In Stone Tower: The Political Theater of Arthur Miller, Jeffrey D. Mason offers a reexamination of the playwright's major works and political involvements, mixing theory, history, and dramatic analysis to argue that Miller's body of work fundamentally revolves around the deployment of and reaction to societal power. The book's title refers to the scenic backdrop for After the Fall, the nearly destroyed stone tower left over from a German concentration camp that dominates the landscape of the play. This symbol of the relationship between power and the individual provides the metaphoric framework for Mason's investigation. In his brief opening chapter, Mason outlines his agenda using Augusto Boal's vision of theatre as a political activity, Tony Kushner's intersection of the personal and political, and a Foucauldian lens defining politics as working “in terms of compulsion and coercion” (4). He considers the way in which Miller's work depicts the acquisition, deployment, and negotiation of power in social situations, and the fate of individuals who resist that power. This agenda is executed consistently throughout the book, though Mason's methodology varies from chapter to chapter, some relying entirely on his own close readings, others drawing usefully on the established work of other historians and theorists.
The second, much longer chapter, “The Playwright as Player,” investigates Miller's status as a political activist and essayist, mixing historical testimony from the HUAC trials with later reflections from various essays as well as Timebends, the playwright's autobiography. Including comments from Miller on topics that range from Richard Nixon to George W. Bush to the Vietnam War, Mason provides a usefully varied perspective, laying the groundwork for the subsequent chapters. Mason frames Miller as somewhat of a centrist, a man who harbors “deeply cynical suspicion of institutionalized power and its processes” (72) while simultaneously eschewing true radicalism, instead choosing to work inside the existing political system. Following his overview of Miller's political life as documented by history and the playwright's own words, Mason proceeds in the next five chapters to apply these ideas to Miller's body of work. Each chapter offers extensive dramatic analysis as seen through the explicitly political lens that Mason has constructed.
The chapters entitled “The Political as Personal” and “The Personal as Political” examine the playwright's major works from opposite ends of the power dynamic. The former covers All My Sons and Death of a Salesman, observing the way in which both plays render political issues in largely personal terms. The latter flips the focus to the more explicitly political The Crucible and The Archbishop's Ceiling, noting that in these plays only a single individual “stands between government and complete subjugation of the community” (145). These chapters are essentially close readings, very occasionally drawing on Marxist criticism, but largely relying on dramatic analysis to frame Mason's insights on personal and political power.
His chapter “The Holocaust” returns to the perspective of Miller as a political moderate, arguing that his plays outline a complex view of history rather than simply demonizing the Nazis and victimizing the Jews. Mason offers in-depth readings of Miller's major Holocaust plays, providing insightful dramatic analysis of Broken Glass, Incident at Vichy, Playing for Time, and After the Fall. Perhaps the most useful chapter in this book, “The Holocaust” examines these works in a detailed historical and theoretical context, bringing in Miller's own words as well as those of numerous Holocaust historians and theorists. Departing from his singular approach in previous chapters covering Salesman and The Crucible, Mason creates a complex lens through which to reconsider Miller's dramatic treatment of the Holocaust.
In a chapter entitled “The Women,” Mason sidesteps the debate on Miller's position regarding traditional gender relationships and instead considers “how he used ‘man’ and ‘woman’ in his plays, especially in the context of his treatment of the range of political relationships on the continuum from the most public instances to the most private” (206). Mason offers close readings of Linda Loman, Kate Keller, Abigail Williams, and several other characters, demonstrating that the playwright's gender politics are fundamentally normative, and showing how his women, whether wives, brides, or mistresses, are trapped by the powerful constraints of family, society, and their own sexuality. Mason's approach is more descriptive than critical, and this chapter does not cite any major feminist theories or writers; his conclusions are based almost entirely on a thorough dramatic analysis.
The final chapter, entitled “Violence,” returns again to theories of power, using Foucault's study of the history of institutional punishment to frame a “poetics of violence on the stage” (262). Foucault argues that the act of criminal punishment in Western society has shifted from physical abuse to a more abstract but no less brutal agony of isolation and imprisonment. Mason then applies this concept to numerous examples of violence in Miller's works. The final fates of John Proctor and Willy Loman, for example, are not depicted onstage, thus demonstrating Miller's proclivity to “include torment as a subject but without allowing it to overtake the action” (262). Though this chapter surveys many instances of violence in Miller's more canonical works, it focuses on Resurrection Blues, with the idea of crucifixion serving as the link to the notion of violence. This discussion segues into Mason's conclusion, where he sums up his assessment of Miller's political theatre. Again he emphasizes moderation, describing a playwright who “finds meaning and encourages hope in the staging of the struggle,” but who is ultimately “too pessimistic to admit complete solutions to the problems his characters inevitably create” (282). Ultimately, though Mason's varying methodology makes his endeavor uneven in places, the book's through line of politics and power is clear, and Stone Tower provides interesting insights regarding Miller's work.
