This book provides a creative and engaging take on an issue of considerable topical relevance in both of the countries studied. Present-day Argentina and Chile are both experiencing significant levels of urban protest and mobilization, something that has been almost routine in Argentine political culture but is a more recent departure for Chile, where student-led street protests in and since 2006 have irrupted onto a largely static and demobilized posttransitional political arena. Given the high levels of security-force repression endured by both countries during the military dictatorships of the 1970s and 1980s, the issue of police behavior, and particularly of the management of citizen mobilization in public space, is a sensitive one and is often taken as a litmus test for the success or failure of the democratization of state–citizen relations and the exercise of coercive power.
Michelle Bonner adapts the horizontal and vertical accountability framing developed by Guillermo O’Donnell, and the social accountability variant of it proposed by Catalina Smulovitz and Enrique Peruzzotti, to investigate how and by whom the limits of “acceptable” protest policing are set, developed, and challenged in response to incidents and accusations of heavy-handed or outright repressive police behavior. She finds that Argentina has managed to a greater degree to develop a civil rights framing for expectations of police behavior, one that acts to inhibit police violence somewhat and reduce manipulation or stage-managing of protest incidents and the reporting of them. By contrast, she asserts that in Chile, a public-order framing persists, basically suspicious of collective action and of the motives and intentions of protesters, and accordingly more tolerant of repressive or transgressive police treatment of participants. Thus far, the characterization is convincing, albeit static. However, Bonner usefully also offers an account of the ways in which such framings have changed or may continue to evolve. She adopts the notion of “discursive accountability” as a framing activity through which various actors strive to “create … a cognitive environment where it is understood that repressive protest policing is no longer acceptable” (p. 26).
Chapter 1 discusses how the very notion of repressive and nonrepressive policing, and the dividing line between them, is necessarily contextually and culturally determined. Chapter 2 examines the particular meanings of protest policing behavior in the context of low-intensity Latin American democracies, given not only authoritarian legacies but also the effect of neoliberalism in stripping down state functions to the point where security provision, in its narrow, policing, interpretation, is foregrounded. Chapters 3 to 5 provide, respectively, a history of Argentine protest policing, and analyses of prevailing discourses about it, including media treatments. Chapter 6 takes the case study of Pueyrredon Bridge, where two men were killed during a 2002 protest incident, which has been widely considered a tipping point toward a more skeptical and less indulgent attitude on the part of political authorities toward police wrongdoing, real or alleged.
Turning next to Chile, Chapters 7 to 10 treat similar themes showing a basic contrast in much stronger public sympathy for police, even during and after the Pinochet dictatorship. Unsurprisingly, therefore, media and other discourses tend to cast doubt on the motives and veracity of protesters, rather than police, to the point where protest organizers are persuaded of the need for and legitimacy of requests to “self-police” activity in public space. The case study chapter, however, illustrates Bonner’s discussion of the dynamism of discursive frames, showing how undeniable police wrongdoing in 2010 student protests was eventually acknowledged by the conservative mainstream press, leading to the eventual, albeit grudging, recognition by police authorities of individual—though never institutional—“excesses.” Although a dominant civil rights framing still seems distant or improbable, there is a detectable shift toward the expectation of transparency and accountability to back up police claims of exigent circumstance.
Bonner’s concept of discursive frames, developed, deployed, and internalized by a mix of institutional and noninstitutional actors (inter alia police chiefs, political authorities, social movements, and human rights organizations), is useful in bridging the gap otherwise left between official policy pronouncements and the monitoring of media coverage, since mass media sources are rarely a particularly reliable guide to the “general public opinion” for which they are so often, and somewhat lazily, taken as a proxy. We are, in other words, presented with a more realistic and nuanced scenario where public opinion varies widely, certain groups have a much closer and more personal stake in rights-compliant policing than do others, and that which individual officers believe and are told is and is not acceptable does inform their everyday behavior on and off the job. Getting inside the heads of public officials or members of the security services, in order to somehow decipher what they really make of the written and unwritten codes that surround their profession and others’ perceptions of it, is of course a challenge better suited to social psychological or even anthropological techniques than to the political science framing adopted here.
The author wisely steers clear of claiming special insight into what officers “really” think or do, and her subject is primarily what is thought of and said about, rather than by, police responsible for facilitating and managing social protest. Nonetheless, it is striking that the interview lists given in an appendix are notably light on police interviewees for Chile (only three sources are given, in contrast to nine for Argentina). This may reflect institutional disengagement or reluctance to be interviewed on the part of Chilean forces, as well as the larger and more diverse nature of policing structures in federal Argentina. However, the answer would in itself be of interest in allowing more conclusions to be drawn about the readiness of the respective countries’ forces to engage in informed discussion about their practices. If Chilean forces regard protest in itself as a suspect and largely illegitimate activity, we might surmise that they may be equally unreceptive to the notion of scrutiny from outside bodies or scholarly study, whether national or international. Since this kind of receptivity is, however, at the heart of Bonner’s notion of discursive accountability, the question is of more than secondary importance.
Justification of the comparison itself is also somewhat light on detail: While it is clear that a comparison of these two neighboring countries is achievable, valid, and interesting, there is relatively little identification of the independent variable set that is being tested in each case, such as might make the book of broader interest. The assertion that the study tells us about “the challenges of repressive protest policing in new democracies” (p. 15) is not quite borne out, although the book’s conclusions do make convincing efforts to go beyond the self-evident fact that all policing settings generate social discourses in order to show how particular aspects and dynamics of those discourses can combine toward a restraining, civil-rights-framed consensus. More on the processes by which discursive-accountability actors emerge and decide to make policing a particular object of their activism would, however, be welcome, as would more elaboration of when and under what circumstances their goals meet with wider social take-up and approbation (the author does, for instance, describe the unusual breakthrough in “friendly” media reporting of Chilean student protests in 2010, but does not convincingly account for it).
Overall, Policing Protest in Argentine and Chile is a readable and well-sourced work that will be of interest to scholars and students of policing issues, Latin American political and social dynamics, and possibly also of discourse and framing approaches to civil society mobilization.
