It is a matter of sadness, at least for this reviewer, that Mughal history has barely a foothold in the British university system. I am not aware, although would be most happy to be proved wrong, that it is taught anywhere as a full undergraduate course. It does, however, have a presence in the odd postgraduate programme. It is a matter of sadness: in part because British students, some of whom are of South Asian origin, are deprived of knowledge of a civilisation with which Britons were much involved for 300 years and which helped to shape the British present; in part because the Royal Asiatic Society, in whose journal this review appears, was, with its mother society the Asiatic Society of Calcutta, a great patron of Mughal knowledge; and in part because it is one of the richest worlds for the historian to explore as in the process one savours political achievement, artistic achievement and remarkable human beings.
Muzaffar Alam and Sanjay Subrahmanyam are two of the world's leading scholars of the Mughal Empire. Since 1994 they have achieved the unusual feat of joint authorship, publishing two books in addition to the one under review and some twenty articles. Alam was educated in Islamic studies outside the western system and then studied history at the Jamia Millia Islamia, Aligarh University and the Jawaharlal Nehru University. . . He brings to the partnership expertise in the Islamic textual tradition in Urdu, Persian and Arabic. Subrahmanyam was trained as a social scientist and completed his initial research at the University of Delhi on the economic history of south India. He brings to the partnership skills in the social sciences, in south Indian languages as well as Dutch, French and Portuguese, interests in early modern history ranging from Iberia to Southeast Asia, and an instinct to question old ways of seeing things and to discover new ones.
This book contains ten joint studies written between 1997 and 2009. It is rounded off by an epilogue on the Mughals in exile and begun by an outstanding historiographical introduction. This latter takes us from the scholar civil-servants of the British Empire and their Indian interlocutors, for instance, Sayyid Ahmad Khan, Shibli Numani and Jadunath Sarkar, through the communalist readings of the mid-twentieth century to the post-independence period in which, first, Muslim and Hindu elites set out to rescue their history from the hands of British ICS historians and, second, a broadly Marxist school, under the leadership of Irfan Habib and based at Aligarh University, came to dominate the field. Amongst the limitations of this school were: that the focus of research was on the Empire from Akbar to Aurangzeb ie 1556–1707; that the idea of the Mughal state as a highly centralised extractive system came to be privileged; and that the eighteenth century inevitably came to be framed by the idea of decline.
The ten themes chosen, the authors tell us, were in part “deliberately conceived to swim against the tide of historiographical orthodoxy”. Two studies demonstrate that the denizens of the Mughal world were more curious about and engaged with the regions beyond the subcontinent than is generally thought. In one we note correspondence between Bahadur Shah, Sultan of Gujarat, and various Portuguese authorities in the 1530s. In another, using his travelogue, we note how an Iranian in the Mughal service, Muhammad Husain Sabzawari, regards the world of mainland and island Southeast Asia. Four studies deal with the early seventeenth century. The first draws on Jesuit materials and the autobiography of a Mughal notable, Asad Beg Qazwini, to assess the way in which the succession from Akbar to Jahangir was managed. The outcome suggests the resilience of Mughal institutions against those who would see the regime as an arbitrary despotism. The second contrasts Asad Beg's views of the Mughal frontier with the Deccan Sultanates with that of an earlier Mughal envoy to the region, the poet Faizi, brother of Akbar's friend and administrator, Abu'l Fazl. He depicts a brief moment in Mughal-Sultanate relations in which diplomacy and money triumphed over force. The third study involves a reworking by Faizi of the Indian story of Nala and Damayanti. We are shown the extent to which Faizi was influenced by the ‘Mirror of Princes’ literature in producing his narrative poem in Persian and its influential afterlife down to the nineteenth century as an Urdu text. The fourth study takes us back to Jesuit sources but also to a recently-discovered text of the first importance, the Majalis-i Jahangiri of the Mughal intellectual, Abdus Sattar ibn Qasim Lahauri. This gives us a ringside seat between 1608 and 1611 at the debates which took place between Catholics and Muslims at Jahangir's court. These can be seen, as the authors suggest, as the precursors of similar debates which took place in the colonial period, although between Protestants and Muslims.
The seventh study emerges from strong competition as the favourite of this reviewer. It is devoted to the munshi, whose numbers grew steadily in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century India, and who was the classic Indian official with whom East India Company officials, who came to govern, had to deal. We are given an excellent idea of what a bureaucratic training was like, in particular the importance of writing well and counting accurately. We are then introduced to the life of a late-seventeenth and early-eighteenth century munshi, a Hindu and probably a Kayasth called Nek Rai, who at an early age wrote his autobiography. We are told: of his upbringing in Allahabad in a family of munshis; of his literary training and absorption in Persian culture; of the high regard he develops for the great Mir Munshi, Abu'l Fazl, through the study of his letters; of his respect for the Chishti saints; and of the many travels of his youthful life as his father, also a munshi, follows his employer from post to post in northern India. The authors suggest that in the emergence of Nek Rai and his fellow munshis we are seeing the growth of a class ‘similar to the Chinese literati’. They also note the cultural and religious inclusiveness of Nek Rai who sees the world through Persian and “all the richness of the ‘secular’ tradition that Indo-Persian represented by the seventeenth century”.
The last three studies move into the eighteenth century “long the neglected stepchild of Mughal historiography”. In the first the emerging succession-state of Arcot in south India is studied using both Persian chronicles and the records of the Dutch East India Company. Amongst other things this piece emphasises the importance of studying together activities on both land and sea in the first thirty years of the seventeenth century, that is both trade and politics, in order to understand the rise of Arcot. The second study returns to the figure of the munshi in the eighteenth century both as an actor in changes in Mughal rule and as witness of them. The outcome is a further consolidation of the image of an ‘Indo-Persian republic of letters’ which is one of the stronger contributions this book makes to our understanding of the ‘long Indian eighteenth century’. The final study examines the writings of an obscure Mughal prince of the late-eighteenth and early-nineteenth century. His major inspiration was Babur's autobiography. This prince did succeed in escaping from his confinement in Delhi's Red Fort, which was the lot of Mughal offspring, but failed to found a kingdom as his ancestor had done. In reflecting on the specific qualities to be found in a true Mughal prince he insists that he must have extraordinary powers (karāmat). These the great Mughals did have, but not this unfortunate man.
This is a wonderful book. Every study opens up new possibilities for research. It should be compulsory reading for all those who wish to work in the field, to teach Mughal history, or to engage with it as students. “Taken together, or read separately”, the authors declare, “these studies form part of a renewal and reorientation of Mughal historiography that has taken place over the last quarter-century and more. These studies can be understood in a variety of ways but there is little doubt that they constitute a gradual erosion (if not dismantling) of the erstwhile hegemony of the ‘Aligarh School’”. That school still has some fire in its belly, but there is no doubt that there is a host of new trends as Alam and Subrahmanyam tell us: there is renewed interest in religion under the Mughals, spurred by the debates around the destruction of the Babri Masjid in 1992, and leading to a return by scholars such as Simon Digby, Richard Eaton, Carl Ernst and Nile Green, to the huge body of materials left by Sufis ; there is a new intellectual history of the period reflected in work on Persian and vernacular literary materials through to music which seeks to take understanding beyond the old paradigm of cultural failure and stasis, as is represented by Katherine Brown's excellent article ‘Did Aurangzeb Ban Music?’, Modern Asian Studies, 2007; there is a new interest in understudied periods of Mughal history, for instance, the early-sixteenth and early-seventeenth centuries; there is the emergence of the regional monograph – Richards on Golconda, Eaton on Bengal, Singh on the Punjab and Hasan on Gujarat; there is the move to integrate art and architectural history with Mughal history in general, represented most notably in the work of Ebba Koch, there is the recent move in Karachi and Lahore, as well as in Qum and Tehran, after decades of neglect in India, to produce editions of important Persian texts; and finally there is the innovative treatment of gender and associated matters by historians such as Rosalind O'Hanlon and Ruby Lal. This book is a landmark in the field. It is also a great pleasure to read.
