In her book, Merike Blofield focuses on a compelling research question: How do Catholic countries respond to secularisation, changes in women's social roles and feminist political mobilisation once they become democracies? Of the three countries considered, only Spain legalised divorce and liberalised abortion during its transition to democracy, whereas neither Argentina nor Chile have liberalised abortion. This difference in policy outcome sets Blofield's research agenda. The contrast is all the more striking since the three countries have very similar trajectories. All democratised recently and all are considered ‘late female mobilisation states’. They even share similar levels of church attendance, women's education and women's participation in the work force, and are similar in levels of economic development and urbanisation. The social urgency of solving the problem of illegal abortions existed across all three countries.
In seeking to explain why Chile and Argentina did not liberalise abortion while Spain did, Blofield points to their deep socio-economic inequality as a key factor. She discards basic established assumptions about non-economic policy changes, such as the ‘secularisation thesis’, which holds that in increasingly secular and democratised societies arguments based on individual and women's rights will eventually win out over appeals to tradition and religion. Blofield also refutes the common view that Latin America is more conservative, citing polls in Spain, Argentina and Chile before legalisation in Spain that show a great similarity of values and opinions.
Instead, her argument is built on the notions of interest and solidarity. What most studies relate to culture, gender and politics, Blofield relates to economics. In her view, the Catholic Church and the political right form a strategic alliance against abortion law reform. The right offers political influence to the church, and the church, in turn, accentuates moral individualism that diverts the public from their concern on redistribution. The more unequal the society, the easier it is for domestic elites to influence the media, thereby framing policy, and set the agenda through financing.
Against such a powerful alliance of interests, Blofield argues, it is difficult for feminists with their limited political access to redefine legal abortion as a public health and women rights issue. Only strong social pressure could bring about change. However, deep social inequality in Latin America prevents the emergence of a broad reformist movement, which depends on the participation of the middle classes. The middle classes in this region are indifferent to the suffering of the poor; there is no ‘class solidarity’. According to Blofield, this moral feeling could only arise in the context of a certain social equality, such as exists in Spain, where feminists and the political left were able to mobilise the public in spite of its Catholicism.
Unfortunately, Blofield's theory and methodology lag behind her appealing research question and challenging thesis. While it is laudable that she incorporates inequality as a variable, the book has some serious flaws for any theory-sensitive reader who believes in a ‘thick description’ of social life. Not only do divorce and abortion lose their specificity when swallowed in all-encompassing class categories, but in her attempt to stress the great impact social inequality has on the outcome of social policies, Blofield drastically separates power and interests from culture and gives a rather slim space to the notion of meaning. Social action is equated to strategic and economic calculation (in particular when the action is undertaken by the political right or the elites in general), and beliefs and morals (equated to poll results in this study) are most likely to be the effect of media manipulation. From this analytical perspective, one could hardly expect any social change to take place in unequal societies: the elites have powerful strategic alliances that favour the status quo, the middle classes lack the moral feelings necessary to mobilise for reform, and the lower classes lack time and resources.
Furthermore, when action is only strategic, the category of solidarity, although central to the argument, becomes residual and hard to grasp. The reader does not understand where this moral feeling comes from. And to deprive the ‘strategic’ alliance between the church and the political elites in Catholic Latin America of belief sounds too much like a political manifesto. Since Max Weber, social theory has acknowledged the presence and significance of varied and even contradictory aspects of social life such as values, charisma, tradition and rationality. For Weber, not even the very nature of capitalism could be fully grasped without considering religion. Contemporary theories in gender studies, cultural studies, cultural sociology and post-colonial studies, many of which are inspired by Marx, all emphasize the intersection and inseparability of power and culture. Had Blofield not only looked at polls, but done some gender-sensitive qualitative research, she would have found other power structures besides socio-economic inequality operating in this particular policy field.
Still, in spite of its shortcomings, the book provides valuable empirical information and insights about the political and institutional particularities of each country. Moreover, the comparative nature of the study and the analysis of the interplay between local and international actors (from the Vatican and the international religious right to the liberal institutions and domestic feminists) make the book appealing not only to those interested in the specific issues of divorce and abortion, but also to a wider public.
