Introduction
Currently much attention is focused on sea-level rise and the potential for ice-sheet collapse. Ice streams have been cited as the potential weak link that could lead to this collapse (e.g. Reference HughesHughes, 1973). Ice streams account for the majority of ice discharge from the West Antarctic ice sheet (WAIS) (Reference BentleyBentley, 1987) and they influence the behavior and stability of ice sheets by providing a means for rapid discharge from the interior of the ice sheet.
Field measurements indicate that neighboring West Antarctic ice streams vary widely in behavior (Reference BentleyShabtaie and Bentley, 1987; Reference Whillans, Bolzan and ShabtaieWhillans and others, 1987), and satellite observations have recorded significant changes in activity (Reference Bindschadler and VornbergerBindschadler and Vornberger, 1998; Reference RignotRignot, 1998). Studies of the WAIS indicate that irregular ice-stream behavior is, in large part, controlled by subglacial bed conditions and processes occurring at and within the bed (Reference Alley, Blankenship, Bentley and RooneyAlley and others, 1986, Reference Alley, Blankenship, Rooney and Bentley1987; Reference Blankenship, Bentley, Rooney and AlleyBlankenship and others, 1986, Reference Blankenship, Bentley, Rooney and Alley1987, Reference Blankenship, Alley and Bindschadler2001; Reference Rooney, Blankenship, Alley and BentleyRooney and others, 1987; Reference AlleyAlley, 1989; Reference Engelhardt and KambEngelhardt and Kamb, 1991; Reference Anandakrishnan, Blankenship, Alley and StoffaAnandakrishnan and others, 1998; Reference BellBell and others, 1998; Reference Tulaczyk, Kamb, Scherer and EngelhardtTulaczyk and others, 1998). Troughs in the underlying topography may delineate ice-stream margins, and a step in ice-surface topography typically marks the onset of streaming (Reference BentleyShabtaie and Bentley, 1987). Aerogeophysical imaging (Reference BellBell and others, 1998) and seismic profiling (Reference Anandakrishnan, Blankenship, Alley and StoffaAnandakrishnan and others, 1998) indicate that the area of Ice Stream B, which flows into the Ross Ice Shelf (Fig. 1), coincides with a geologic boundary between a sedimentary basin and crystalline bedrock. Reference Anandakrishnan, Blankenship, Alley and StoffaAnandakrishnan and others (1998) and Reference BellBell and others (1998) asserted that a transition from crystalline bedrock to softer sediments is necessary for onset of streaming to occur. Drilling at an upstream portion of Ice Stream B (Fig. 1) recovered a weak, unconsolidated sediment layer located at the base of the streaming ice (Reference Engelhardt, Humphrey, Kamb and FahnestockEngelhardt and others, 1990; Englelhardt and Reference KambKamb, 1991; Reference KambKamb, 1991). Detailed examination of weak tills retrieved from Ice Stream B determined that the till formed from recycled poorly indurated sediments. Therefore, movement of ice streams via a deforming-till layer may be controlled by locations of sediment sources (Reference Tulaczyk, Kamb, Scherer and EngelhardtTulaczyk and others, 1998).
(a) Satellite image of Antarctica with study areas marked. EAIS, East Antarctic ice sheet; WAIS, West Antarctic ice sheet. AVHRR image from http://TerraWeb.wr.usgs.gov/TRS/projects/Antarctica/color/index.html. (b) Distribution of data used in this study. Black lines mark positions of cruise tracks. Multibeam data and 3.5 kHz data were collected for all of each cruise.
Despite great interest in the connection between subglacial geology and ice behavior, there remains much to be learned from field observations. The Antarctic continental shelf, previously covered by expanded ice sheets, contains a relatively undisturbed record of subglacial conditions that is more accessible than the current subglacial environment.
This paper presents geophysical and sedimentological observations from the continental shelf offshore of each of the major ice-drainage outlets between north Victoria Land and the Antarctic Peninsula (Fig. 1). All major drainage outlets of the WAIS are included, except those of the Weddell Sea. In addition, drainage areas of the East Antarctic ice sheet (Pennell Coast and western Ross Sea) and the Peninsula Ice Cap (Marguerite Bay) are included. The research focused on the large glacial troughs that occur in each drainage area. The dataset includes seismic imaging of the substrate over which the ice flowed, high-resolution seismic imaging of the upper bed, multibeam swath bathymetry imaging of large geomorphic features on the shelf, deep-tow side-scan sonar imaging of smaller bedforms, and geological sampling of the bed. Relationships between geomorphic features and substrate geology were observed. These correlations have implications for the control that the substrate geology may exert on ice behavior.
Methods
The majority of the data used in this study were collected aboard the RV/IB Nathaniel B. Palmer during the 1998 and 1999 seasons (cruises NBP9801 and NBP9902). Our analysis of individual drainage outlets followed a systematic approach whereby seismic records, swath bathymetry data and sediment cores were acquired along the axis of troughs. Data between troughs were collected primarily in transit. The seismic data were collected with either a 50 in (820 cm3) or a 210 in3 (3442 cm3) generator-injector air gun and a single-channel streamer. The data were recorded with an Elics seismic acquisition system. The seismic data were band-pass filtered. The vertical resolution of these data is on the order of 10 m. The 3.5 kHz data are higher-resolution, but do not penetrate beyond ∼10 m. The 3.5 kHz data were not processed. The multibeam swath bathymetry data were collected with a Sea Beam 2100 hull-mounted system and consist of 120 beams of 12 kHz data. Data editing removed anomalous beams. Processing included applying a corrected sound-velocity profile, and gridding and displaying the data in shaded-relief maps. Grid size varied for each image based on the water depth and area included in the image; an average grid size is about 30 m by 30 m. Vertical resolution of the multibeam data is on the order of a few meters. The Datasonics deep-tow side-scan sonar images finer-scale bathymetric features. These data were not processed. The geological dataset consists of piston cores that penetrated to a maximum of 8.15 m and kasten (gravity) cores that are up to 2.5 m long.
Substrate differentiation was based on seismic facies descriptions and consisted largely of determining if the sub-crop in each area is crystalline or sedimentary. Continuous to semi-continuous parallel to divergent seismic reflections, which onlap landward onto more chaotic seismic units, represent sedimentary substrates. Chaotic and discontinuous reflection patterns were interpreted as crystalline substrates. This seismic reflection pattern also can represent a diamicton. The two are distinguishable because till and glacial-marine diamictons form a thin deposit packaged with marine strata and rest on an erosional unconformity, whereas the basal contact is not observed in crystalline bedrock where there is generally much greater relief. In addition, sedimentary strata of different ages onlap crystalline basement rocks. Onshore outcrops also were used to help interpret the observed seismic units.
Glacial landforms were identified and divided into categories of depositional, erosional or mixed based on mode of formation (Table 1; Fig. 2). Table 2 presents sedimentary units identified in cores and seismic profiles. Analysis of the data followed Reference AndersonAnderson’s (1999) summary of sedimentological and seismic criteria for defining deposits that occur on the Antarctic continental shelf and his description of geomorphic features imaged by side-scan sonar and multibeam techniques.
Summary of geomorphic features identified in this study
Sedimentary units described in this study
Multibeam swath bathymetry: (a) Central Ross Sea showing gullies at the shelf break; (b) Sulzberger Bay showing the trough carved by grounded ice and the associated erosional grooves and roches moutonnées; (c) Pine Island Bay showing mega- scale glacial lineations that become overlain by an ice berg-furrowed sediment wedge further offshore; (d) Pine Island Bay showing meltwater channels; and (e) Eltanin Bay showing drumlins. See Table 1 for further discussion of geomorphic features, and Figure 1 for locations. The multibeam data have a vertical resolution of a few meters. Two of these images are modified from Reference Anderson, Shipp, Alley and BindschadlerAnderson and Shipp (2001).
Results
North Victoria Land shelf
The Pennell Coast is located west of the Ross Sea in north Victoria Land, where the Transantarctic Mountains meet the coast (Fig. 1). In contrast to the other areas in this study, drainage along the Pennell Coast is wholly within East Antarctica. The continental shelf, relative to the other regions in this study, is very narrow (Fig. 3a). Rugged bathymetry and crystalline substrate, similar to the onshore portion of the study area, characterizes the inner shelf (Fig. 3b) (Reference Brake and AndersonBrake and Anderson, 1983). Multibeam data from the inner shelf show steep troughs and erosional grooves. A narrow sedimentary wedge occurs on the outer shelf (Fig. 3c); no lineations were observed on the outer shelf. Piston cores collected from the trough flanks contain diamicton overlain by a thin pelletized unit (Table 2) and topped by diatomaceous deposits with varying amounts of ice-rafted debris. The basal diamicton is interpreted as till based on its occurrence below the pelletized unit, moderate shear strengths, lack of pebble fabric visible on X-ray and lack of pristine microfossils. The presence of till in piston cores indicates that the ice sheet grounded on the shelf. Limited multibeam data collected seaward of the shelf break indicate the presence of gullies.
(a) Bathymetric map of the continental shelf offshore of the Pennell Coast region showing the steep, narrow trough on the inner shelf that grades into a broad trough on the outer shelf The distance between the crystalline–sedimentary contact and the shelf break is narrow, 35 km, compared to other areas. Contour interval is 100 m. (b,c) 50 in3 air-gun seismic line (b) from the inner shelf showing the crystalline basement and (c) from the outer shelf showing progradational sediments. Locations are shown in (a).
Ross Sea
The Ross Sea, located between the Pennell Coast and Sulzberger Bay, is bound on the western margin by the Trans- antarctic Mountains, to the south by the Ross Ice Shelf and to the east by Marie Byrd Land (Fig. 1). The Ross Sea receives drainage from both the East and West Antarctic ice sheets. The continental shelf, wide relative to the rest of the study regions, is geographically divided into western, central and eastern sectors. Broad glacial troughs characterize the continental shelf. These troughs, occupied by paleo-ice streams over several glaciations, trend northeast–southwest (Reference HughesHughes, 1977; Reference AndersonAnderson, 1999; Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999).
On the basis of seismic data, the continental-shelf substrate is predominantly seaward-dipping sedimentary strata. Deep Sea Drilling Project (DSDP) site 270 recovered Early Paleozoic marble and gneiss close to the sea-floor on the inner shelf of the central Ross Sea (Reference Hayes and FrakesHayes and Frakes, 1975). Just south of the DSDP 270 site, the innermost central shelf has crystalline bedrock at the sea-floor, based on interpretations of seismic data. Excluding the innermost western and central Ross Sea shelves, unlithified sedimentary wedges and till sheets overlie the lithified sedimentary substrate. Geomorphic features, in addition to core data, have been used to define the extent of ice during the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM). In the western Ross Sea, ice extended to the outer shelf but did not reach the shelf edge (Reference Licht, Jennings, Andrews and WilliamsLicht and others, 1996; Reference Domack, Jacobson, Shipp and AndersonDomack and others, 1999; Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). Ice in the central and eastern Ross Sea extended to the continental- shelf edge (Reference Domack, Jacobson, Shipp and AndersonDomack and others, 1999; Reference LichtLicht, 1999; Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). Multibeam data show mega-scale glacial lineations within troughs. Drumlins occur on the inner shelf of the central Ross Sea, in association with the transition from crystalline to sedimentary substrate (Fig. 4). Subcrops of sedimentary strata characterize the innermost western Ross Sea shelf. Side-scan sonar and sub-bottom profiler data reveal thin, patchy deposits overlying an erosional surface in this region (Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999).
(a) Drumlins in the transition zone inpaleo-ice stream 3 in the central Ross Sea shown on swath bathymetry data. Darker shades of gray indicate shallower depths, and lighter shades of gray indicate greater depths. (b) Line drawing of a full seismic profile showing substrates upon which features in (a) formed. Crystalline bedrock occurs on the inner shelf, and seaward-dipping strata occur farther offshore. The drumlin field occurs near the contact between crystalline and sedimentary substrates, (c) Seismic data showing three substrate zones in detail. C1 is seaward-dipping strata, C2 shows strata onlapping onto crystalline bedrock, and C3 shows smooth crystalline bedrock on inner shelf.
Cores from the Ross Sea typically recovered diatom- aceous mud overlying a soft diamicton with moderate numbers of microfossils. The latter is interpreted as an ice-shelf facies. A thin pelletized unit locally marks the base of the ice-shelf facies (Reference Domack, Jacobson, Shipp and AndersonDomack and others, 1999). Below the pelletized unit or directly below the ice-shelf facies is till. The transition between the ice-shelf facies and the till is variably marked by an increase in shear strengths, color change and decrease in microfossil abundance. Locally, cores sampled a stiff diamicton, interpreted as lodgement till, underlying the sequence (Reference Anderson, Kurtz, Domack and BalshawAnderson and others, 1980; Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). Radiocarbon ages indicate that these strata were deposited during and since the last glaciation (Reference Licht, Jennings, Andrews and WilliamsLicht and others, 1996; Reference Domack, Jacobson, Shipp and AndersonDomack and others, 1999; Reference LichtLicht, 1999). In the western Ross Sea, lodgement till occurs on the innermost shelf in association with the thin, patchy deposits overlying the eroded sedimentary substrate. Softer diamictons occur in association with mega-scale glacial lineations (Reference Domack, Jacobson, Shipp and AndersonDomack and others, 1999; Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999).
Sulzberger Bay
Sulzberger Bay, located east of the Ross Sea (Fig. 1), is bounded by the Edward VII Peninsula. A prominent trough appears aligned with the structural grain of the Marie Byrd Land coast. Multibeam data collected from the region show an irregular sea-floor characterized by erosional grooves (Fig. 2b). Seismic data acquired during previous cruises indicate that the bay is floored by crystalline bedrock (L. R. Bartek, seismic data, February 1999). Based on the extent of the trough and glacial grooves, it is apparent that the WAIS extended to the shelf break during a previous glacial cycle. Depositional geomorphic features (Table 1) were not observed.
Attempts during 1999 to core in this area largely were unsuccessful and yielded only bagged samples of sand and gravel. Several cores were obtained in Sulzberger Bay during a 1983 expedition (Deep Freeze 83). A core from inner Sulzberger Trough penetrated a light-olive-brown pebbly mud (Reference CassidyCassidy, 1984). A core from the outer trough penetrated a light-olive-gray mud with few pebbles (Reference CassidyCassidy, 1984). Shear strength was not measured on either core. However, both cores were significantly deformed and washed in the liner, implying that stiff material, which often serves to plug the core, was not penetrated.
Getz Ice Shelf (Wrigley Gulf and Bakutis Coast)
Ice streams of the Getz Ice Shelf region currently flow around a group of small islands into Wrigley Gulf and across Bakutis Coast (Fig. 1). Large troughs occur in both of these regions (Fig. 5a). Multibeam data from both troughs show subglacial geomorphic features extending across the shelf, indicating that the WAIS grounded in locations currently at water depths of >1000 m. The data record erosional grooves on the inner shelf, and mega-scale glacial lineations extending across the outer shelf (Fig. 5b). On the inner shelf the troughs are aligned with the structural grain of the area. On the outer shelf, the troughs are oriented more directly offshore. Seismic data from the Bakutis Coast (Fig. 5c) show crystalline bedrock on the inner shelf. The outer shelf is characterized by seaward-dipping sedimentary strata, which toplap against an unconformity. The relief of the sea-floor on the inner shelf where older strata are exposed suggests that the strata are heavily lithified (Fig. 5c).
(a) Location of paleo-glacial drainage trough offshore Bakutis Coast. Box shows area of (b). (b) Multibeam data and (c) seismic data from offshore of a portion of Getz Ice Shelf showing the change from crystalline to sedimentary substrate and the corresponding change in the geomorphic features on the shelf Seismic location is shown on multibeam data.
In Wrigley Gulf and the Bakutis Coast region the transition between the crystalline and sedimentary substrate is delineated by a change from grooves to mega-scale glacial lineations (Fig. 5). Drumlins occur at the crystalline–sedimentary bed transition. Piston cores from the area of mega-scale glacial lineations sampled gray to olive-gray diamicton characterized by low shear strengths (0.22–0.24 kg cm−2). These deposits are interpreted to be deformation till, based on their stratigraphic relationships, shear strengths, X-ray character and low abundance of microfossils. Overlying the till are thin deposits of gray to brown diamicton with lower shear strengths than the till; this is interpreted to be glacial-marine sediment. Cores from the area of crystalline bedrock sampled dark-gray dia- micton with shear strengths of 0.1–0.19 kg cm−2. These sediments are interpreted as glacial-marine deposits, primarily based on the abundance of microfossils.
Pine Island Bay
Pine Island Bay (Fig. 1) serves as catchment to a major convergent drainage system of the WAIS. Several deep and narrow troughs emerge from the coast (Fig. 6). These converge on the middle shelf to form one main trough that extends to the shelf break (Fig. 6b). The bathymetry of the continental shelf changes from a rugged inner shelf to a smooth outer shelf (Reference Kellogg and KelloggKellogg and Kellogg, 1987). The inner shelf displays relief with depths of 400–1700 m, while the outer shelf averages 500 m in depth. A seismic profile collected along the axis of the main trough reveals the transition in bathymetry corresponds to a change in substrate. An irregular crystalline bedrock surface characterizes the inner shelf and most of the middle shelf. Farther offshore, this surface dips below seaward-dipping strata, which toplap against an erosional surface at or near the sea-floor (Fig. 6c). North of Burke Island, a sedimentary wedge, composed of prograding sequences of chaotic and layered deposits, overlies these strata. The occurrence of this wedge and other deposits above the glacial unconformity creates the broad, smooth bathymetry common on the outer shelf.
(a) Location of paleo-glacial trough, marked with a 600 m contour line, in Pine Island Bay. Shaded areas within the trough represent areas deeper than 1400 m. Location of (b) is shown. (b) Detailed bathymetric map of Pine Island Bay showing the steep, narrow trough on the inner shelf and the broader shallower trough on the mid-outer shelf Contour interval is 200 m. (c) Seismic line from Pine Island Bay. Location is shown in (b).
Multibeam bathymetric images show channels on the rugged crystalline basement of the inner shelf, and the preliminary interpretation is that these features are melt- water channels (Fig. 2d). Glacial erosional features include grooves and gouges. Drumlins occur just landward of the contact between crystalline bedrock and sedimentary substrate. Gores from the inner shelf are short, but sampled alternating units of diamicton with low shear strengths (<0.1 kg cm−2) and clay. This is interpreted to be a sub-ice- shelf unit. Within the deeper portions of the trough on the outer shelf, mega-scale glacial lineations are present (Fig. 2c). In locations shallower than 700 m depth, such as the younger sedimentary wedge, iceberg furrows obliterate the lineated surface (Fig. 2c). Gullies occur on the continental shelf offshore of Pine Island Bay.
Eltanin Bay
Eltanin Bay (Fig. 1) is a broad bay located in the Bellingshausen Sea west of the Abbot Ice Shelf and east of the Ronne Entrance. In the LGM reconstruction of Reference Denton and HughesDenton and Hughes (1981), Eltanin Bay receives drainage from a large area of Ellsworth Land. Multibeam data reveal a large trough extending across the shelf. The data show erosional grooves in the inner portion of the bay. Farther offshore, mega-scale glacial lineations characterize the geomorphology. No data were collected from the outer shelf due to severe weather conditions. A drumlin field separates the zones of erosional grooves and mega-scale glacial lineations (Fig. 2e). Individual drumlins are 5–10 km long. The multibeam data suggest there may be channel-like depressions around the heads of the drumlins, indicating that formation of the drumlins may have included pressure melting and water flow around the drumlins. Multibeam data show that the WAIS grounded where water depths are currently up to 1200 m on the middle shelf, although the grounding line probably was seaward of the data coverage. Piston cores collected from the middle shelf sampled till, with shear strengths of <0.34 kg cm−2, beneath thin units of very soft diamicton with greater abundance of microfossils. The area of diamicton is coincident with the area of mega-scale glacial lineations.
Marguerite Bay
Marguerite Bay is the most northern drainage area surveyed in this study; it is located north of Alexander Island at the southern end of the Antarctic Peninsula. It receives drainage from the Antarctic Peninsula Ice Cap. A deep trough, >1650 m, occupies the inner shelf of Marguerite Bay and extends seaward across the shelf (Reference Pope, Anderson and ElliotPope and Anderson, 1992). The inner- shelf seismic data from this region are not from the same location as the multibeam data. However, the seismic data available do show basement rocks and folded forearc rocks at the sea-floor (Reference Bart and AndersonBart and Anderson, 2000). Based on these seismic data and comparison of the multibeam data to data in other areas, the substrate in the inner shelf is interpreted to be crystalline bedrock with highly irregular topography. Grooves occur on the trough floor. Steep slopes, especially on the western flank, mark the trough boundaries. A drumlin field lies farther seaward. Seismic profiles collected offshore of the drumlin region show smooth middle and outer shelves floored by prograding seaward-dipping strata (Reference Bart, Anderson, Gooper, Barker and BrancoliniBart and Anderson, 1995), and sampling at ODP site 1079 recovered lithified sediments (Reference Barker, Camerlenghi and ActonBarker and others, 1998).
Cores collected from the eastern portion of the bay sampled thick muds with ice-rafted debris and a moderate number of microfossils, underlain by sediment-gravity-flow deposits (Reference Kennedy and AndersonKennedy and Anderson, 1989). Cores from the western region sampled thin glacial-marine units underlain by transitional glacial-marine deposits, or in rare cases, thick sections of stiff till occurring in water depths of >700 m (Reference Kennedy and AndersonKennedy and Anderson, 1989). A single core collected from within the drumlin field sampled glacial- marine sediment underlain by sediment-gravity-flow deposits.
Correlation between geomorphic features and geological substrate
In each of the study areas, large glacial troughs were mapped on the continental shelf offshore of major drainage outlets. The troughs vary in size and extent across the study areas. However, their general shapes and bathymetry are similar, in that they are narrower and deeper on the inner shelf over crystalline bedrock and broader and shallower on the outer shelf where they cut sedimentary strata. This change in trough geometry, from narrow and deep to broad and shallow, partially may be controlled by the foredeepened nature of the Antarctic continental shelf, in that the troughs must broaden on the outer shelf to allow for somewhat constant volumes of ice.
Analysis of the data from across the region reveals a range of substrates on which former expanded ice sheets were grounded. Two end-members include slightly erodible crystalline bedrock and more easily eroded sedimentary strata. In locations where ice is interpreted to have flowed over both end-members, a transition zone between the two exists. Each substrate zone displays characteristic geomorphic features and sedimentary deposits that are consistent throughout the drainage areas.
Crystalline bedrock
The inner shelfofmost study areas is characterized by crystalline bedrock with highly irregular bathymetry. Deep erosional grooves and steep-sided troughs are the dominant features (Fig. 2b). These features indicate the direction of ice flow, which appears to have followed the structural grain of the underlying bedrock, displaying sharp turns and an orientation that is not always directed offshore. The north Victoria Land (Fig. 3), Sulzberger Bay (Fig. 2b), Getz Ice Shelf (Fig. 5) and Pine Island Bay (Fig. 6) study areas are the main examples of these features. Other landforms associated with crystalline bedrock include meltwater channels such as those seen in Pine Island Bay (Fig. 2d), and roches moutonnees such as those seen in Sulzberger Bay (Fig. 2b). Erosional formation of the landforms may be controlled by either grounded ice (e.g. grooves and roches moutonnees) or by meltwater (e.g. incised channels) (Table 1).
Sedimentary substrates
Sedimentary strata that dip offshore characterize the outer shelf in most areas. Troughs widen and shallow as they extend across the softer substrate, and mega-scale glacial lineations are the dominant geomorphic feature. Mega-scale glacial lineations form in material eroded from the substrate. Individual lineations are tens of kilometers long and are about 0.4 km wide. Sets of lineations can be seen to deviate in orientation as ice is able to spread and the flow direction changes.
In general, as the ice sheet advanced across the continental shelf it sampled crystalline bedrock, lithified sedimentary strata and unlithified Plio-Pleistocene deposits. The extent of these geological domains varies from one area to the next.
Sedimentary substrates characterize most of the Ross Sea (Fig. 4) and the outer shelves of north Victoria Land, Wrigley Gulf and the Bakutis Coast (Fig. 5), Pine Island Bay (Fig. 6), Eltanin Bay (Fig. 2e) and Marguerite Bay. Sulzberger Bay is the only study area where no sedimentary substrate is known to exist. The north Victoria Land drainage area is the only area that has a sedimentary wedge not characterized by mega-scale glacial lineations. Elsewhere, lineations exist just seaward of the crystalline bedrock-sedimentary-strata contact. Thus, it appears that mega-scale glacial lineations can form on lithified sedimentary strata, as well as soft Plio- Pleistocene sediments.
The distribution of deformation till (Table 2) appears to correlate to the occurrence of mega-scale glacial lineations. This relationship previously has been documented in Antarctica in the Ross Sea (Reference LichtLicht, 1999; Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). In most study areas, cores collected from the region of mega-scale glacial lineations consist of glacial-marine deposits overlying relatively soft till. Variations include the eastern Ross Sea where lodgement till, in addition to soft till, is occasionally found in the region of mega-scale glacial lineations. Also, cores from areas such as bank margins between adjacent ice streams in the Ross Sea sampled deformation till, but lack associated geomorphic features. Few cores from the areas of crystalline substrate recovered diamicton. However, when diamicton is recovered in cores from areas of crystalline substrate, it is not significantly different from that in cores farther out on the shelf.
It is not possible from this dataset to accurately measure the thickness of the deforming bed in the different study areas. The complete thickness of till is at least as large as the amplitude of the mega-scale glacial lineations. These average about 15–20 m in height across the study areas. Seismic profiles from the Ross Sea image a distinct unit in which mega-scale glacial lineations occur that are 15–35 m thick (Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). Cores did not penetrate the bottom of this deposit. Hence, it is beyond the range of the data to determine whether the entire unit is deformed, or only its upper surface.
The extent of deformation till varies from basin to basin, but more data are needed to quantify its distribution. The minimum dimensions of such a deposit can be inferred by analyzing the extent of mega-scale glacial lineations and the distribution of deformation till sampled in cores. In the Ross Sea, where a sedimentary substrate floors most of the area, the area of lineations extends almost 200 km from the inner to the outer shelf. In those areas where multibeam data were collected across the troughs, mega-scale glacial lin- eations are imaged across the entire trough. Limited bathymetric data show no mega-scale glacial lineations in the area of the inter-ice-stream banks and boundary ridges in the Ross Sea (Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999), but cores indicate deformation till is present.
Transition zone
A geomorphic transition zone occurs where the substrate changes from crystalline bedrock to sedimentary strata. The extent of this zone varies. It includes portions of the sea-floor seaward and landward of the point where strata begin to onlap onto the crystalline basement. Drumlins occur within the transition zone. Only one area, the north Victoria Land shelf, has crystalline and sedimentary substrates, but lacks drumlins within a transition zone.
Offshore Getz Ice Shelf, drumlin-like features occur landward of the crystalline–sedimentary substrate contact (Fig. 5). These drumlins have their heads in crystalline bedrock and grade seaward into thin onlapping sediments. Different types of drumlins include those in the central Ross Sea. These are rock-cored drumlins, with seismic data showing underlying bedrock highs serving as obstructions to ice flow (Fig. 4). In Eltanin Bay, drumlins are believed to be composed of sediment. Deep troughs surrounding the heads of the drumlins in Eltanin Bay may indicate erosion by water that flowed around the drumlins during their formation (Fig. 2e). Drumlins in Pine Island Bay display the same property, but these are bedrock drumlins formed in the crystalline portion of the transition zone.
Discussion
Many studies have examined the role of subglacial geology in the behavior of Northern Hemisphere ice sheets (e.g. Reference AlleyAlley, 1991; Reference MacAyealMacAyeal, 1993; Reference Alley and MacAyealAlley and MacAyeal, 1994). Reference ClarkP. U. Clark (1994) proposed that subglacial bed conditions, not climate, caused rapid fluctuations in behavior of the Laurentide ice sheet. Reference BoultonBoulton (1996) attributed large-scale till sequences formed by the North American, British and European ice sheets during the last glacial cycle to the process of subglacial sediment deformation over beds of unlithified sediments. Reference Marshall, Clarke, Dyke and FisherMarshall and others (1996) used geologic and topographic data to model areas of potential fast flow in the Laurentide ice sheet and suggested that interior plains and the continental shelf, rather than the crystalline shield, favor ice-stream development. Reference PattersonPatterson (1998) proposed that geology and topography beneath the Laurentide ice sheet exerted control on the areas of fast ice flow. Her results indicated that ice-covered sedimentary valleys contained thicker ice and reached the pressure-melting point before areas of positive relief. This mechanism facilitated faster flow. A geologic control on modern-day Antarctic ice streams has also been proposed (e.g. Reference Anandakrishnan, Blankenship, Alley and StoffaAnandakrishnan and others, 1998; Reference BellBell and others, 1998).
A consistent distribution of geomorphic features was observed in each of the drainage areas. A typical distribution includes erosional features such as grooves or roches moutonnées on the inner shelf, drumlins in the transition zone, mega-scale glacial lineations on the outer shelf, and gullies on the slope (Fig. 7a). This distribution pattern of geomorphic features correlates with changes in the substrate (Fig. 7). Additionally, the features observed on the continental shelf may be interpreted to reflect the behavior of the ice sheet that was grounded on the continental shelf. The crystalline, transition and sedimentary substrate zones are interpreted to represent three different conditions of ice flow (Fig. 7c). Table 3 summarizes the flow conditions in each zone.
Diagram summarizing the inferred relationship between geomorphic features, substrate and subglacial ice-flow velocity. (a) Distribution of geomorphic features in plan view. Black represents areas of erosion, and gray represents areas of deposition. (b) Corresponding change in substrate from the inner to outer shelf (c) Relative speed of ice flow.
Geomorphic features observed in this study and their interpretations
A correlation between a deforming bed and streamlined bedforms has been made by several workers including C. D. Reference ClarkClark (1993, Reference Clark1994), Reference Hart and SmithHart and Smith (1997), Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others (1999), Reference Stokes and ClarkStokes and Clark (1999) and Reference Canals, Urgeles and GalafatCanals and others (2000). On the Antarctic continental shelf, troughs in areas of sedimentary substrate have been interpreted as areas of convergent ice flow and streaming ice (Reference AndersonAnderson, 1999). This is based on the configuration of the bathymetry, the concentration of sediment within portions of the troughs, and the lineated nature of the upper surface. The mega-scale glacial lineations visible on multibeam swath bathymetry data have been interpreted as representing areas where ice was streaming (Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). Areas of mega-scale glacial lineations also have been correlated to deposits of soft diamicton (Reference Domack, Jacobson, Shipp and AndersonDomack and others, 1999; Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). Slower-moving ice is interpreted to have occupied banks, although no absolute rates are implied.
Flow over the crystalline substrate is thought to have been relatively slow and resulted in erosional geomorphic land-forms. Flow over the sedimentary substrate, where there is a deforming bed, is interpreted to have been relatively fast. It is important to note that although the data show that a sedimentary substrate is required for the presence of mega-scale glacial lineations, there are areas of sedimentary substrate that do not have mega-scale glacial lineations, particularly the inner shelf of the western Ross Sea and the outer shelf of north Victoria Land, despite having supported grounded ice. Therefore, a sedimentary substrate is required for fast flow by bed deformation, but fast flow does not occur on all sedimentary substrates.
The transition zone spanning the crystalline-sedimentary substrate contact represents a zone of acceleration. Drumlins are the most prominent features within transition zones, including the central Ross Sea, Getz Ice Shelf, Pine Island Bay, Eltanin Bay and Marguerite Bay. The acceleration zone was an area of dynamic change in the ice sheet, and thus was also the area of maximum relief in the ice surface. Reference BellBell and others (1998) described an area of high relief in the ice surface at the modern-day onset of Ice Stream B.
All locations with crystalline substrate on the inner shelf and mega-scale glacial lineations on the outer shelf have drumlins in the transition zone. Drumlins were not observed in any other setting. Because drumlins occur between regions of slow ice flow over crystalline substrate and regions of fast flow over sedimentary substrate, they are interpreted to be indicative of acceleration. Reference Mickelson, Clayton, Fullerton, Borns and WrightMickelson and others (1983) and Reference Attig, Mickelson and GlaytonAttig and others (1989) suggested that drumlins formed in areas where the ice was partially frozen to the bed and locally thawed. This may be comparable to the association we have made between drumlins and ice acceleration. Drumlins also have been interpreted as forming in areas of extensional flow (Reference LundqvistLundqvist, 1989b; Reference Van der Wateren and MenziesVan der Wateren, 1995), but to our knowledge this study provides the first correlation between drumlins and the interpreted onset of streaming flow for Antarctic ice streams.
Meltwater also is interpreted as having played an important role in controlling ice behavior. The data indicate that the amount of meltwater present varies from basin to basin. Abundant channels in Pine Island Bay, which are interpreted as meltwater channels based on the morphological expression (Fig. 2d), represent the only evidence for meltwater on the inner part of the shelf. Drumlins occur seaward of the channels and show the influence of meltwater, with erosion occurring around the drumlin heads (Reference ShawShaw, 1988; Reference Shaw, Kvill and RainsShaw and others, 1989). Similarly, the drumlins in Eltanin Bay (Fig. 2e) and the Ross Sea (Fig. 4) appear to have channels, or moats, around their edges. These channels possibly were formed by localized flowing water. This water may have been caused by high stresses around the drumlin that resulted in locally high dissipation of mechanical energy to heat. As drumlins grade into mega-scale glacial lineations, this water was available to be incorporated into deforming till. Meltwater affected ice- stream dynamics until the ice reached deformable sediments on the shelf, where it became incorporated into the sediments to produce deforming till. No geomorphic features indicative of large amounts of meltwater were imaged on the sedimentary substrate. Because water must be incorporated into till to allow deformation to occur, free meltwater probably does not occur in areas of deforming till. Gullies at the shelf break in the Ross Sea, Pennell Coast shelf, Sulzberger Bay and Pine Island Bay represent erosion by debris-rich meltwater expelled when the ice grounded near the shelf break (Reference AndersonAnderson, 1999). The fact that there is evidence for meltwater both landward and seaward of the mega-scale glacial lineations indicates that available melt- water was incorporated into the deforming till in the areas of mega-scale glacial lineations.
Bathymetry itself is a control on ice flow. Banks and adjacent troughs in the Ross Sea have primarily sedimentary substrates. However, ice flow over bank tops is interpreted to have been relatively slow, in contrast to the fast flow in the troughs (Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). A certain thickness of ice is required to create enough effective stress on the underlying sediments to initiate fast flow (Reference Tulaczyk, Kamb and EngelhardtTulaczyk and others, 2000a, b). Therefore, once a trough has been formed, ice will consistently be thicker in those areas, and streaming will be concentrated in troughs and away from banks.
The shelf offshore of the Pennell Coast is one area where the zone of sedimentary substrate provides no evidence for a deforming bed, and there is no transition zone. There are a few linear, mounded features visible on the multibeam data in the area of sedimentary substrate. Because of their small scale, they are not interpreted to be mega-scale glacial lineations, but rather erosional grooves. Why there is no evidence for a deforming bed on the Pennell shelf is unclear; three possibilities are presented here. One reason may have to do with the width of the shelf. The Pennell study area has a narrow shelf with little sedimentary substrate; the maximum distance ice flowed over sedimentary substrate is about 35 km. In other areas, such as Pine Island Bay (Fig. 6) and offshore of the Getz Ice Shelf (Fig. 5), the acceleration zone covers only a few tens of kilometers and forms right at the crystalline–sedimentary substrate transition. However, seaward of the transition zone there is over 300 km of sedimentary substrate in Pine Island Bay and at least 85 km in the Bakutis Coast area of Getz Ice Shelf. There may be a minimum distance over which the ice flows on sedimentary substrate to allow either for an increase in speed or else for geomorphic features to be formed. Alternatively, the dominant grain-size and associated porosity of the till may not be appropriate to hold the water needed to form deforming till. The Pennell Coast shelf sediments are dominated by volcanic sand, and the tills may be too sandy to develop into deformation till. Lastly, the Pennell Coast receives drainage from a small area of the Transantarctic Mountains and there may not have been enough ice feeding the system for ice-streaming at the scale recorded by megascale glacial lineations.
Implications
Ice that is underlain by deformable till may be prone to fast retreat or to collapse (Reference Engelhardt, Humphrey, Kamb and FahnestockEngelhardt and others, 1990; Reference MacAyealMacAyeal, 1992). If this is true, is ice in places like Sulzberger Bay and the Pennell Coast inherently more stable than in places like the Ross Sea? Geomorphic features indicative of retreat, such as corrugation moraines, are present in the western Ross Sea (Reference Shipp, Anderson and DomackShipp and others, 1999). These retreat features are evidence that the ice stayed in contact with its bed during retreat. Radiocarbon dates from the western Ro ss Sea also indicate a gradual retreat (Reference Conway, Hall, Denton, Gades and WaddingtonConway and others, 1999; Reference Domack, Jacobson, Shipp and AndersonDomack and others, 1999). There are no retreat features visible in any of the other study areas. This may indicate decoupling during ice-sheet retreat, but it may well be due to either a lack of sediment to form such features or incomplete data coverage. If the lack of retreat features is indicative of fast retreat, a potentially rapid retreat occurred in areas characterized by crystalline substrate and no deforming bed, such as Sulzberger Bay, and a slow and gradual retreat is indicated in the western Ross Sea, which had an extensive deforming bed. Do these data suggest that a deforming bed may not have led to instability? Reference Tulaczyk, Kamb and EngelhardtTulaczyk and others (2000a, Reference Tulaczyk, Kamb and Engelhardtb) proposed that deformation of the subglacial bed may be a process that operates at end-members of very fast or very slow flow, without taking place in the conditions between those two end-members. Thus, ice resting on a deforming bed may have an internally regulated mechanism by which fast flow may be stopped.
As ice advances and retreats across the shelf, it comes into contact with different substrates. This implies that, throughout a glacial cycle, ice behavior will be subject to different controls that should be included in models of ice behavior. Conditions for stability in the ice sheet also may change through multiple glacial cycles. The substrate and acceleration zones are not stationary through time. Throughout multiple glacial cycles, more and more erosion takes place, shifting the crystalline-sedimentary substrate contact farther seaward. This requires ice to be grounded farther onto the shelf in each cycle before it reaches the sedimentary substrate and is able to achieve fast flow.
Conclusions
This study provides the first documentation of the range of geomorphic features present on the Antarctic continental shelf and their correlation with substrate type. Where crystalline bedrock is the substrate, ice tended to follow the structural grain of the bedrock and carved deep troughs. Where ice flowed over relatively soft sedimentary strata, the direction of ice flow was more directly offshore. In these areas the signature of the ice consists of till deposition and mega-scale glacial lineations that formed in the deforming bed. Drumlins are the characteristic feature observed in the transition zone that spans the crystalline–sedimentary substrate. Ice is interpreted to have flowed relatively slowly in the area of crystalline substrates and relatively fast in the area of mega-scale glacial lineations. In this interpretation, drumlins would indicate a zone of acceleration. Because the presence of a deforming bed affects the rate at which ice can flow, the substrate below an ice sheet may also exert a fundamental control on the stability of that ice sheet.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by U.S. National Science Foundation–Office of Polar Programs grant No. 9527876 to J. B. Anderson. The authors would like to thank the crew of the RV/IB Nathaniel B. Palmer and Antarctic Support Associates personnel for productive cruises. S. O’Hara provided invaluable support with the multibeam data. The staff at the Antarctic Research Facility at Florida State University provided assistance with the cores. We thank H. K. Gampbell and A. Mosola for discussions. We also thank G. D. Glark, J. Taylor, an anonymous reviewer, and editor M.J. Hambrey for their helpful reviews of the manuscript.
