Since the beginning of systematic fieldwork in North Africa during the 19th c., Algeria has been known as a country with an exceptional rich ancient heritage and many unique archaeological monuments. Paradoxically, this country remains among the Mediterranean's least-visited spots. While Tunisia and Morocco established efficient tourism systems to present and to exploit their ancient past after independence, Algeria – for political, ethnic, religious, and ideological, but also administrative and infrastructural reasons – remains more isolated in the Maghreb. Even many scholars familiar with the importance of the country still do not know how to approach it. This book provides an archaeologically well-founded invitation for both scholars and laypeople to visit this country, and it is in fact its first archaeological guide in English. It is the successor of a French vademecum illustré from 2003, translated and revised by P. Kenrick.Footnote 1 One has to bear in mind that the predecessor was never meant as a real guide, but more as a presentation of Algeria's antiquity, for it appeared on the occasion of the “Djazaïr, l'année de l'Algérie”, celebrated in 2003 in France. Unlike the original, the English translation's pocket format is eminently suitable for journeys. Although it comprises fewer sites than the volume from 2003, it gives more substantial information on the selected sites. It is divided into a historical introduction (pre-Roman to Byzantine times), followed by three sections on the main Roman provinces within the borders of Algeria: Mauretania Caesariensis, Numidia, and Africa Proconsularis. Within these three chapters the most important and visitable sites of (mainly Roman) Algeria are presented, complemented by a useful glossary of some technical terms, a short bibliography, a chronological timeline, and a topographical and onomastic index.
One might be surprised by a longer review in this academic journal of a guidebook written for both scholars and a broader audience. However, Algeria provides a first English synthesis and therefore a much-needed approach to an area with enormous scientific potential. Although the country's heritage has often been considered important, it is far from being adequately represented in (non-francophone) archaeological communities. This book should thus be acknowledged as a critical reference point, and an important step for further international research in this region. Since it also stimulates reflection on the role of archaeology in debates of identity negotiated throughout a period of profound political, cultural, and social transformations during the past 70 years, it is certainly of high and immediate academic relevance. Despite its format as a guide, which bears certain limitations, the publication of updated and independent on-site views from the field and museums is highly welcome, given the stagnation of Algerian archaeology (see below). The critical parts of this review should to some degree be attributed to the limited format (and dual audience) of the guidebook, which of course could not allude to all scholarly issues in detail. My remarks should, therefore, be considered as starting references for future thoughts that might be more clearly addressed in a larger-scale scholarly monograph.
Given the book's main goal, many practical features for visits are given: several discussed sites are equipped with new useful advice on entrances of archaeological zones and museums not provided in the preceding book (e.g. figs. 48, 92, 99, 194, 249, 277). It would, however, have been helpful to signal systematically any approximate limitations on the publicly accessible archaeological zones (such as fig. 194). This would have provided substantial help for orientation in terrains that are often far from easy to explore, especially in cities that are still inhabited (e.g. Sétif, Madauros, or Theveste, figs. 92, 286, 293). For Algiers, Guelma, and Constantine one regrets the absence of site plans. Nonetheless, the book provides the user with special advice on which details to pay attention to, where to insist on access, and where a visit is less pressing (e.g. 96, 103, 159, 179, 199, 246). The addition of opening hours, exact addresses (especially for museums and offices for photo permissions), and entry prices might have been helpful tools as well. This would have supported users in planning their journeys and avoiding disappointment once they arrive at an archaeological site/museum that does not actually exist anymore or is closed to the public (e.g. Timgad (215) and Theveste (275), but true for many other examples cited below).
The book's most substantial achievement, both for a broader public and for scientific research, is its lavish and mostly high-quality illustrations. The images, a good portion of which were recently reproduced by P. Kenrick, and the detailed plans are a highly convenient help for site visits. They often show the current state and also obstacles (such as vegetation or fences) to access of monuments. Some illustrations (e.g. figs. 105, 128) count among the few pictures that have ever been published of the respective monuments. Fig. 283 shows tombstones from Khamissa that were only described in CIL 8, nearly 150 years ago. The colored picture of the remarkable Antistii altar from Thibilis shows traces of ancient polychromy (fig. 276). These images are of great interest for future academic studies. Carefully redrawn detail plans and their explanations, especially of urban quarters, baths, or houses (e.g. figs. 102, 103) provide beneficial orientation in the field and new citable references for evidence mostly excavated over a century ago. The visitor is enlightened by modern and mythological anecdotes (yellow boxes) that one might expect in a guide of this genre (75, 78). The numerous paraphrased inscriptions add texture to the ruins the visitor is observing (193–94). Finally, dubious reconstructions or restorations are signaled (115, 117, 126, 127, 214), in order to distinguish ancient evidence from modern additions.
A general limitation of the guidebook format is that it does not leave much room for discussion of the current state of Algerian archaeology and the role that antiquity plays in this country: two aspects with which a visitor is, however, always and ubiquitously confronted. The chapter ‘History of research’ (17–21) practically ends with Algeria's independence in 1962, barring a half-page on the postcolonial period (21). I will therefore try to provide here a complementary sketch (far from being complete by itself) of the situation from 1962 to the present, since my own experience on Algerian sites taught me that a visitor without this contextual background can barely understand the critical state of many sites and of Algerian archaeology in general.
The three decades after 1962 were marked by significant progress in the consolidation and internationalization of Algeria's archaeology. Numerous national projects were launched (Theveste: necropolis 1976–78; Tipasa: Matarès 1968–74; Djeddars: 1967–70), but so were international projects, in cooperation with French (Sétif: E necropolis 1962–67; basilicae 1960–64; Tiddis: rampart 1966; E necropolis 1967; Theveste: amphitheater 1965–68; St. Crispine 1965–67; Rusguniae: baths 1962–67; Lambaesis: Aesculapium 1988; Hippo: several spots 1964–65; Tipasa: several necropoleis 1963–1970s; Cherchell: several necropoleis and survey 1970–1990s; Algerian museums: lamps and sigillata 1970–1990s), German (Tipasa: St. Salsa 1965–67; Theveste: St. Crispine, 1965–68; Siga: 1977–80; Lambaesis: ‘pré-fabrica’ and praetorium 1972–73; ‘royal mausolea’ 1974–80), Italian (Ubus valley: survey 1969–72; Nador: villa 1972–74), British (Cherchell: forum 1977–81) and American scholars (Sétif: Late Antique/Islamic quarter 1977–84; Lambaesis: Aesculapium 1988; Belezma: survey 1991). The Bulletin d'Archéologie Algérienne issued 7 volumes and 7 supplementary monographs on fieldwork from 1962 to 1991. Although pre-Roman and early Islamic evidence was now slowly promoted (see 21), the Roman period was still at the center of research. However, in the early 1990s, archaeological activity and the status of sites and museums gradually declined, because of the dramatic civil war and increased bureaucratic obstacles.Footnote 2 Even where there have been (and still are) many local rescue excavations, it is impossible to assess their extent (even for Algerian scholars), owing to the lack of structured publication formats.
In the new millennium, international projects in Algeria have been limited, only a few of which are cited in the book. From 2000 to 2006 an Algerian–French mission worked on a new book on Hippo Regius (without excavations; 307). Several objects were exhibited in 2003 in France, 2003–4 in Italy, and 2009 in Germany. In Cherchell, Algerian–French excavations took place in 2003; the ‘Old Museum’ has been being restructured by an Algerian–German team since 2008; and the site's inscriptions are being made accessible in a French–Algerian database initiated in 2010. An Italian–Algerian exposition, “I Fenici in Algeria,” was published in 2011. In Lambaesis, rescue excavations/restorations in two villae (183) have been conducted by an Algerian–French team since 2006. In Algiers, Algerian–French excavations took place at the ‘place de martyrs’ (77) from 2009 onwards, and several international teams analyzed marble provenience, architecture, and sculpture in some Algerian museums/sites (ca. 2006–15). One should add an Italian–Algerian survey in the south of Hippo (2003–9), and Algerian–French missions on rescue archaeology (2009–18), on academic training (2018–22), and on the quarries of Timgad (2019). Most of the field projects still await final publication. Several reports of current projects appeared only in Arabic, highly impeding international perception and accelerating scientific isolation (a law requiring reports to be written in Arabic was revised only in 2012). Yet bureaucratic paralysis and governmental inactivity have led to the creation of regional societies: APPAT (Association pour la protection du patrimoine archéologique de Tiaret, 1992), Castellum Tingitanum (Association Athar Chlef, 2001), Aouras (Société d’études et de recherche sur l'Aurès antique, with a journal, 2003), Minerve (Tébessa, 2006), and ASPPA (Association pour la sauvegarde et la promotion du patrimoine archéologique, with the journal Ikosim, 2012) and the University of Algiers’ journal ATHAR (1992). These provide regional platforms for heritage protection, education, and the publication of new findings.Footnote 3 In 2019, the National Research Centre (CNRA) revived the Bulletin d'Archéologie Algérienne.
However, there is a series of other serious challenges which the country's authorities for cultural heritage are facing today. This guide addresses some of them, but they are in fact far more numerous: deliberate dismantling and destruction of monuments (Lambaesis, 176), stone quarrying, uncontrolled urbanization in zones non aedificandi (Lambaesis again, 170), vandalism, alarming pollution (cited only at 175, 277), vegetation/inundation (e.g. Hippo's entire southwest area, 246, but also its north area, and Tipasa's west necropolis), illegal excavation, looting, and questionable restorations (e.g. in Khamissa, Cuicul, and Medracen). Several sites described in this book and many others have been erased since 1962 (e.g. large parts of the necropoleis, all temples, and the circus of Cherchell; the Matarès necropolis in Tipasa, the Ceres temple, the Roman bridge (1986), the aqueduct (1987), and two necropoleis (1993) of Hippo; an entire pre-Roman quarter in Cirta; vast parts of Lambaesis’ haute ville presented in fig. 187; several classified archaeological zones in Algiers; etc.). These sites simply cannot be visited anymore. Other sites mentioned in the guide are not open to the public (e.g. the ‘Hadrianic cisterns’ in Hippo, 244; the east baths in Cherchell), or were never firmly localized on the ground (e.g. the tophet in Tipasa signaled in fig. 48) or have photography restrictions (e.g. Cherchell's theater and harbor zone, which are occupied by military facilities). Considering the current reality in the field, it is questionable to condemn only ‘French’ spoliation and destruction of antiquities during the colonial era (e.g. 38, 54, 93, 174, 246, 259, 272, 276, 277, 284). These problems with and threats to cultural heritage are daily facts in Algeria. Although they are being addressed and combated by some Algerian scholars (and in social media and the press),Footnote 4 improvement will only happen if the value of protection of pre-Islamic heritage is acknowledged on a broader basis in Algeria's modern society.
Interestingly, there always was (and still is) a desire to link Algerian identity to the classical history of the country.Footnote 5 While the French were keen to prove their role as successors of Rome in Algeria (18–20), the time after independence was marked by a difficult relationship to the country's pre-Islamic past. Nevertheless, there was increasing interest in the pre-Roman period, especially in the Numidian (Berber) kings, who presented welcome figures of indigenous resistance and state formation. The ‘royal tombs’ (Beni Rhénane, 24; Kbour Roumia, 75; El Khroub, 161; Medracen, 166) have produced uncountable attributions to specific kings, even if no burial owner could (and probably ever will) be identified with certainty. Still, these monuments are branded as national lieux de mémoire and visitors can experience this in a very direct way.Footnote 6 While the mausolea (including the Djeddars) were inscribed into the tentative UNESCO list in 2002, their constant degradation took place at the very same time.Footnote 7 Most recently, the ‘national heroes’ Massinissa and Jugurtha were celebrated extensively by several state-protected colloquia (all quickly published), by popular literature, and, more significantly, by official honorific monuments.Footnote 8 In 2017 and 2019, King Massinissa received two emblematic statues in Louta (near Bejaja) and Algiers.
These monuments with their multilingual inscriptions (among them Tifinagh) are not only designed to root modern Algeria into a glorious ‘indigenous’ past, but also to reconcile Algeria's population through a common history. The Roman and Christian pasts – the main chronological focus of the guide – are still perceived somewhat ambiguously. On the one hand, sites such as Timgad, Cuicul, Tipasa, or Algiers, all inscribed in the UNESCO list from 1982 to 2002, suffered severely under modern ‘festivales’ organized annually in their ruins and under systematic destruction by modern public works.Footnote 9 On the other hand, the Roman sites still provide the best potential for tourism. Inhabitants of Tipasa are proud of their Roman heritage (the site is always crowded), just as Annabis still celebrate the grandeur of St. Augustine in Hippo (with annual festivities in the erroneously localized basilica pacis in the heavily restored ‘Christian quarter’ (239)).Footnote 10
By following the general outline of the 2003 book and certainly also because of the limited space of the guidebook, Algeria does not fully represent the current state of archaeological research (see 307). Even if there had been limited fieldwork during the last two decades in Algeria, several important studies on the country's ancient past have appeared. While one welcomes the integration of T. Amraoui's book and of recent results of the teams led by D. Mattingly in the African frontier zones (307), more recent groundbreaking (and anglophone) studies were not incorporated.Footnote 11 In particular, the pre-Roman and Vandal periods would have benefited from revision. Starting North Africa's history with the arrival of the Phoenicians (2–3), along with the statement that “it is impossible to say anything about [the indigenous societies] before the fourth century BC” (2), reflects an outdated perspective and stands in contradiction to the current branding of the pre-Roman cultures in Algeria described above. Today, we know on firm archaeological grounds that urbanization, agriculture, metallurgy, long-distance trade, and many other achievements were not imported by Phoenicians to the coasts of North Africa, but were developed among the societies of North Africa's interior as early as the 10th–8th c. BCE.Footnote 12 There have been two decades of intensive work on the Vandal period,Footnote 13 the results of which have totally shifted away from the old scenario of a devastated Africa as suggested by literary sources (232–33). All supposed ‘Vandal destructions’ (33, 54, 61, 68, 233, 252) are modern narratives that cannot be proven archaeologically. On the contrary, the veritable boom of church construction, as well as the majority of Late Antique North African mosaics, appears to fall exactly between the mid-5th and mid-6th c. CE. The ‘Vandal century’ was therefore a thriving period, as also shown by results from surveys and from numismatic, epigraphic, and ceramic analysis. In my opinion, we should start to present these ‘re-written periods’ in books, especially if they address a broader audience. Several minor mistakes could also be corrected in a next edition of this guide, if there is the intention to produce such.Footnote 14
Summing up, this book is a successful and important first step to attract a wider public as well as scholars to visit the extraordinary ancient remains of Algeria. It opens a broad panorama for all people interested in this country to which access is still complex on different levels. Although it has some lacunae in terms of spelling out post-1962 problems with the protection of the country's heritage, in terms of acknowledging the current state of research and in terms of providing some more practical hints to the real situation on the sites themselves, this selective guide will be a great first service for visitors and scholars willing to explore the rich Algerian past.
