Taking up Liz Gunner's 1994 claim that South Africa's crisis of legitimacy has been replaced by a crisis of identity, Rhodes University lecturer and playwright Anton Krueger's monograph Experiments in Freedom: Explorations of Identity in New South African Drama offers a timely portrait of some of the most influential and prevalent works of South African drama over the past twenty years. Arranged into thematic rubrics, Krueger's book is focused on the question of South African identities, which the author defines as fluid cultural signs, social constructions, and negotiated sites rather than as the fixed biological identifications or the ontological categories upon which the apartheid regime was predicated. The study is divided into six parts, the first of which, “Exploring Identity,” is an occasionally choppy theoretical checklist in which Krueger establishes his terms and methodology. Thereafter follow five additional topical rubrics/parts: “Gendered Identities,” “Anti-Apartheid Identities,” “Ethnic Identities,” “Syncretic Identities,” and “Racial Identities.”
Under the second rubric, “Gendered Identities,” Krueger works through the performance of white South African masculinities in the post-1994 milieu because, as he claims, “this is an identity construction which has undergone a particularly significant alteration since the advent of democracy” (50). Approaching masculinity as a semiotic formation, he examines sexual maturity, exile, and loss of voice in Athol Fugard's The Captain's Tiger (1998) and Sorrows and Rejoicings (2001), male chauvinism in Anthony Akerman's A Man Out of the Country (1986), and sexuality as healing in Zakes Mda's The Bells of Amersfoort (2002). This part of Krueger's analysis would be stronger had he layered race (whiteness) over gender (masculinity) more explicitly, and teased out the tensions these identity constructions engender more fully.
In Part III, “Anti-Apartheid Identities,” Krueger asks how a nation, as an imagined community, can heal and restore itself on an imaginary level; he frames the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) as an “attempt to will a country into existence, rather than to restore a country which has been lost” (109). In a broader analysis of several dramatized versions of the TRC, Krueger focuses on Ubu and the Truth Commission, the 1997 collaboration among visual artist William Kentridge, playwright Jane Taylor, and the Handspring Puppet Company, and this play's challenge to South Africans to participate in the meaning making of the nation by engaging the fraught and fragmentary past. Offering a deft analysis of both the TRC's function as a site of the “largest and longest continuous performance of nation building ever seen in the country” (96) and of Ubu and the Truth Commission as an examination of justice, judgment, and witnessing, this chapter unpacks the vital moment in the history of post-1994 South African performance that was the TRC.
Part IV, “Ethnic Identities,” is dedicated to readings of stagings of multicultural national pluralities in a democracy that has eschewed the grand narratives of the past. In his analysis of Grieg Coetzee's 2002 play Happy Natives (about two actors—one black, the other white—who are commissioned to create a corporate theatre piece about the New South Africa), Krueger examines the “ironies of the nebulous term heritage” (129; italics his) and the shifting affiliations the characters experience between fixed and fluid definitions of themselves as individuals and as members of various ethnic groups.
Part V, “Syncretic Identities,” the most nimbly executed section of this study, examines the Dionysian work of Brett Bailey as well as the hybridized dramatic works of Afrikaans playwright Reza de Wet, whose plays refuse clear affiliations with nation or ethnicity in favor of what Krueger calls “realms of experimentation with senses of self beyond consideration of gendered, politicised or nationalised identities” (140). Bailey is known for his provocative, mythic pieces of ritual theatre; his boldness as a white man operating within the taboo space of black African spirituality makes him a contested figure in the South African theatrical landscape. Krueger's chapter on Bailey is well-rounded and cogently articulated; it offers an insightful chronicling of Bailey's concerns with cultural collisions and his devised creation of chthonic performances that challenge grand narratives and the status quo. In his chapter on Reza de Wet's Afrikaner magical realism, Krueger examines the transgressive nature of her Afrikaner characters. By pairing the iconoclastic de Wet with the Dionysian Bailey, Krueger paints a vivid portrait of two of the most vibrant, challenging, white artists working in South African theatre today.
After largely avoiding an engagement with race, claiming that it belongs to the “outmoded science of eugenics” (195), Krueger finally dedicates Part VI of the book to “Racial Identities,” specifically analyzing the case of maverick Mpumelelo Paul Grootboom, whose harsh, uncompromising style, cinematic approach to playwriting and directing, and focus on violence reveal the deep resentments still underpinning much of South African society. Krueger includes a discussion of the racial politics of theatre making in contemporary South Africa (where the key players are still predominantly white) as well as Grootboom's 2005 play Interracial, an angry tirade against the white power elite and established theatre that deploys parodies of whiteness as it takes these power structures to task. Krueger concludes that race, while theoretically agreed upon to be an “outmoded pseudo-science” (205), has historically been a central idea in which South Africans invest much of their identities and that continues, unfortunately, to haunt the new democracy.
Experiments in Freedom covers an extraordinary breadth of material and is a valuable engagement with the complexities of gender, ethnic, and racial identity affiliations in its study of post-1994 South African drama and theatre. in Part VII, “Conclusions,” Krueger offers the image of the rhizome—its roots sprouting in “every conceivable direction” (213)—as the metaphor for theatre in the new South African democracy. He ends with a call to embrace paradox, and to let go of the idea of identity as a useful determinant of meaning creation within the new South African culture. Experimenting with identities that are “syncretic, minoritarian, fractured, unstable, and uncertain” and embracing “paradoxical identities” (231), is, argues Krueger, the mark of a truly free democracy.
Complementing Krueger's examination of identity are two collections of plays that explore the complex cultural, racial, and gendered negotiations of South Africans in this new democracy. In At This Stage: Plays from Post-apartheid South Africa, University of the Witwatersrand lecturer Greg Homann brings together four contemporary works organized around the question of how South Africans can imagine a future while still haunted by the traumas of the past. Included in the collection are Reach! (2007) by writer-director Lara Foot Newton; Some Mothers' Sons (2005) by playwright, arts advocate, and cultural critic Mike van Graan; Shwele Bawo! (2004) by award-winning actress and playwright Motshabi Tyelele; and Dream of the Dog (2007) by Market Theatre dramaturge Craig Higginson. Homann frames the collection with two essay chapters. The first is a history lesson on the three distinct phases he sees South African theatre working through after the 1990 unbanning of the African National Congress (ANC) and the release of Nelson Mandela from prison. The second is an introduction to the common themes of these four plays as South African works that continue to “forge their new national imaginary” (1). All four plays explore the process of reconciliation across racial, gender, and cultural lines as well as the ways in which characters from disparate subject positions navigate whose version of truth is most viable in the new democracy.
Both Reach! and Dream of the Dog examine tensions between the white old guard and the new generation of blacks negotiating their decidedly different memories, traumas, and histories. Working through racial and cultural differences that divide them, both plays articulate the struggles South Africans face in attempting to coexist respectfully. Reach! is ultimately a hopeful story about a woman without a future (sixty-three-year old Marion Banning) and a man without a past (nineteen-year-old Solomon Xaba) who learn to care for each other in the new democracy. Dream of the Dog, on the other hand, articulates a greater melancholy about the scars and damage of the past continuing to haunt South Africans today. As the elderly, white couple Patricia and Richard pack up and leave their farm, they are visited by Look Smart, a boy who witnessed Richard's sins years before and who now, as a menacing grown man, has come to settle accounts. In Some Mothers' Sons, two lawyer friends are each detained under the law (union activist Vusi for protesting apartheid and Afrikaner Braam for murder in the new democracy), and each has to defend his friend's case. An exploration of the failed criminal justice system, then and now, van Graan's play explores South Africans' disillusionment with the rule of law and suggests that violence is as much a part of the new democracy as it was under the apartheid regime. Also included in Homann's collection is Motshabi Tyelele's Shwele Bawo! (A Grave Injustice), a one-woman piece about a successful member of the new black economic elite who is charged with the murder of her abusive husband. Through her protagonist's journey, Tyelele unpacks not only the oppressive forces of gender relations, but the cultural traditions that uphold gender inequity as well. According to Homann, all four plays “reflect the challenges and questions South Africans are currently confronted with as we advance towards the dream outlined in our Constitution” (29), and they represent some of the important voices being articulated in contemporary South African theatre.
In a second recent anthology of plays, Armed Response: Plays from South Africa, editor David Peimer has collected five intense works concerned specifically with the role of violence in contemporary South Africa. The most brutal of the collection is Mpumelelo Paul Grootboom and Presley Chweneyagae's Relativity: Township Stories, a harrowing piece that lays bare the gruesome cycles of violence plaguing South Africa's townships and their inhabitants. Aptly dubbed the Township Tarantinos, these bold authors create a dramatic play that reads very much like a Tarantino film, with its episodic and graphic barrage of rape, murder, incest, and torture. (Chweneyagae is best known for his starring role in the Oscar-winning film Tsotsi, a tale of the exploits of a tough township gangster with no moral rudder.) What is more terrifying in Relativity than the story of Thabo—a boy sexually molested by his brutal father who then goes on to rape and strangle a series of women with their undergarments—is the starkness, even complacency, with which the violence is treated. Violence, particularly against women, is described and enacted with such dispassionate brutality that the line between aestheticized pleasure and social commentary often becomes blurred, leaving readers in a disquieting position between voyeur and moral judge.
Peimer's collection also includes Lara Foot-Newton's Reach!, as well as Xoli Norman's Hallelujah!, about a naive and optimistic poet who becomes an activist after his neighbors are raped and murdered in front of their small daughter. Whereas Relativity: Township Stories stages violence on live bodies onstage, including two rapes and a scene of testicular torture, the violence in Hallelujah! is articulated verbally, and the overall effect is far more searing. The collection also includes Peimer's own play, cowritten with Martina Griller, called Armed Response. It is a postapartheid thriller about a Mafia-esque private security company that bullies citizens into buying their protective services. The remaining play in Peimer's collection is Martin Koboekae's Bush Tale, the most poetic and abstract but also the most hope-filled selection in the anthology. It is about an encounter in the bush between Jan, a black man pushing a wheelbarrow, and Marietta, a white women fleeing from her husband. At first distrusting and critical of each other, through their interactions they learn to witness and to engage each other as live bodies behind all the racial, gender, and class markers that divide them.
South African identity—negotiated, contested, articulated, and performed—is a central concern of all three texts reviewed here. Krueger, Homann, and Peimer's work contributes to the larger discourse on how South Africans are dramatizing their foray into democracy. All three books remind us that while there is much to celebrate and admire about the country's transition, there is much work still to be done, and many identities yet to be negotiated. Each book also reminds us that the theatre is a vital and important arena in which such work can take place.
