In Writing with Scissors: American Scrapbooks from the Civil War to the Harlem Renaissance, Ellen Gruber Garvey highlights the wealth of information that can be uncovered by carefully exploring one type of archival document in depth. Garvey's thorough examination of hundreds of scrapbooks reveals not only the surprising and interesting purposes scrapbooks fulfilled for their makers, but also the ways in which personal scrapbooks were political statements important to a given community. Garvey discovers in scrapbooks historical evidence unavailable by other means, such as the African American identity of a religious figure who publicly passed as white (158) and marginal notes by scrapbook creators that reveal the authorship of formerly anonymous newspaper pieces (191). Garvey's accounts of scrapbooks are at times intensely gripping, as when she documents a woman's 1870 attempt to hide her family's recent slaveholding by pasting over a slave ledger (58–59). At other times, the narrative is enjoyably witty, as with Mark Twain's advertisement for his patented scrapbook, which he claimed would provide an impressive public service to the nation by reducing profanity from frustrated scrapbook makers (62–64).
Garvey proposes that the unique importance of scrapbooks as compared with other types of archived documents is their true democratic nature: “people who occupied positions far from political power or social authority” could create scrapbooks and “thereby enhance their own cultural authority” (209). Given this thesis, the heart of the book lies in the sections that cover scrapbook makers who were marginalized in American society at the time of their scrapbook creation. Chapter 4 on African American scrapbooks demonstrates that black Americans had an urgent need to write history with scissors because the white press either ignored or condescended to them. Later, Garvey makes the same point for women's rights activists (197).
At the turn of the twentieth century, when not enough books on black history were being published, scrapbook collections played an important role in the intellectual life of African American communities; contemporary readers could explore private museums and libraries containing encyclopedic scrapbooks (168). Scrapbooks made by African Americans highlighted the unfolding history white people hid, misrepresented, or ignored. Using the era's abundant cheap newspapers, African Americans compiled history on their own terms, with scrapbooks that celebrated the lives and achievements of ordinary blacks (162–63, 171). Garvey's analysis of how scrapbook makers carefully documented the white press's active promotion of lynching (150) dramatically underscores her theme of the important personal-as-political nature of scrapbooks (152–53). Garvey does not, however, discuss whether the African American scrapbooks contained any clipped newspaper accounts of the novel Adventures of Huckleberry Finn to reveal what black readers thought of Twain's book, thereby linking this chapter with her prior one on Mark Twain.
When faced with a finished scrapbook, it can be difficult to decipher the order of assembly behind the finished product (21). Gleaning insight from archived scrapbooks, therefore, often requires a careful reading and additional research, which Garvey expertly executes. Unlike the modern scrapbooking hobby, which tends to focus on remembrances of an individual or familial past, the historical scrapbooks covered in Writing with Scissors were often used to store information the authors believed would help them in the future. For example, a scrapbook filled with newspaper clippings of home remedies for livestock ailments was made by a university graduate teaching in the East, who saved articles for the life she thought she might one day lead on a farm in the West (3).
Writing with Scissors is generously illustrated, reproducing the primary sources the author explored. Garvey exhibits a thorough engagement with recent historiography and an appropriately heavy reliance on primary sources. In addition, she intriguingly proposes that there are many connections between nineteenth-century scrapbooks and modern ways of coping with an abundance of information in the digital age. In particular, Garvey sees a clear link between scrapbooks and today's internet reader applications in which items are isolated from their original context to create “new knowledge” in another form (249, 251).
Not every chapter of the book is equally well-written. An early section on anonymity is dry and an overlong digression from scrapbooking. The chapter on women's rights activists strays too far into a history of their activism, rather than staying grounded in their scrapbooks. Chapter 6 begins with redundancies from the introduction and is stridently defensive of scrapbooks’ worthiness to be included in archives where, Garvey urges, they be kept in one piece as makers intended. This essay is strikingly out of place near the end of a book that ably proves how useful and interesting scrapbooks can be. Also accession information found on many pages belongs in footnotes, as relevance to the themes of the book is not apparent. Quibbles with various sections aside, this interesting, engaging book is recommended.
