Dear Political Science, We address you, but we want you to recognize that this is not for you. The contributions to this symposium are for the women of color who identify as political scientists: to those who remain in the confines of the discipline and to those who have broken free at all stages.
This symposium was inspired by a three-day writing retreat that the authors attended preceding the 2020 Southern Political Science Annual Conference in San Juan, Puerto Rico. We were 10 early-career women of color from universities around the country. During the retreat, we engaged in accountability partnerships, thought exercises, and in-depth writing experiences paced by our own needs. Moreover, we each found space at the retreat to engage in authentic dialogue about what it means to be a woman of color in political science, how graduate school shaped our early-career experiences, and what we hope our work will provide in terms of intervening in the broader discipline.
As a result of this retreat, we organized this symposium to describe how spaces like these (1) decolonize existing notions of productivity and worth in the discipline; (2) foster mentorship and connectedness for scholars at the margins across institutions; (3) require greater support from political science associations seeking to increase retention of women of color, disabled, immigrant, queer, and gender-nonconforming faculty; and (4) necessitate our own attention to how we hold space in the discipline and in the communities with which we identify. By putting ourselves first in conversation about these topics, we hope to shape the dialogue around junior women of color and how we might reimagine structures that support our existence, scholarship, and collaboration while also dismantling harmful practices rooted in colonial and neoliberal politics.
WHAT DOES IT MEAN AND LOOK LIKE TO DECOLONIZE POLITICAL SCIENCE?
From its inception, American higher education was limited to property-owning white males. This meant that access to education was dictated by the systems of power that privileged wealth, whiteness, and masculinity. Entire disciplines and their methodologies are founded on colonialism, white supremacy, heteropatriarchy, and capitalism. We are continually reminded that Western academia persists as an active hegemonic force and that political science as a discipline is no different in genealogy. As increasing numbers of nonwhite, poor, and historically marginalized students and faculty gain access to higher education, we are confronted by academic standards based on these underlying oppressive ideologies and their gatekeepers.
This symposium deconstructs this broader inquiry through several urgent questions: How has chronic fatigue and exhaustion shaped the lives of women of color in political science? What are the unique constraints that junior women of color face at this particular moment? How can we fashion a new way forward that prioritizes collective care and restoration as central to our academic practice? We write from what bell hooks (Reference Harbin and Greene1989) called a “profound edge”: we locate ourselves in this space of radical openness knowing that “our living depends on our ability to conceptualize alternatives, often improvised.” This symposium was written collectively during the year after the initial retreat and through a series of conversations in the wake of multiple ongoing world crises.
We started this collaborative writing during a global pandemic that has so severely impacted the lives and livelihoods of women of color in academia. Many of us still have not had time to grieve and mourn the tremendous loss in our families and communities. We write as the pandemic has altered our conceptions of time, normalcy, and relationalities with one another and with work. Themes emerging from this symposium engage with issues of exhaustion, community care, and combating the various harms that we face daily in our discipline. We critically engage with the harmful practices that we see in the discipline with the intention that we do not reproduce those that have caused us harm.
CENTERING REST AGAINST A TIDE OF COMPULSORY PRODUCTIVITY
Our symposium addresses the specific ways that conference culture perpetuates the notion that we must produce scholarship despite the conditions of the world. With rigid deadlines, unrelenting online conference schedules, and unaffordable workshops that frequently require junior scholars to pay in advance of reimbursement, we are constrained, hampered, and exhausted. In Jackson and Juárez Pérez (2022, this issue), the authors suggest that productivity narratives must be reframed and redefined to account for the unique circumstances that face junior women of color. They suggest that scholars at the margins adopt a form of radical self-love that “entails deprogramming of neoliberal productivity narratives, healing from abuse, holding ourselves accountable for hurt we have caused, and developing work cultures centered on our needs rather than profits.”
We confront the demands of universities to continue teaching in an attempt to return to normal when many of us are sick, chronically ill, disabled, and immunosuppressed. We are expected to remain flexible to serve institutions even when the rigidity of campus administrators, alumni, parents, and trustees put students, staff, and faculty at risk of premature death. Harbin and Greene (2022, this issue) describe these processes as “invisible forms of labor” expected from junior women of color in the discipline and how “these requests are especially burdensome for those of us who are the only faculty member of color in our department.” While enduring trauma from personal loss, historic global unrest, environmental catastrophe, and ongoing repression from police, health officials, and academic institutions, junior women of color are asked to show up and drop all of these issues at the door. This context is critical for this issue as we come together in this pandemic to prioritize our well-being and to reimagine alternate temporalities of work.
ON COMMUNITY CARE
We situate our collective work within a much longer lineage of women of color in academia, including bell hooks, Audre Lorde, June Jordan, and the Combahee River Collective, who are building alternative models of care and labor outside of neoliberal capitalist imperatives. We locate our work within a lineage of women of color in political science who are channeling resources and building spaces of radical nourishment such as the work of Sistah Scholar, People of Color Also Know Stuff, and the Women of Color Workshops. This work inspires us to continue advocating for our own spaces, for us by us; to reclaim our own narratives; and to move away from pain and victimization to sustenance and abundance. Lemi, Scott, and Wong (2022, this issue) discuss in their article how to envision new relationalities that leave open the possibility for experimentation and improvisation: “[w]e manifest abundance and challenge the scarcity mindset that years of chasing papers have left us with.”
We approach our collective work keeping in mind what Piepzna-Samarasinha (Reference Jackson and Pérez2018) wrote about making time to tend to one another’s needs, desires, dreams, and visions: we prioritize building our own “care webs” so that those who are most precarious in the discipline can fully participate in the work with autonomy and dignity. As Piepzna-Samarasinha (Reference Jackson and Pérez2018, 17) reminded us, “This is about some of the ways we are attempting to dream…in a way where we are in control, joyful, building community, loved, giving, and receiving, in a way that doesn’t burn anyone out or abuse or underpay anyone in the process.” This work is not easy and so much of it is trial and error plus persistence. It requires us to slow down and to enact alternative models of time, accountability, and productivity that exist outside of capitalist paradigms to ensure that we do not replicate existing harms of the neoliberal university.
FORGING OUR OWN PATH
In all of these articles, the contributors invite us to think beyond the current realities of the discipline and to imagine what political science could be when we take better care of one another. Nelson and Sedique (2022, this issue) reflect on their experiences from the retreat and what it means to create deliberate spaces that are rooted in restoration to center our own needs in the writing process. What becomes clear is that the writing process is about not only putting words to paper but also being thoughtful about the struggles, fears, and burdens that can inhibit our ability to write—and about the hopes, visions, and joys that compel us to write our multiple truths.
This symposium also discusses being intentional about building mentorship opportunities as care networks. Fields and Means (2022, this issue) reflect on the importance of sponsorship as a necessary component of support for building and sustaining the pipeline of junior women of color in the discipline. At the individual level, Jackson and Juárez Pérez (2022, this issue) remind us to slow down and to practice radical self-love as a means to combat the insidiousness of colonization that has silenced and erased our own humanity. It is important that decolonizing ourselves leads us to abandon harmful and toxic practices that deepen our precarity and devastate our emotional and mental health. This engagement includes cultivating a decolonial citation practice that does not reinforce the power of abusers and gatekeepers.
This symposium calls for a decolonizing of the discipline that centers radical kinship that comes from rest and restoration, as the Combahee River Collective (1977) reminded us: “[t]he only people who care enough about us to work consistently for our liberation are us.” As conferences urge us to return to “normal” despite living through multiple pandemics, we see conference culture as a primary site of the hyper-productivity model that prioritizes work over anything else. Instead of focusing on the neoliberal capitalist drive to return to normal—the productivity of the tenure track, conferences, presentations, grants, and deadlines—we commit to moving at a slower pace that prioritizes ourselves and one another. We refuse to simply move on. We invite women of color, political scientists, and other scholars invested in liberation to join us in changing our discipline to one that embraces wholeness.
I feel like the world is running past me.
Failure—colonizer in my head.
Paranoia—surveillance state in my home.
Pain—received and caused.
Carrying over 500 hundred years of trauma in my blood.
So, y’all keep running, don’t mind me here, just puffing trees under the moonlight.
In solidarity,
Jenn Jackson, Jamil Scott, Melina Juárez Pérez, and Diane Wong
Coeditors
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We acknowledge that this symposium was conceived on occupied Taíno Territories and developed and completed on Indigenous lands across Turtle Island. We honor the ongoing resistance and stewardship of Indigenous peoples on whose lands we live, work, and play—from Lenape Lands to the Coast Salish Sea. We thank the anonymous reviewers, all the women of color in the discipline whose shoulders we stand on, and Melissa Michelson and Michael Jones-Correa for their early support of this project.
