The present volume represents the proceedings of a colloquium by the same name, organised by Alexandra Dardenay, Nicolas Laubry and the École française de Rome, in June 2018. The intent of the meeting was to explore the anthropology of the Roman domestic sphere, including activities of its inhabitants, daily life, behaviours, rituals and family structure. Although a social approach to the Roman house is not new, the editors of this volume argue that geographers have tended to ignore domestic space (8), while classicists, architectural historians and archaeologists have limited their investigations to text-based, formalist/architectural and material/artefactual approaches respectively. The editors here promote a more integrated, holistic approach in which ‘anthropological’ methods and critical theory (e.g. sensory archaeology, visual culture, gender or subaltern studies) drive research beyond the limitations of ‘traditional’ methodologies (8–9).
Anthropology of Roman Housing thus presents research by scholars who approach their research questions using multiple or mixed methodologies. The collection constitutes ‘a sampling of aims, problems and methods’ (16) and yet feels cohesive in its overall presentation. The first essay, by Sandra Zanella, rightly occupies the first position, providing an overview of scholarship on Roman domestic space, starting with the codification of Vitruvian terminology, its application to architectural spaces and the problematic ascription of behaviours to labelled spaces. She also identifies the early anthropological approach of Andrew Wallace-Hadrill, artefact assemblage analysis (Penelope Allison) and spatial syntax (Mark Grahame) and GIS (Michael Anderson) analyses in Roman houses as key methodologies in the field. Her essay closes by demanding an interdisciplinary approach, in line with the aim of the volume.
The essays that follow are not grouped by topic or methodology, though the first three examine the Roman house and its spaces via the mining of legacy data and artefactual finds (Antonella Coralini) and the analysis of room articulation, vision/viewsheds, access and décor in houses of Herculaneum (James N. Andrews) and Pompeii (Anna Anguissola). These scholars demonstrate the benefits of integrating approaches to understand how houses and their spaces were used in the months or years prior to the Vesuvian eruption of 79 c.e. Through the analysis of artefact finds as documented in early excavation reports, Coralini suggests that the Casa del Centenario (IX.8.3, 6, Pompeii) had lost its primary domestic function in its final years and took on a commercial function, where rooms were opened to paying guests. Her argument, however, is in part predicated on the belief that we know how specific domestic spaces were used and assumes that some household spaces/rooms could not have fulfilled domestic and commercial functions simultaneously.
Andrews explores the social functions of the house in Herculaneum, where upper floors were used to reinforce and display the home-owner's status. The subtitle of his chapter implies a careful analysis of seasonality. However, his discussion of temporality/seasonality is quite generic and could have been improved by incorporating an examination of building orientation and solar-temporal data. Finally, Anguissola explores the inclusion of villa-like features (e.g. views of the countryside or the sequencing of interior spaces) in urban homes along the southern cliffs of Pompeii, which evoked elements of villa life (e.g. otium and the salubritas of nature) and accommodated associated behaviours. In her analysis of ‘urban villas’, she argues for a more nuanced arrangement of social and familial, ‘public’ and ‘private’, spaces.
The volume pivots on two essays: a chapter by Alain Bouet on latrines, followed by a contribution by Marin Mauger on the lares and household lararia. Readers hoping for a rich cultural study of domestic latrines from Bouet will be disappointed, as his survey focuses more on latrine design and chamber-pot form. Consequently, while he offers musings regarding user privacy, toilet-rooms as indicators of social status and the possibility that some domestic latrines may have been opened to the public, no one topic was investigated in detail. Moreover, rather than presenting evidence from a single Roman town, Bouet presents latrines from disparate sites, house types and public and private settings, all of which may have functioned in culturally specific ways. By contrast, Mauger's detailed study explores how lararium locations, visibility, imagery and associated cult practices defined and shaped the perception of household space. By analysing the placement and iconography of lararia, Mauger argues that the lares and attendant deities served to designate a space as domestic, distinguish one household from another (e.g. in the Casa a Graticcio, Herculaneum), and demarcate the home as a sacred territory.
The volume closes with five essays that explore the relationship of domestic space to specific householders (i.e. women, ethnic/social groups and infants) via various methodologies. Ria Berg examines gendered artefact assemblages and their distribution to propose the presence of a women's room at or near the household tablinum in various Pompeian houses. Polly Lohmann aims to locate women or women's domestic, short-term activities in Pompeian houses through an analysis of graffiti. Unfortunately, she notes, female names are often limited to a ‘tag’ (isolated name), a brief greeting or sexualised messages. Also, most graffiti appear to have been written by men and were addressed to female slaves with Greek cognomina. Thus, while the evidence suggests that women could read, ‘female household members remain invisible in many Pompeian residences’ (235).
Mantha Zarmakoupi analyses architecture and domestic décor to explore the question of ethnic Italian identity (Ῥωμαῖος/Romaios, pl. -oi) at Delos, suggesting that Romaioi expressed their Roman/Italic ethnicity by placing lararia with traditional Roman rituals on house façades, incorporating commercial space into their homes to display economic status and displaying bilingual inscriptions in highly visible areas or heavily trafficked passageways. Like Zamakoupi, Jesús Bermejo Tirado proposes a relationship between the house forms in Roman Celtiberia, onomastic traditions and the organisation of household families. In this chapter, he identifies three housing types and name structures (e.g. the Roman tria nomina), and argues that differing forms reflect changes in family structure across the late Republican, Augustan and late Roman periods.
Nathalie Baills-Barré and Mélissa Tirel close the volume with their research on child burials found in or near houses and not in customary burial sites outside the city. Through an analysis of 866 individuals across 200 sites in Roman Gaul, they argue that the inhumation of infants (<6 months) or young children (<5 years) reflected unique rituals in which youngsters were permitted alternative burial locations because they were considered too young for cremation (cf. Plin., HN 7.72; Juv., Sat. 7.135–140; and Fulgentius Expositio Sermonum Antiquorum 7).
Overall, this volume — with chapters in English, French and Italian — collects eleven rich essays that will be valuable to scholars in the field. While many of the methodologies are not ‘new’, the practice of combining methods for a more holistic approach proves to be valuable. The publication is nicely produced with high-quality, clear images, although this reviewer found the lack of chapter bibliographies (or a compiled bibliography) somewhat frustrating. Finally, the expense of the volume and the lack of a digital e-book may limit access to this important work of scholarship.
