Insiders, Outsiders, Injuries and Law is a festschrift volume that is not only a tribute to its honouree, but also stands independently as a contribution to socio-legal studies for scholars and students alike. Dedicated to David M. Engel, a distinguished socio-legal scholar at the State University of New York (SUNY) at Buffalo, the volume is a collection of essays celebrating Professor Engel's influential article, ‘The Oven Bird's song’ (Reference Engel1984, and reprinted in the volume reviewed here; pages cited refer to the reprinted version of Engel's paper, hereafter ‘Oven Bird’). Contributors examine the paper's themes, purposes and sources, as well as its critical legacy in classrooms and subsequent socio-legal scholarship in the US and abroad.
The ‘Oven Bird’ of 1984 reports Engel's ethnographic work on law use in the pseudonymous Sander County, a semi-rural mid-western township where he conducted fieldwork as a legal scholar in the late 1970s. The paper is best known for his finding that people who identified themselves as Sander County natives tended to forego filing personal-injury claims, even when confronted with serious injuries incurring through no fault of their own. Contract disputes, on the other hand, flowed more readily to the county court. The contrast forms the paper's core question. Engel points to the centrality of the court (or, rather, the idea of the court) to people's sense of community. The perception of the court in this regard is in some ways shared by both of the groups that Engel (following local discourse) distinguishes as insiders and outsiders. Insiders forego injury claims as evidence of their priority on community over compensation when things go wrong. Outsiders acknowledge the value of community but have little experience of it, particularly in the sense of having local support networks. Importantly in Engel's analysis, the distinction between insiders and outsiders is one that residents see differently depending on their sense of community membership. Insiders regard it as a moral distinction – imagining themselves to be guardians of a local tradition of getting along and seeing outsiders as valuing ‘bucks’ more than social ties. Outsiders, meanwhile, confront injury as a practical problem – for example, regarding litigation as offering the possibility of income replacement if they are unable to work, in the absence of other forms of community support.
‘Oven Bird's’ conclusion throws the insider/outsider distinction into relief as a self-reinforcing moral distinction embedded in the contemporary circumstances of Sander County – a distinction that (as Engel indicates) says more about tensions and anxieties in the community at the time than it does about demographic transformation per se. For Engel, insiders are living out an invented tradition that exists ‘nowhere except their imaginations’ (p. 36). This is an essential point: although residents may express their moral judgments in terms of categorical distinctions that emulate a sociological discourse (e.g. ‘insiders’ and ‘outsiders’), these terms conceal as much as they reveal with regard to actual social relations, lines of division or exclusions. Engel's cultural analysis shows Sander County residents wrestling with changes made visible by new arrivals, but he also shows how selective their focus was: newcomers were present but, in the moral logic of insiders, they were also stand-ins for a host of other developments – new forms of business, for example, and other revisions of the literal and figurative landscape.
Throughout, Engel's focus is on residents’ ideas of litigation as an indicator of their status relative to the community as they know it – not their experience of litigation processes or outcomes. The occlusion of law, politics and economy in the very image of the litigious outsider and its counterpart, the scheming insider, is among the most crucial insights in ‘Oven Bird’ and is developed further in Engel's subsequent writings on Sander County (Engel, Reference Engel1987; Greenhouse et al., Reference Greenhouse, Yngvesson and Engel1994).Footnote 1
The Trautner collection originated in part in conference papers delivered at SUNY Buffalo Law School to celebrate David Engel's long career there. Barbara Yngvesson's comprehensive chapter situates ‘Oven Bird’ in the context of Engel's other major research projects and professional commitments, and Alfred Konefsky's chapter sets the work in the context of the SUNY/Buffalo law faculty. But, otherwise, the star of this book is the work itself, as written by Engel and read by colleagues (and reread by Engel himself in the book's concluding chapter). Especially for those who know David Engel, this deflection will be immediately recognisable as consistent with his personal modesty (for an example of which, see his comments on the reception of this widely celebrated work in Halliday and Schmidt (Reference Halliday and Schmidt2009, p. 91)). Focusing on the life of one paper rather than the life of the singular scholar who wrote it brings out to a remarkable degree the suggestive richness of ‘Oven Bird's ethnographic substance. It also foregrounds the institutional and historical context of its production in the late 1970s and early 1980s, and its ongoing reception among socio-legal scholars and their students in the decades since. In this regard, the SUNY/Buffalo law school emerges as a vital centre of collegial support and scholarly creativity. These more local aspects of the book should interest anyone concerned with what academic workplaces have become since the 1980s.
Birds of a feather
The editor, sociologist Mary Nell Trautner, has thoughtfully arranged the chapters into five parts, the fifth wholly devoted to a chapter by David Engel offering further thoughts on ‘Oven Bird’ (more on this below). The thematic organisation of the volume reveals the editor's creative choreography of the book's collegial project of collective rereading. Most of the contributors, writing from their own primary research, address the implications of an insider–outsider distinction such as Engel found in Sander County for questions of access to law and justice in the US and elsewhere.
Part I reprints ‘The Oven Bird's Song’ and presents two chapters on the theoretical and institutional context of Engel's ethnographic research in Sander County (by Barbara Yngvesson and Alfred Konefsky respectively, as mentioned above).
Part II turns to research inspired at least in part by ‘Oven Bird’, particularly with regard to perceptions of law use as a register of difference: on matters of legal consciousness (Anna Maria Marshall), lawyers’ client selection (Lynn Mather), jury judgments (Valerie Hans) and the social dimensions of contracts (Stuart Macaulay). Macaulay's essay is unique in the collection in attending specifically to the short section of ‘Oven Bird’ that focuses on contract litigation, where Engel points to a contrast between Sander County insiders’ expressed negative attitudes towards personal-injury suits and their positive attitudes towards contract suits. Macaulay reads this paradox as reflecting a fundamental ambivalence over rights and the limits of rights as a basis for social connectedness. As Macaulay observes, ‘rights do not enforce themselves’ (p. 120).
Extending that insight, Part III turns the lens the other way, to consider difference – in particular class and other status differences in the US – as a recursive effect of the social distribution of rights and the selectivity of affirmative access to the legal system: for indigenous people (Eve Darian-Smith), underserved workers (Michael McCann) and people criminalised in migration (Jamie Longazel). Anne Bloom's chapter examines the identity implications of tort law's construction of productive bodies – a theme that resonates with David Engel's concluding chapter, where he reflects on his research on the socio-legal dimensions of disability, re-imagining the low rates of personal-injury litigation in Sander County as effects of personal exhaustion from physical pain and the stress of complex circumstances for potential plaintiffs (for a methodological discussion of Engel's work on disability, see also Berrey and Nielsen (Reference Berrey and Nielsen2007)). Renée Ann Cramer's chapter – like McCann's essay on teaching ‘Oven Bird’ but from a different angle – takes readers to her classroom, where current students find ready identification with the reluctant litigants of the Sander County of almost four decades ago.
The idea of difference as among the circulatory effects of law is the main theme of Part IV. Contributors develop problems of legal choice making and the micropolitics of conflict and conflict resolution in Taiwan (Anya Bernstein), Japan (Yoshitaka Wada) and Canada (Annie Bunting). These chapters reveal both similarities and differences in comparison with Sander County residents and, more to the point of this section, confirm the viability of Engel's insights as a basis for comparative socio-legal research, particularly through ethnographic and other qualitative methods. In turning from the US to what the editor calls ‘other cultures’ in the title for this part of the book (p. 217), Part IV raises questions for the book as a whole.
The division of the book into US and non-US subsets is interesting in itself, since it is mainly in that light that readers may be alerted to the diversity of implicit cultural claims throughout the book. Authors take subtly different positions on such questions as: What is the relationship of citizenship to culture through law? To what cultures are these others ‘other’? Do Sander County insiders have a local culture? Is Sander County a local version of something we should call American culture – or perhaps a version of what many observers see as America's two-culture problem? Is law necessarily the law of a culture, the mediator of its internal conflicts and contradictions? Readers familiar with socio-legal scholarship will recognise the resonance of these formulations. By contrast, in ‘Oven Bird’ and in his concluding essay, Engel finds a different opening to cultural inquiry in the effort (by anyone, resident or analyst alike) to identify the ambiguous stakes in questions such as these, as well as in the asymmetrical social relations that make such stakes visible. His interpretivist approach is of a piece with his ethnographic method, in the field and in the text. Overall, the collection necessarily leaves the cultural question open, presenting it in different ways in the separate essays (usually as a question of method). This very quality makes the book as a whole strikingly well suited for use in classrooms wherever ‘law and society’ traditions frame the discussion. Its clarity and accessibility of prose are additional assets in this regard.
Other birds, other songs
Most of the book's chapters address ‘Oven Bird’ by looking back across the space of time between now and then – tracing its imprint on subsequent scholarship, its status as canon and its comparative implications. This temporality is obviously appropriate to the purpose of the volume as a critical celebration of a paper that proved to be both harbinger and – in this collection – proxy for its author's ensuing scholarly career. But the afterlife of ‘Oven Bird’ is not the only temporal dimension of the collection. Engel himself, always alert to the complex ways in which law and social relationships curate time (see Engel, Reference Engel1987; Engel and Engel, Reference Engel and Engel2010), situates the paper in its own ‘now’ – a now that expands with his retrospection in Part V.
‘Oven Bird’ and those interpretive afterthoughts suggest that Engel's analysis can be read not just as an enduring artefact of its own times in our present day, but also as a dynamic prequel to what came next in its own day. Engel is interested in temporality and in a subtle way resists the implication of timelessness that the work's canonical status might seem to invite. He himself emphasises the connections between time and experience (and time as experience) in contexts of social change. We know (explicitly from Engel himself, p. 36) that the nostalgia Sander County insiders felt for the town's imagined past was false in its pastness; however, as he and some of the other contributors suggest, this is only part of the story. The rest begins in the question of what might have been, or might yet be, the future truth of residents’ ideas about their lives together and apart (Engel, Reference Engel1987, p. 606). In Sander County, insiders worried about ‘Mexicans’, ‘Commies’ and blue-collar workers who had recently arrived as employees in the town's newly established factories – lumping these groups together along with nameless others who (in the words of one interviewee) killed their downtown ‘dead’ at some point before Engel's arrival (pp. 12–13).
It would be impossible now (or then, as Engel makes clear) to disentangle the arrival of shopping malls and industrial parks from the timeline of residents’ concerns about the future in Sander County and, wisely, Engel does not venture into causal explanations. But he does emphasise the importance of ‘events of articulation’ – that is, events that crystallise more diffuse concerns, giving them a definite form or image (Engel, Reference Engel1987, pp. 612–615; see also Greenhouse et al., Reference Greenhouse, Yngvesson and Engel1994, p. 113). Importantly, he shows not only the insiders’ concerns in this regard, but also those of the outsiders who – rightly, it seems – saw the town's inner workings as the privileged domain of long-time residents. In the reported interviews, individuals referred to insiders and outsiders collectively, as if everyone's identity was bound up in one or the other category – indeed, obviating the very idea of ‘everyone’ except within these categorical terms. Engel's narrative emphasises the local unease in this arrangement. And his own. His account makes clear the sense of the town's recent emptiness as being due not just to diminished foot traffic in shops and restaurants, but an evacuation of identity itself, depersonalising the public in a way that many residents – insiders and outsiders alike – appear to have found personally alienating.
Engel's portrait of a community in distress over the erasure of personal and collective identity is subtly drawn. Crucially, ‘Oven Bird’ does not portray a straightforward prejudice against newcomers in behavioural terms, but rather – consistently with his cultural approach mentioned earlier – he offers a more complex assessment of the ways residents attached locally unfamiliar faces to otherwise faceless large-scale processes of political economy affecting the town and county. Perhaps the alternative to this symbolic diversion would have been to look to each other – to name names, so to speak, as to decisions taken and implemented. The insiders’ implicit critique of the transformation of capital in their town – its accumulation rendered impersonal and without apparent limit by the new enterprises in their surroundings – is a crucial part of the backdrop behind the paper's law story. Those connections, explicit in ‘Oven Bird’, are also brought to the fore in Engel's subsequent writing on time and social change in Sander County (Engel, Reference Engel1987).
How, then, shall we look forward from where Sander County stood then? To some extent, Sander County's story might – I stress might – seem to fit easily on a timeline that includes what came next in the US: strong electoral majorities favouring candidates who supported the Reagan revolution, a backlash against civil-rights law enforcement in Congress and the courts, a significant dismantling of the federal safety net in welfare and antidiscrimination law, mass incarceration and a significant hardening of immigration law targeting the southern border. In light of the way in which federal law and policy have generally unfolded since the 1980s, the force of those local prejudices in Sander County is palpable – easily read as if they were evidence of a national political discourse spoken in local accents.Footnote 2 In the wider bipartisan political community that made neoliberal capitalism into the political mainstream in the US, the image of immigrants, welfare recipients and tort plaintiffs as morally suspect, poised to cash in on their rights, became familiar tropes in the public debates that shaped the Civil Rights Act of 1991, the Welfare Reform Act of 1996 and the Immigration Reform Act of 1996 – and much since. In hindsight, ‘Oven Bird’ might be read as showing the context of such concerns in face-to-face relations. What can we say of its foresight?
Red birds or blue?
The relevance of Engel's analysis of Sander County to understanding what came next in the US is not only its evidence of moral judgment and social prejudice as elements of the legal fabric of that small community, but also his theoretical concerns with the intertwining of logics of otherness within liberal individualism. Engel's account exposes the extent to which people's selective alienation from the institutions of government (incipient in Sander County while Engel was conducting research there, pp. 28–30) circulates through the same channels by which they demarcate difference in their own milieu – even through their own injured bodies.
Where contracts are concerned, though, Sander County insiders were prepared to litigate (pp. 30–32, 33), their interest in preserving the institution of the contract outweighing the considerations that held them back from personal-injury claims. Most contributors to the Trautner volume who mention it read this as essentially a paradoxical finding; however, Engel's analysis points to another possibility. Yes, insiders reached for the courthouse door on the one path and not on the other, but on both paths – from the perspective Engel offers – they value legal contracts as social contracts. Thus, their acceptance of contract suits is not automatically inconsistent with their restraint in the personal-injury domain; we need both domains to understand either. As for outsiders – like insiders when faced with breaches of contract – rights appear to be meaningful in that they are understood not just as promising access to law's power, but also as social contracts (though formulated differently, around their status as workers or citizens, for example, rather than as neighbours). Here, too, noticing the connections between outsiders and insiders in this regard underscores the varied ways in which Engel's interlocutors register litigation as an index of moral value and express their understandings of moral value as derived from a sense of membership, responsibility and choice. Of insiders and outsiders alike, then, one could say that they either act on their rights or, with those rights in view, act otherwise. The choice – no matter which one – is meaningful to them as moral action only to the extent that it is a choice, and a choice adjoined to social responsibility (in whatever terms this is understood).
This is a more complicated picture than it might seem to be at first. Engel describes the complex ways in which residents’ ideas of law's place in public and private life are filtered by local knowledge, preference and opportunity over time. This is not to say that the lines of difference between insiders and outsiders are independent of anyone's experiences of stigma, prejudice or exclusion, but that, as a work of cultural analysis, the beauty – the theoretical heft – of ‘Oven Bird’ is the weight Engel puts on the irreducible combination of all of these factors in time. In this way, the paper leaves the future open, stopping at the point at which Engel rejects the idea of the court as marking the difference between the (imagined) past and present. Rather – for insiders, outsiders and scholars alike – the idea of the court as Engel portrays it divides an uncertain future from itself. The recent revival of debates over legal consciousness in socio-legal studies confirms Engel's prescience in his search to understand the dialectics of the new forms of inequality Sander County residents saw emerging and for which they were feeling essentially unprepared (see Young and Billings, Reference Young and Billings2020, pp. 34–35; also Berrey and Nielsen, Reference Berrey and Nielsen2007, p. 34; Abrego, Reference Abrego2019, p. 644).
Reading from today's present, it is too easy to read the paper as an explanation of the political geography that divides red and blue in the contemporary US – in other words, to assume that Sander County's insiders mobilised their alienation and passed it along to their children, incubating resentments across generations that became visible as the nationalist populist movements that reshaped the electoral landscape around xenophobia and anti-globalism. Perhaps. But in fact this is impossible to know, and not just because we readers do not know the identity of Sander County or the tenor of the town now. Rather, it is because it is so difficult to read ‘Oven Bird’ now without the lenses of that subsequent national history first filtering the possibilities.
Moreover, as an empirical matter, caution is warranted since the fundamental difference within the account is the one that distinguishes personal injury from contract suits – more fundamental since it is a more or less stable empirical distinction in a way that the difference between insiders and outsiders cannot be. The difference between insiders and outsiders is (as Engel's concluding line about the imagined past makes clear) a temporal distinction, not an empirical one. Appreciating this delivers fresh insights as we look to the future of Sander County from where ‘Oven Bird’ ends. Are we looking in the mirror? This is another way of asking: Is the future open or closed? At the paper's close, the hegemony of the insiders is neither guaranteed nor permanent, consequential though it was at the time of Engel's writing. In our current milieu, this possibility may seem counter-intuitive, or just wrong-headed. But, as I see it, if there is a lesson for us now in Sander County then, it is that the current political situation in the nation at large was not inevitable. Insiders and outsiders were contingent statuses, not fixed traditions or bounded communities.
The contributions to Insiders, Outsiders, Injuries, and the Law – including ‘Oven Bird’ itself – show how challenging it is to distinguish empirically between democratic individualism and alienation once the value of a person is imagined in monetary terms. This conundrum is evident in insiders’ and outsiders’ moral reasoning with respect to personal-injury and contract suits in Sander County – in the process drawing courts into processes of economic, social and political change (see also Young and Billings, Reference Young and Billings2020, p. 33). Perceptions of courts in relation to personal interests, as well as ordinary people's uses of law, are at the fulcrum of this interpretive dilemma. This is the essence of the Trautner volume's timely immediacy, as contributors probe a complex set of cultural contradictions that law makes visible at particular times and places, but that law cannot resolve.
