take, she chooses to examine this matter from the city of Rome's perspective, exploring how the Urbs experienced several crises from the early fourth to the early seventh century.
Diocletian's reforms entrenched the fact that Rome had lost its place as the Empire's political centre. Yet, as S. demonstrates, the city was still home to the wealthiest aristocracy of the Mediterranean world, whose members were perennially eager to compete for political influence and social preeminence. It is this very competition which she identifies as a driving factor in the various restoration efforts in the aftermath of crises that shook the city, such as Maxentius’ downfall in 312 (ch. 2), Alaric's sack of Rome in 410 (ch. 3), Geiseric's sack in 455 (ch. 4) and Ricimer and Anthemius’ civil war in 472 (ch. 5). S. argues that, because of their wealth and eagerness for status, senatorial aristocrats were the most capable actors to lead restoration efforts. In comparison, she paints a humble picture of the bishops of Rome, dependent as they were on patronage of these elites until the sixth-century Gothic Wars, Justinian's Pragmatic Sanction and the subsequent Lombard invasion of Italy destroyed the foundations of senatorial prosperity and political influence (chs 6–7). The history of the senate symbolically ends with pope Honorius (625–638) — himself of senatorial descent — turning the Curia into an ordinary church. At this point, the papacy irreversibly takes over the helm of government, senators disappear and Rome ceases to be an ancient city.
S.'s model of ‘resilience’, which hitherto has mainly been used in environmental debates, aptly enables her to move beyond binary distinctions that have long dominated this field, as she acknowledges both the calamities that Roman society experienced and the capacity of individuals and groups to marshall resources to aid recovery. The greatest strength of this monograph is the attention it gives to Roman senators as the powerful agents they were — or could be — following Constantine I's reforms. Especially during the reigns of Odoacer and Theoderic the Amal (476–526), they led the way as a political body by granting legitimacy and providing experienced officials to monarchs who ushered in Late Roman Italy's last ‘Indian Summer’.
At times, however, S.'s enthusiasm for senators as saviours of Rome leads her towards an over-positive assessment of their capacity to restore Rome. While every instance of senatorial restoration of buildings, monuments or statues in this period is diligently recorded, we rarely hear about instances where ‘[a]dmittedly, elites … [did] not always respond to crises in ways that advanced the best interests of the populace or society at large’ (304). Why, for instance, not discuss Valentinian III's Novellae of the 440s, which reveal that the senatorial aristocracy thwarted any imperial effort to compel them to pay taxes that would have helped remedy the fragile state of the Imperial West and improve its army? Could the treaty of 442, which left Africa's richest provinces in Geiseric's hands, truly be described as being ‘from the Roman imperial perspective very advantageous’ (143)?
Similar oversights may also be found in earlier parts of S.'s book. In the first chapter, for example, the opportunity to discuss how internal developments may have contributed to the Empire disappearing as a sovereign state in the West, and its impact on Rome, is missed. It is surprising that the bibliography lacks any studies of the growing body of scholarship by authors such as Henning Börm, Christine Delaplace, Walter Goffart or Guy Halsall. The omission of such studies may explain the rather unfortunate choice consistently to style various non-Roman communities or commanders as ‘Germanic’ or even ‘German’. The former was in Late Antiquity only applied to those living closest to the Rhine, while the latter is deeply anachronistic for this era. Whether we should already label the Roman East as ‘Byzantine’ in the sixth century is also debatable (chs 6–7). Meanwhile, certain cited works do not appear in the bibliography (e.g. Mathisen 2019), and several errata occur: no Hun or Sueve is ever recorded as officer or senator in the late fourth century (92); the magister officiorium Olympius (c. 408–410) was not a eunuch (101); Flavianus never participated in Magnus Maximus’ usurpation (117); the comes Africae Heraclianus never staged a usurpation (126, 132); Theoderic the Amal was already dead in 535, when supposedly intervening in Rome's pork supply (158); the eastern emperor of 518–527 was Justin I, not Justin II (256, 258); Paulus Diaconus was active in the eight century, not the seventh (273).
At the end of the day, The Falls of Rome is still a work that deserves to be read. It is a synthesis and culmination of decades of research on the clergy and senatorial order of the late antique Urbs by a world-leading authority. It is well written and should definitely be recommended to students interested in how ancient Rome responded to the many crises in its final centuries.
