William Robert Grove was, as the subtitle of Iwan Rhys Morus's short biography tells us, a ‘Victorian gentleman of science’. He was also a Welshman, born in Swansea in 1811, though he spent most of his career in London. Morus's book is among the first contributions to a new series from the University of Wales Press on Scientists of Wales, and it endeavours to place Grove firmly within his Welsh context as a means to open up consideration of how science ought to figure in the way Welsh people view themselves and are viewed by others. Although the book will be of interest to many historians of science, its main intended audience clearly lies among the Welsh. Citing Grove's work in developing the gas battery (now better known as the fuel cell and widely touted as a promising source of clean electric power), Morus asks (p. 3), ‘what would the history of science – and of Wales – look like if a Welshman were credited with inventing one of this century's most significant technological innovations? What would that do to the way we – the Welsh – think of ourselves and science?’ Should it really matter where particular scientists and inventors come from; what languages they speak; what ethnic, racial or gender identities they hold? Scientific results may ultimately be impersonal, but it is clear enough that in practice such things do matter, not least in the effects that recognizing such origins and identities may have on people, particularly the young and members of marginalized groups, who are contemplating their own relationship with and potential place in science. Here Grove presents an intriguing, though not altogether straightforward, example of what it might mean to be both Welsh and a man of science.
Grove was far from being a marginal figure in his own time, and Morus devotes many of his pages to reminding us just how prominent and widely respected Grove was in the Victorian scientific world. He was well known for his experimental achievements and inventions, though more for the powerful zinc and platinum battery he devised in 1839 than for the fuel cell that has more recently become his main claim to fame. He was also celebrated for his influential writings on ‘the correlation of forces’, which in many ways paralleled and foreshadowed the principle of the conservation of energy, as well as for his efforts to reform and modernize the Royal Society of London and other British scientific institutions. Later in his career Grove was also a distinguished jurist, becoming a judge of the Court of Common Pleas in 1871 and rising to the Queen's Bench in 1880; he was knighted in 1872. In short, throughout most of the long Victorian era, Grove was a distinguished figure in both the scientific and legal worlds, widely recognized and amply honoured. But with few exceptions, notably when he arranged to have the British Association for the Advancement of Science meet in his native Swansea in 1848, he was rarely regarded as particularly Welsh. Certainly from the 1850s on, when he was firmly established in London, Grove seems to have seen himself and been seen by others as someone who came from Wales but later largely left it behind.
Morus is the leading authority on the electrical world of early nineteenth-century London, and he does of masterful job of weaving together accounts of Grove's development of new batteries, his work as professor of experimental philosophy at the London Institution in the 1840s, and his use of the platform that position afforded him to expound his ideas about the correlation of forces. Morus is especially good on Grove's use of technologies of display, so that for Grove the gas battery served not primarily as a clean source of electrical power but as a means to illustrate in a striking way the conversion of chemical affinity into electrical force, and so to convey the broader principle of the correlation of all physical forces.
Grove contributed to science in many ways and in many different venues, from the laboratory bench to the lecture hall, and from devising instruments to helping guide scientific societies. Beyond his role as a young man in helping to launch the Swansea Scientific and Literary Institution (later the Royal Institution of South Wales), and later in bringing the British Association to Swansea, none of these activities were specifically Welsh. There was certainly nothing distinctively Welsh about the gas battery or the principle of the correlation of physical forces, and Morus is far from claiming otherwise. But neither were they un-Welsh, and this, it seems to me, is the underlying point of this book and of the series of which it is part. By the early decades of the nineteenth century, South Wales, like many other areas in the British Isles and throughout Europe, was fully capable of producing and nurturing, at least in a small way, someone like Grove with an interest in science. By the end of his life, Grove had travelled a long way from his roots in Wales, but those roots nonetheless still lay in Wales. As Morus concludes (p. 145), ‘Whether it makes sense for us now to describe Grove as a Welsh man of science is clearly an open question’. What matters, though, is that someone born and raised in Wales could become a significant contributor to science in the nineteenth century, and that ‘we can see how Wales and Swansea's scientific culture contributed to making him what he was’.
