Dr. Yücel Güçlü is a career diplomat in the Turkish Foreign Ministry, who holds a PhD from the University of London. He has written extensively about Turkish diplomats and the Turkomans of Kirkuk. In his latest book, The Armenians and the Allies in Cilicia 1914–1923, Güçlü “analyzes the development and final outcome of the Armenian events in Cilicia between 1914 and 1923. The central goal of the work is to explain why the Armenian conflict emerged and how it was eventually resolved” (p. 2). At the heart of Güçlü's thesis is a presentation of Armenian revolutionary and separatist movements and associated Allied wartime and postwar schemes regarding the region carefully interwoven with Ottoman political and military reactions. Cilicia is the historic name for the broad hinterlands of the Gulf of Iskenderun (or ancient Alexandretta) bounded by the Taurus and Amanus mountains. Its valleys provide a gateway from the Caucasus to the Mediterranean and its mountains a barrier between Syria and western Anatolia. Moreover, the railways connecting Europe and the Middle East run laterally though it, effectively lending Cilicia strategic value in wartime. Competing for domination of Ottoman owned Cilicia in 1914 were its Armenian inhabitants, the Russians, the French, and the British.
Güçlü begins with an exposition of the political implications of the “Armenian Question,” in which he briefly covers the impact of the relocation and massacres of the Armenians on present-day international relations and Turkish–Armenian relations. This is followed by a geopolitical overview. In Chapter 3, Güçlü takes up the issue of “Armenians in Cilicia before the First World War,” in which he examines the rise of the Armenian revolutionary committees. A very contentious and revisionist aspect of this chapter is his explanation of the events culminating in the Adana massacres of April 1909, conventional accounts of which are based largely on an Armenian narrative. This tragic event has long been portrayed as deliberate Ottoman oppression of innocent citizens in which 30,000 Armenians were slaughtered that was somehow triggered by the army's counterrevolution in Istanbul. However, that explanation has never quite fit into the heady exuberance of the second constitutional period and the cause and effect of this origin linkage has never been clear. Using contemporary consular reports, Güçlü unravels the question of origin by exposing the Armenian revolutionary committee's attempts to use a small but incendiary incident to further their own interests, which, in turn, led to massively inappropriate Ottoman responses. Güçlü finds Ottomans and Armenians jointly responsible for both the origin and the escalatory violence that spiraled rapidly out of control. Recognizing that the revolutionary committees were only a small part of the Armenian population, this recasting of Armenians as participants rather than victims is a major shift in the historiography.
Chapter 4 details “Allied Landing Schemes on Cilicia and Armenian Subversion” and outlines the close coordination between the Allies and the Armenian committees regarding preparations for an Allied amphibious invasion near Alexandretta. This story is integral to a full understanding of Ottoman interpretations regarding the nature of the direct threat to their precarious lines of communications. In the following chapter, Güçlü examines what he terms “Measure of self-Defense and Relocations,” and he supports and reaffirms the official Turkish government position that the Ottoman state relocated the eastern Armenians because they were in revolt and threatened national security. He offers both Ottoman and Western reports from the archives of America, Britain, and Turkey to prove his assertions. Chapter 5 is titled “Attempts at Including Cilicia in the Proposed Armenian State.” Güçlü asserts that Armenian efforts to secure Cilicia within an Armenian state began at the outset of World War I and continued through the period of French occupation (which lasted until 1922). He details the unsuccessful, uphill diplomatic battle waged by Armenian nationalists, thousands of whom had returned to Cilicia after the armistice in an attempt to carve out an independent state. The chapter concludes with the story of the French evacuation and the flight of the Armenians, who feared retribution at the hands of the Turks.
Chapter 8 examines the Lausanne Peace Conference (20 November 1922–24 July 1923) and the renewed diplomatic attempts by Armenians to establish a homeland via a treaty. Rather than blame the sad ending of Armenian aspirations on the Allies, Güçlü contends that it was the strength and negotiating skills of the Turkish delegation that led directly to the treaty favoring the new state of Turkey (and simultaneously excluding the possibility of an Armenian state). He concludes by reaffirming the official Turkish position that actual and authentic evidence of an intentional and premeditated Armenian genocide has yet to come to light.
This is a well-written and balanced book that contains a different, and notably politically incorrect, view of the Armenians and Ottomans in Cilicia. At the heart of Güçlü's book is the idea that Armenian nationalists conspired relentlessly with the Western powers before, during, and after World War I to carve out an independent Armenian state from the Ottoman Empire. Güçlü rejects the idea that the Ottomans alone were responsible for what happened to the Armenians during this period and argues that Armenian nationalists consistently contributed to Ottoman perceptions of an Armenian threat during a period of wartime. In turn, the actions of a small number of nationalists had devastating consequences for the many when the Ottomans relocated the entire eastern Armenian population. Unfortunately, even though this book is solidly supported by new research, the author's rejection of the notion of an Armenian genocide weakens the substance of what he has to say.
The Armenians and the Allies in Cilicia 1914–1923 will enrage the Armenian lobby, and Dr. Güçlü is certain to be cast as a genocide denier. However, anyone (including constituents of the Armenian lobby) who is seriously interested in the Armenian relocations should read this book. The reason is that, politics aside, Turkish historical sources have a story to tell. Dr. Güçlü's evidence adds significantly to our understanding of these events, and his interpretations add to the overall narrative of what really happened to the Armenians during World War I. I strongly recommend this book, and I applaud the University of Utah Press for having the courage to print it.
