Anne Isla’s Economics as Rhetoric: The Thought of Bernard Maris introduces Bernard Maris—one of contemporary France’s most original intellectuals—to a non-French-speaking audience, in the tenth anniversary of his death during the 2015 Charlie Hebdo attack. As one of the rare economists exploring rhetoric, and diverging from Deirdre McCloskey’s (Reference McCloskey1998) approach, Maris offers a unique contribution to heterodox economics.
Beyond presenting Maris’s work, Isla argues (as she further develops in her forthcoming French volume) that his most original contribution lies in his epistemological reflection on the nature of economics and its rhetorical dimension. This book comprises an introduction and five chapters.
In the introduction, Isla portrays Maris as a multifaceted figure: economist, professor, journalist, and public intellectual. She retraces his path from mathematical monetary theory to a rejection of mainstream economics for its failure to address social concerns. His engagement with the history of economic thought, literature, and psychoanalysis led him to embrace heterodox economics.
A central target of Maris’s criticism is the claim of axiological neutrality in dominant economics. For him, transforming economics into a “hard science” via mathematical formalism conceals ideological assumptions and excludes the public from debates. He believes economists should cultivate citizens, not merely advise elites.
An advocate for reducing working time, combating inequality, and preserving the planet, Maris echoes Karl Marx, John Maynard Keynes, and even Joseph Schumpeter in calling for a redefinition of economics as the “struggle of men against one another” (p. 15; based on Maris Reference Maris and Slim2007, p. 191). According to Isla, rhetoric is not merely a method for Maris but the cornerstone of his theoretical innovation.
Chapter One deepens Maris’s argument that mainstream economics is pure rhetoric. He dissects the Walrasian elements of the market—not as analytical tools but as myths. These portray markets as efficient and self-regulating, minimizing real-world complexities and imperfections. Neoclassical reliance on homo economicus reduces individuals to utility- maximizing automatons, devoid of ethical or emotional complexity. This model, Maris insists, legitimizes existing hierarchies under the guise of scientific neutrality.
Maris contends that rhetorical analysis must unearth these narratives. Drawing on Plato’s suspicion of rhetoric and Aristotle’s typology, he shows how economic discourse cloaks normative assumptions. Models invoke logic (logos), gain authority via technical language (ethos), and manipulate public emotion (pathos). For Maris, economics is not a neutral science but a dialectical discourse shaped by persuasion. Its supposed objectivity hides that marginalist economics reintroduces the very values it claims to exclude.
Maris insists that economics must return to the social sciences, embracing reflexivity and performativity. Its role should be to clarify public debate and support democratic decision-making.
Chapter Two examines Maris’s reading of the Methodenstreit and its consequences. According to Maris, the quest for scientific legitimacy blurred the line between normative and positive claims, reducing the discipline’s relevance and locking it into an epistemological impasse. Its distancing from politics led to the disappearance of laws of motion of the economy (and later elimination of macroeconomic laws) and a retreat into microeconomics and agent rationality.
Maris identifies three figures within economics: the scholar, the expert, and the politician. The scholarly role eroded when figures like Anne Robert Jacques Turgot and Adam Smith abandoned political economy’s critical concerns—especially the non-neutrality of money—in favor of equilibrium models. Depoliticized and seeking legitimacy elsewhere, economics turned to the natural sciences, despite lacking experimental capacities.
In this context, Maris critiques the rise of the expert. Since economics lacks empirical verification akin to physics, its models rely on normative assumptions disguised as objective analysis (Varian Reference Varian1989). Maris writes, “What I observe, I observe in the name of what must be” (Maris Reference Maris2008, p. 25). Thus, the expert imposes value judgments while claiming neutrality, subordinating politics to the logic of scarcity.
Isla further explores Maris’s argument that mathematical formalism creates a technocratic elite that excludes public deliberation. Even economists who question markets remain bound by abstraction. Market myths displace democratic ones. For Maris, economic expertise becomes a rhetorical machine distorting both inquiry and democracy. He calls for a reflexive economics, conscious of its limits and accountable to society.
Chapter Three contextualizes Maris’s thought, portraying him as a singular thinker who synthesizes Post-Keynesianism, Marxism, Freudian psychoanalysis, and conventionalism. From Keynes, he adopts uncertainty and collective action; from Marx, the analysis of capitalism’s contradictions, though he rejects historical determinism. Sigmund Freud enables him to theorize economic behavior through unconscious drives—fear, desire, and death.
Maris’s critique is anchored in the idea of “convention,” according to which markets, preferences, and the economy are not natural phenomena but social constructs. Economics, consequently, becomes a space for narrative and ideology. Maris’s originality lies in embedding these theoretical strands within a rhetorical framework. To be a conventionalist is not to embrace relativism but to acknowledge the constructed nature of economic knowledge and the asymmetries of power it conceals. Economics must reveal its own fictions to remain open to democratic contestation. This chapter positions Maris as a philosopher of the economy rather than merely a critic.
Chapter Four showcases Maris’s reflections on capitalism and its future. He views capitalism as a contingent order grounded in accumulation, competition, and the erosion of solidarity. Scarcity and methodological individualism are not neutral theories but discourses of domination. These constructs repress communal life and interdependence. The future of capitalism hinges, therefore, on ethical transformation. Balancing critical pessimism with utopian imagination, Maris envisions economics as a space for moral and political reinvention.
The conclusion synthesizes the epistemological, ethical, and political stakes of Maris’s thought. He is not merely a heterodox economist but a public intellectual urging his fellow economists to rethink their discipline.
His critique is not reformist but calls for reclaiming economics for democracy. Maris envisions economists as engaged citizens, committed to dialogue. The role of the economist is not to predict or prescribe from above but to participate in collective deliberation and offer interpretations that empower rather than silence. For this, economics must shed its pretense of neutrality. Maris’s humanism is also stressed: economics must begin from lived experience—work, ecology, inequality. His legacy is a style of thinking, a “rhetoric of resistance.” Economics, for Maris, must not only describe the world but help change it.
To conclude, Anne Isla’s work presents a timely and necessary contribution to the study of heterodox economic thought. The book offers a lucid reconstruction of Bernard Maris’s intellectual trajectory.
Isla’s study stands out for its thematic cohesion and its ability to bridge disciplines while staying grounded in economic critique. Despite its density, Chapter One, “Choosing Heterodoxy,” is particularly illustrative of Maris’s belief that mainstream economic models are ideological constructs legitimizing dominant narratives. By exposing the internal logic of neoclassical discourse, Maris calls attention to its reductionist anthropology and depoliticizing effects.
From a history of economic thought perspective, Isla’s book functions as both recovery and interpretation, granting Bernard Maris his place among twentieth-century economic dissidents. Isla demonstrates a clear command of Maris’s writings, even if the absence of a clearly articulated history of thought methodological framework—particularly concerning archival practices and criteria for text selection—limits the reader’s insight into the construction and interpretation of the material. This omission, however, does not undermine the scholarly value of the work; instead, Isla’s flexible approach mirrors Maris’s own intellectual style.
Ultimately, Economics as Rhetoric is not only a thoughtful recovery of Bernard Maris’s work but also a powerful reminder of the central role rhetoric plays in the construction of economic knowledge. Through Isla’s interpretation, engaging with Maris becomes an invitation to explore a fundamentally different-from-usual way of practicing economics—one rooted in ethical commitment and inspired by radical democracy. While sharing many points with McCloskey’s rhetorical turn, Maris prefers “blasphemy” (a full methodological break with orthodoxy) over her reformist “heresy.” Isla’s book, in this light, deserves a place in the growing literature that seeks to recover pluralism, meaning, and critical reflexivity in economic thought.
