In Boundaries Undermined, Delwar Hussain looks at the boundaries—political, social, sexual—that operate in a border region, in a divided village that lies partly in India and partly in Bangladesh. As an anthropologist, he has keen insight into the events, people, and surroundings that create the livelihood, conflicts, and way of life in these remote villages. As the story of the twin villages of Boropani and Khonighat unfolds, one has to remember that the colonial history of creating the nation-state has always been immersed in violence. In the aftermath of partition, the earlier colonial power play reemerged in the process of modernization as economic competition; in the current neoliberal state, the perennial conflict is even more complicated by the presence of new sets of actors besides the all-powerful state.
In five chapters, the history, the present, and, more importantly, the lack of any different future is captured in the fluid narration and makes one wonder whether the benign neglect of the state(s) toward this region can be interpreted as a mixed blessing or not. This narrative describes the colonial makings of the border, the state's reclamation of such borders, and the realm of possibilities when the state relegates such issues to global powers and allows neoliberalism to define economic interests. Hussain describes the economic trajectory of the two villages, tied to the demand for coal for a cement factory, in chapter 1, while chapter 2 chronicles the aftermath of economic downturn. Chapter 3 is about the sexual lives of the borderland, which seem to be as ambiguous as the border itself. Chapter 4 documents the role of new players, NGOs, in the neoliberal economy. A detailed analysis of the religious and cultural practices in the borderland, which are much more tolerant than the hinterlands, is provided in chapter 5.
Hussain takes us through the practices of everyday life on the border and shows us how the border can be simultaneously upheld and subverted through normal acts of livelihood. The descriptions and analyses of economic endeavors that are mostly illegal, and the sociocultural practices that seem far more permissive than those in the countries where these villages are located, raise the question of the extent to which the nation-state remains present on the border. The political boundaries are no doubt set by the states, but the people undermine these boundaries, often for survival and pragmatic reasons, even though their whole lives are determined by these very boundaries. Hussain introduces us to this paradox through the voices of the inhabitants, who are not presented as victims, but as agents making life choices in spite of the exploitation by the traders and the aggression shown by the gatekeepers of the state.
The livelihood of the people of the two villages of Boropani depends on the cross-border coal trade, and the illicit small entrepreneurs thrive on the labor of ill-paid migrant workers. The people, especially the laborers, have to tackle all kinds of boundaries, imposed from above by the state and from within by societal norms. A substantial number of migrant workers are hijras, or transgender people, who are able to carry out a double life as both males with wives and children, and as lovers, choosing their own gender identity. The laborers may be economically deprived, but they have been able to carve out this no-man's land where they feel safe with their sexual preferences and practices.
Hussain mentions the existence of indigenous people, but they do not appear much in the book. In spite of the presence of migrant workers, conflict between the local people and the newcomers seems to be absent. It is not religious conflict but religious harmony that seems to dominate the border in this era of peak intolerance in both India and Bangladesh. At the same time, class resentment is seething in Khonighat, the village that was once prosperous because of a cement factory and that plunged into dire poverty after it closed. The abandoned limestone laborers cannot let go of their anger and bitterness towards the cross-border coal traders who now monopolize the border economy.
While issues besetting nation-states like India and Bangladesh, religious groups such as Hindus and Muslims, and subalterns like adivasi (indigenous) and transgender people comprise the book's plotline, the story is often told from the perspective of a single person who breathes and struggles in the region. What is impressive is how easily Hussain has connected these narratives with other border situations throughout the world.
Boundaries Undermined is an important addition to the literature on multifaceted issues of borders and boundaries; all the more so because it focuses on a quiet and neglected part of the global frontiers, most of which are now mired in blood, tears, and senseless violence. This book should be read by all scholars and students who are curious about political borders and globalization, colonial history and modernization, and social boundaries and their countervailing resistances.
