In this groundbreaking and indeed monumental work Michael Danti presents to the world, at last, a comprehensive account and interpretation of the Late Bronze Age and early Iron Age material from Hasanlu; it is a magnificent contribution. The site and excavations at Hasanlu are legendary in Near Eastern archaeology; a status which they hold not only because of the breathtaking nature of the finds but equally as a result of the breathtaking lack of final publications. This situation is being finally addressed however. Following on from his publication of the Ilkhanid period remains at Hasanlu (published in 2004), Danti turns his attention to the remains of “Period V”, a designation not quite so straight forward as it might seem. To put this in context, the excavations at Hasanlu were conducted from 1956 to 1977 (more precisely, in two phases, 1956–1964 and 1970–1977) under the direction of Robert Dyson. The multiple excavations paid greater focus to the high mound, with more restricted operations in the low mound. “Period V” remains were found in soundings in both areas. Danti, after setting the scene with a detailed examination of the geographic, geological and environmental background, together with a summary of previous investigations, then turns to the matter central to the volume, Hasanlu Period V. This simple designation masks a complex reality. At the time of the excavation the term Hasanlu V was used to label levels of what the excavators perceived as the “Iron I”. This referred to materials recovered in soundings both on the high mound, where a columned hall and other constructions were uncovered, but more extensively in remains in the lower mound, a large part of which were graves. With the passage of time and scholarship, many refinements to the chronology have been made and the understanding of what Hasanlu V actually covers is now substantially different from its original conception. The defiining material from the beginning was a ceramic assemblage of which two forms were most characteristic - cups in a burnished grey ware (MBW) and vases in a yellowish-white ware with reddish-brown paint (PKW). Another characteristic is the appearance of the columned hall, something which Danti associates with secondary state formation. There are however many complications along the way. Not all “Period V” levels were recognised as such at the time and subsequently, with re-analysis of the material (including the discovery of previously unreported exposures), the definition and the understanding of Period V has evolved. While “Period V” was originally dated to 1200–1000 bce and regarded as “Iron I”, it is now dated to 1450–1250 bce, that is Late Bronze Age, with the designation Iron I now referring to the retrospectively recognised Hasanlu Period IVc (1250–1050 bce). This rectification of the situation is built on firm foundations. Danti bases his reinterpretation on a very detailed reanalysis of the stratigraphy, architecture, and radio carbon dates of the pre-Period IVb levels, meticulously elucidating their true place in the sequence and at the same putting paid to various erroneous conceptions which have crept in, not least the idea that there is a ‘cultural gap’ in the occupation between the Bronze Age and Iron Age in the Ušnu-Solduz region. The hard evidence for this reanalysis is presented with an overview of the ceramics of Hasanlu VIa-IVc, an undertaking of necessity closely bound up with reference to the sequence from Dinkha. Danti documents the material exhaustively with a very detailed survey and analysis of ceramic types of the region culminating in a very visual graphic presentation in the form of charts showing the distribution of each type in time (pp. 272–275 and after p. 292); colour plates also illustrate carbon dates from Hasanlu and Dinkha and the statistical distribution of ware-types. This done, the work moves on to a review of burial culture in the Ušnu-Solduz, presenting and evaluating the evidence for Middle Bronze, Late Bronze and Iron I graves at Hasanlu and Dinkha, and also referring to burials from Dalma Tepe and Hajji Firuz. The burials consist of single and multiple inhumations, pithos burials and stone-lined and mudbrick tombs. Apart from a rich repertoire of ceramics, grave goods include beads (copper-bronze, frit, carnelian, quartz, shell) and copper-bronze artefacts such as blades, spearheads, anklets, pins, rings and earrings; in numerous instances joints of meat were also provided. Of particular interest is grave SK59 in which the deceased was buried with a cylinder seal clenched in the teeth (p. 307), possibly as an act to ‘seal’ the burial (cf. p. 315). The personal ornaments are further discussed in the following chapter by Megan Cifarelli. The work finishes with a conclusion and appendices on archaeological survey and reconnaissance of Ušnu-Solduz, radiocarbon dates, concordances of section numbers and stratum descriptions, catalogues of the Period VIb-Ivc burials at Hasanlu and of the personal ornaments, and data on architectural dimensions; there is also an extensive bibliography. The volume is very richly furnished with plans, sections and drawings throughout and this is complemented by a selection of black and white plates illustrating the excavations from original photographs from the project archives. Finally the volume contains a 1:50,000 removable map of the Solduz valley showing the topography and archaeological sites. In conclusion, this is a monumental, magisterial work. It sets a standard in the publication of the excavations at Hasanlu truly worthy of the project. The dedication and detail which Danti and Cifarelli have brought to this endeavour is inspiring. It will be the defining work on the early Iron Age at Hasanlu and a seminal work in Iranian archaeology for decades to come.
No CrossRef data available.
