No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
Why should a discourse influential among Alevi religious communities sanctify Kemalism, the Turkish state's militantly secular ideology? Markus Dressler draws on this paradox to organize his monograph on the Alevi religion. The fact that Kemalist regimes have not reciprocated the Alevis' adoration or even treated them very equitably reinforces the riddle.
Alevism, applicable to some 20% of Turkish citizens, is a 20th-century concept. Alevilik also is a reconstruction of the Kızılbaş-tradition (Kızılbaşlık)—an enduring “peripheral” worldview and ethos among Anatolian communities from the early 13th century. The Alevi sanctification of Kemalism, Dressler says, can be sufficiently explained only in respect to Kızılbaşlık. Thus, both traditions and new definitions define his focus.
The Alevi–Kızılbaş nexus works on three inter-connected levels as an explanation of Kemalism's religious sanctification. The exaltation of Atatürk reflects on Turkish religious-political discourse and the centrality-of-identity questions of nation and Islam therein; certain esoteric Alevi religious conceptions elucidate it in history of ideas terms, and both Alevi and the author's own reconstructions of Kızılbaşlık define an encompassing set of dispositions.
Long-term Alevi dispositions, including thought patterns, refer chiefly to “charisma orientation” and a basic outlook breaking down into esoteric notions, chiliasm, as well as latent Mahdi expectations, which emerged through a series of grand rebellions against Sejluk and Osman governments between the 13th and 16th centuries. The 1240 Babaî resurrection marks their beginning, and the revolt of Kalender Çelebi in 1527 marks their ending.
The Safavid tarikat, whose shaykhs had provided leadership for the 16th-century Kızılbaş resurrections (among then Çelebi's), had by then evolved into the Iranian dynasty. Military defeats suffered from the Osmans subsequently contributed to the abrogation of the Safavid dynasty's relations with the Anatolian Kızılbaş. The latter retreated into quietism, which only 20th-century Alevi activism and support of Atatürk's revolution would alter.
The history-of-ideas dimension mainly consists of bāṭiniyya themes: a duality of bāṭin and ẓāhir that, for instance, allows for a conception of Alevism as liberation from the shari

a. Faced with a powerful Islamist movement, this esoterism spurs Alevis to opt for a secular model of society. And beyond that, Alevi Mahdi imagery of Atatürk projects him as harbinger of justice, ending Osman tyranny (p. 228), in bāṭin's victory over the ẓāhir (p. 258).
Finally, the sanctification of Kemalism also emerges from within the Turkish discursive universe, which revolves around questions of national identity and political Islam. Consciousness of Kemalism as a bulwark against the threat of political Islam obviously does not come across in anti-state, Kurdish nationalist Alevism. But it does in all other Alevi sub-discourses discerned by the author—pro-state Turkish national; social revolutionary and state critical; and religious traditional varieties. Beyond these common traits, the pro-state Turkish national discourse sanctifies Kemalism, which allows Alevis to retain Kemalism while relating anew to Alevi religion—the late 1980s saw Alevism's markedly religious revival.
Dressler arranges his reconstruction of the Alevis' long-term dispositions and thought patterns using concepts that generally derive from anthropology, sociology, and social history. The Alevi “longue durée” (Braudel) is conceived of in “worldview” and “ethos” dimensions (Geertz), the latter of which, in the Kızılbaş case, comes to the fore in “charisma loyalty” (Charismaloyalität) that contrasts “scripture loyalty” (Schriftloyalität)—terms that correspond to Weber's Gesetzesund Gesinnungsethik. The ideal types are stated to depend on literacy levels (Goody); they are correlated with “economic and life-form,” and finally subsumed within an overarching dichotomy of “center” (sedentary life-form, literacy, scriptural loyalty, and “periphery”; nomadic life-form, illiteracy, charismatic loyalty).
Though thorough, the work also contains certain unbalances. The author's dichotomous continuities perhaps do not flout his own objections to essentialism, but they do not fuel much consideration of contingencies in shaping Alevism, either. The fact that discourses are more central to this study than modern actors is a token of this. “Situational” analysis here refers to political macro structures rather than to micro contexts of (discursive) interaction. Finally, more than fifty pages on Turkish religious-political discourse (pp. 124–70, 191–200) constitute a project on its own that is largely immaterial to the main argument.
Die alevitische Religion is well edited nonetheless, except for details, such as a footnote accompanying “social boundaries” that contains a mere reference to–and no account at all of—Simmel's, Barth's, and Oberoi's theories (p. 176), and a reference to the anthropologist Ernest Gellner as a “renowned orientalist” (p. 242). Incongruities such as “Wafāīya” (p. 36, n. 78) in the main text versus “Wafā

iyya” in the index and typos and misspellings such as Centres d'Etudes Supérieurs under Shî

isme imâmite (bibliography) remain exceptional.
The author's extensive use of Turkish magazine and newspaper sources adds ethnographic value to a fairly comprehensive bibliography and handy index. Strangely, Dressler fails to discuss how his study improves on or adds to acclaimed monographs on Alevism, such as Krisztina Kehl-Bodrogi's Die Kızılbaş/Aleviten. Untersuchungen über eine esoterische Glaubensgemeinschaft in Anatolien (1988) and Karin Vorhoff's Zwischen Glaube, Nation und neuer Gemeinschaft: Alevitische Identität in der Türkei der Gegenwart (1995). One might mention in his place that in addition to Vorhoff's study, Die alevitische Religion also contains a well-developed argument about a religious and ethnic minority's “secular Islam,” or religious sanctification of secularism. This interesting aspect renders the book broadly relevant to Islamic studies and social science, beyond the interest it is likely to rouse among students of Alevism and of Turkey.