No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
Richly descriptive and well documented, Steel and Steelworkers: Race and Class Struggle in Twentieth-Century Pittsburgh by John Hinshaw makes a significant contribution to the growing body of historical research on steel unionism in the twentieth century. Over the past few years, a number of new studies have broadened our understanding of unionization and work practices in the nation's steel mills, by examining in greater detail the patterns of organization in specific mills and mill towns.
Richly descriptive and well documented, Steel and Steelworkers: Race and Class Struggle in Twentieth-Century Pittsburgh by John Hinshaw makes a significant contribution to the growing body of historical research on steel unionism in the twentieth century. Over the past few years, a number of new studies have broadened our understanding of unionization and work practices in the nation's steel mills, by examining in greater detail the patterns of organization in specific mills and mill towns.
Hinshaw focuses on the Pittsburgh area and follows the development and changes in steel unionism from the mid-nineteenth century through the twentieth. His study analyzes the factors that made Pittsburgh a center for world steel production, and how the industrial elite shaped the city and defined its culture. Then, with equal detail, he describes the restructuring of forces that brought about the sweeping destruction of steelmaking capacity in the region. John Hinshaw's approach is ambitious. Framing his narrative through the urban Pittsburgh landscape, Hinshaw weaves a complex story of labor activism set against corporate power and greed. In each chapter he uses a kaleidoscope approach, so that the reader can appreciate Pittsburgh from the standpoint of industry, city politics, working-class life and union organizing.
The fate of steel and of Pittsburgh, Hinshaw argues, should be viewed as the predictable outcome of capitalism, rooted in profit and rarely dirven by genuine market forces. “Deindustrialization,” he writes, “was less a failure on industrialists' part than a strategy” (xvii). The robber barons of the nineteenth century like Andrew Carnegie, followed by the financial entrepreneurs of the Morgan-Mellon tradition, did not make steel because of a commitment to the industry. Their concern, Hinshaw notes, was always to make money. When changing demands, increased globalization, and market competition made it more profitable to invest elsewhere, that's what steel corporations did. Pittsburgh, dominated by financial and political elites, emerged at the end of the century with a new image. The steelworkers, in contrast, would not make the transition. “‘The most livable city,’” writes Hinshaw, “rested upon a city where a third of its workers labored below the poverty line” (251).
Hinshaw does an excellent job of describing the intolerable conditions African Americans encountered as they entered the industry. From the exclusionary practices in the early years, to the pervasive segregation that characterized occupational structures in the mills throughout most of their history, Hinshaw examines black resistance and accommodation. His explanation of how seniority worked to the advantage of white workers has clarity and drama. He demystifies the different forms of seniority by unit, by department, and by classification that locked minorities into dead-end jobs in the worst departments. “The major issue confronting black steelworkers,” he explains, “was how to enforce their seniority rights” (92). He enlivens this account with interviews and firsthand stories from mill workers.
Hinshaw discusses the intransigence of white workers and the union's national leadership to the demands of the African American workers. Hoping to hold on to the cleaner and better-paying jobs, white workers opposed plant-wide seniority and transfer rights. Company policy had directed most black workers into the hot and dirty jobs in steelmaking; white workers maneuvered to keep them there. At the same time, union leadership took a hands-off approach to local problems around discrimination, and focused its civil rights work on federal legislation and anti-communist propaganda. Hinshaw analyzes how cold war politics blunted efforts to challenge discrimination in the union as well as in the mill. “In the USWA's [United Steelworkers of America] civil rights crusade,” he observes, “anticommunism took precedence over all other concerns” (140).
Despite his focus on the conditions and struggles of African American workers, Hinshaw remains unclear whether he perceives race struggle and class struggle as separate or inseparable. The book's subtitle, “Race and Class Struggle in Twentieth-Century Pittsburgh,” creates an expectation of more analysis of the relationship or intersections between race and class. Yet, in the text, Hinshaw offers no theoretical framework. He maintains a separate storyline for African American workers, although their struggle is characterized as integral to the choices and directions taken by the union.
The overall story begins in the nineteenth century with the rise and consolidation of the steel industry. Hinshaw traces organization from the craft unions from the Sons of Vulcan, to the Amalgamated Association of Iron, Steel and Tin Workers. At each step toward broader unionization, the powerful steel interests were able to bust the unions and drive wedges between workers, based on skill, national origin, race, and later gender. The demand for labor during the First World War encouraged renewed attempts at unionization, culminating in the 1919 Great Steel Strike. Especially in the eastern mills around Pittsburgh, American-born workers resented the encroachments made by the foreign-born, and were among the first to cross the strike lines. African Americans were brought in as scabs, but their role was not as decisive as the strike-breaking of the native-born workers. Black workers were, however, blamed for the strike's failure.
The narrative moves ahead to the period of industrial organizing in the thirties, with John L. Lewis' founding of the Committee for Industrial Organization (CIO). The Steel Workers Organizing Committee (SWOC) led the campaign in the mills. The extreme antiunionism of “Little Steel,” including Youngstown Sheet and Tube and Republic Steel, led to violent police repression in many mill towns. In contrast, Myron Taylor at US Steel, surprised the capitalists as well as many steelworkers, by signing a contract in 1937 with Lewis. Although it brought the union into many Pittsburgh area mills, it shortcircuited the grassroots organizing. Union recognition established centralized bargaining and hierarchical leadership.
Like other historians of steel, Hinshaw attributes the overall conservatism of steel unionism to this contractually-instituted top-down authority. It is interesting how many historians have drawn the distinction between the United Steelworkers Union (USWA) and the United Auto Workers Union (UAW) on issues of rank and file militancy. Strong grassroots protest movements have transformed the steel union, from the dues protesters in the fifties, the Ad Hoc Committee of Black Steelworkers and the I.W. Abel challenge in the sixties, to Ed Sadlowski's Fight Back in the seventies. In contrast, the UAW has been a one caucus-ruled union since the 1940s.
Descriptions of women's experiences in the mill and union are another important feature of Steel and Steelworkers. Since so few women worked in the mill until World War II, and the majority was eliminated in the post-war period, women have remained invisible in many steel union narratives. Hinshaw, however, searched the records and found materials on women, on their efforts to get and keep jobs, and their struggles for voice in the union.
The final chapters of Steel and Steelworkers describe the difficult and fruitless efforts of the union and workers to keep the mills open. How the corporations timed and carried out the plant shut downs, kept the initiative in their hands and contributed to the divisions among workers. Faced with the inevitable dismantling of the mills, workers became embattled over tactical differences. “Big steel exerted enormous control over how workers understood deindustrialization,” concludes Hinshaw (236).
John Hinshaw's book provides a well-constructed overview of the rise and fall of steel, its impact on Pittsburgh and on the workers who depended on that industry for a livelihood. His examination of the reinvention of Pittsburgh in the final decades of the century makes an invaluable contribution to the still quite fragmentary history of the industry and the union.