No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
This concise book is an important contribution to the study of informal-sector domestic service in Turkey. It concerns various issues such as the workings of patriarchy in economic, gender, and class relations; sources of power for structurally weak actors; migrants’ interpretations of tradition and modernity; the institution of door keeping; formation of working-class identity in migrant rural women; and the interaction of the urban middle class with rural migrants.
Ozyegin's venture in exploring domestic service in Turkey is unique, as there is no previous empirical or theoretical study on the structure of this sector or of domestic workers. Considering the unpredictable growth of this informal sector in the post-industrial and developing countries, her extensive research is a crucial contribution to the disciplines of economy, sociology, and gender studies.
Two groups of rural migrant women working in domestic service are the subject of this study: women of the basement (doorkeepers’ wives living in the basements of middle- or upper-middle-class apartments, or “outsiders within”) and women of squatter settlements (“outsiders in third space”). Grouping these women according to their setting in the urban space aims to locate the differences in their class and gender identity; in the effects of patriarchy on them; and in their interaction with rural and urban communities. The empirical foundation consists of four sources of field data: a survey (160 participants), participant observation, in-depth interviews, and focus-group research. These data were collected between 1989 and 1990 from domestic workers living in various neighborhoods in Ankara.
The first chapter introduces some theoretical questions about shifting gender and class conceptions in passage from traditional rural to modern urban space and how these dynamics affect domestic workers’ identity construction. The following questions are raised for analysis in subsequent chapters: what is the agency of domestic workers under the patriarchal construction of social identities? How does the stigmatized situation of doorkeepers and their families within middle-class households influence their interpretation of gender and class? How is the superfluous binary opposition of tradition and modernity experienced by “margin dwellers”? Are the structure and internal workings of domestic service (in terms of the wages, schedules, and recruitment patterns) such that such service can be categorized as part of the informal sector of the economy?
The author's introduction of scholarly works on domestic service in the developing countries provides a theoretical background from which the divergent internal dynamics of this sector in Turkey will be observed. A brief historical background presenting industrialization, modernization, and gender construction in modern Turkey and detailed information about her field research draw us into the comprehensive analyses provided in the following chapters.
What makes Ozyegin's text a strong qualitative (as well as quantitative) analysis is her sensitivity in presenting the individual lives, voices, or “self-definitions” of domestic workers. Their narratives on building gender and class identity both materialize and humanize the analysis of research data. Chapter 2 combines some of these narratives on how the “outsiders within” and “outsiders in third space” become domestic workers. Women of the basement's relative ease in overcoming the patriarchal objection to work (compared with women of squatter settlements) is explained through their spatial immobility (since they usually work for the residents of the apartment building where they live) and easy control of their labor. A significant finding about the relationship between the workings of patriarchy and the domestic-service sector in the Turkish context is that patriarchal control makes migrant women's labor scarce and expensive. Thus, although there is huge supply of domestic workers that could lead to their exploitation when they surpass demand, the control of entry into the labor market by men leads to proleterianization of the actual workers. There is a continuous demand for their labor; they have stable schedules and definitions of work; and they have power in negotiating wages.
However, as we see in Chapter 3, domestic workers do not identify themselves as “specialist” proletarian cleaners; nor do they identify themselves as “generalist” traditional maids. They choose an in-between work identity that is “housekeeper.” A desired personal relationship with their employer in terms of schedules, patronage benefits, and autonomy over the work process reflects their ideal definition of themselves. Although domestic workers may not have a rigid working-class identity, an overall analysis of the modes and structure of employment in this informal sector reveals the correlation with a formal sector. Regular and stable wages, as well as schedules and recruitment patterns, reveal the organized and dynamic nature of domestic service in Turkey.
Domestic service provides a dynamic space for the interaction of different classes of women—traditional rural worker and modern urban employer. According to classical and Marxist definitions of power, the domestic workers would have no power in their relations with the upper-class employers. However, applying James Scott's definition of power of the weak and “routine resistances,” Ozyegin attributes agency to the domestic workers. She claims a relational concept of power that is sustained through continuous negotiations of conflicting interests. These “femininities in competition…selectively utilize and negotiate patriarchal gender beliefs in numerous, subtle, and equivocal ways in their day to day interactions with each other” (p. 151).
Chapter 5 presents an inquiry into door keeping, concluding that both class and gender servility is imposed on the migrant families through this institution. Based on the exploitation of family labor, door keeping uses the migrant family as a laboring unit. As the husband's “gender anxiety” heightens with the feminine tasks of door keeping, patriarchal authority is increasingly asserted in the family. This discussion is crucial for an understanding of the differences between women of the basement and women in squatter settlements in transformation of their economic power to gender equality in the household. Although both groups of women still derive their identities from their roles as wife and mother, and although their wages are spent in an altruistic manner, still they have a sense of economic agency. Ozyegin concludes that these women's pleasure in the perception of agency and empowerment through working is an integral part of their reconfigured gender and class identity.
The only question and concern about Ozyegin's work would be a statistical one. As she admits herself, we cannot consider the sub-sample of women in the squatter settlements as a representative one because of the number of participants and the selection process. The survey was conducted with only 57 women from this group (compared with 103 women from the women of the basement group) who are mostly related to one another through kinship. This fact makes the statistically necessary independent and random-sampling procedure questionable. Still, we should not devalue this path-breaking intensive fieldwork emphasizing the individual voices and agency of many domestic workers.
In sum, the unique field research produces many conclusions on domestic service as an informal sector and on gender and class relations within and between rural migrant and modern urban populations. The book clearly shows the challenges to rural identities in new spaces and conditions of life and how the migrants re-create their space by inventing a new adaptive culture. In all, Ozyegin's meticulous empirical analysis of traditional migrant women, supported by a strong theoretical framework, is a valuable resource for those who inquire into the complexities of modernization in developing countries.