Professor Goldworth's observations and analysis are cogent and interesting. Fortunately, though perhaps not for the same reasons outlined by him, physicians have been aware of the legal and ethical risks involved whenever treatments, however well meaning, entail the risk of death. Physicians have endeavored to avoid the risk of “playing God” with their patients, either in fact or by appearance. Thus, though the law varies somewhat from state to state and policies differ somewhat between hospitals, decisions to discontinue support, make a patient “DNR,” or declare a patient “brain dead” usually require the concurrence of more than one physician, frequently require that one of those physicians has not been involved directly in the patient's care, and recommend or even require the review by an ethics committee. Certainly, in common practice, the care of patients in hospitals or hospices under circumstances such as the one Goldworth envisions is a collaborative process, with input from nursing and more than one physician in most cases. The greater risk may exist for patients being treated at home by a single practitioner. Even in such situations, homecare personnel and pharmacists would be aware of what was going on and would be in a position to afford some safeguards. Large doses of pain medication would not result in demise unless the decision had already been made not to intubate and place the patient on life-support; otherwise such an act clearly would be immoral and illegal.
Additionally, in today's world, almost all patients or their legal representatives have the opportunity to express their personal wishes and philosophy regarding pain control and prolongation of dying before such a situation arises. This has been advocated by physician leadership for some time and further helps the physician to know that the care being rendered is for the right moral reason and that they are not fooling themselves.
Finally, we have some problem with the conclusion that the morality of a physician's actions can only be judged by their consequences. Certainly, the understanding of consequences is critical to imparting morality to a choice. However, the right procedure can be performed for the best of reasons, complications can occur, and death result. It would be foolish to judge that as murder or immoral. Furthermore, unnecessary treatments can be prescribed for purely venal reasons, no harm result, and indeed the patient may feel “better” from a placebo effect. Yet it would be incongruous to judge this as moral or appropriate based solely on the consequences.
Clearly, the actions of a physician must be judged upon intent first and competence second. Judging intent is difficult, which is why it is prudent and wise for physicians in situations of moral uncertainty to work in concert with the patient, the family, others in the care team, clergy, and ethicists to ensure that their moral thinking is transparent and correct. Competence should be judged by a jury of the physician's peers, that is, “peer review,” which requires an appreciation of medical uncertainty and the unpredictability of side effects.
