The public understanding of science campaign emerged in the 1980s out of a concern among scientists that non-specialists (especially in politics and the media) had too little comprehension of basic science. Particularly in its early years, the movement was naive – not only about what needed to be communicated, but also about how people might be reached and why they might be sceptical, given the increasingly close alliance between research science and corporate commerce. In titling his new book Public Understanding of Science: A History of Communicating Scientific Ideas, David Knight recalls these debates but looks back to the long nineteenth century, when things were (at least in certain respects) very different.
During the decades from the French Revolution to the First World War, both the methods for communicating knowledge and the sciences themselves were dramatically transformed. The book opens by surveying the world of Newtonian natural theology, focuses mainly on Britain from the 1820s through to the 1860s, and closes with a call to recapture something of the excitement and fascination of exploring the natural world in this first ‘age of science’. The text is organized around the different ways in which the sciences were communicated: lectures, spectacles, museum displays, travel, science fiction and journalism. There is a chapter on the use of metaphorical language, poetry and symbols, and much on the visual appeal of science – although unfortunately no images are reproduced, in a book that would have been more accessible for its intended audience with an illustration on every page. One chapter (‘Suspending judgement’) focuses on the ways in which philosophical discussions of method have been used to convey the meaning of science, while another (‘Ballyhoo’) examines how the knowledge was presented in terms of technological breakthroughs that would transform everyday life. The text is sprinkled with brief asides and entertaining vignettes, and Knight's keen enthusiasm is apparent.
Almost everything that might be expected in a survey of this kind is mentioned, from the rise of rotary press printing to the changing roles of women in science. This is not, however, the place to look for a systematic account of the transformation of science in relation to state education, the economics of mass communication, or other potentially significant large historical themes. The changing meaning of the ‘public’ during the period, a charged political issue with major implications for this topic, is touched upon only lightly, as are problems in literacy, education and access. One gets the impression that the century was dominated by a few leading scientific figures and key ideas – and in certain contexts it was – but it would be good to know more about the range of people who actively participated in scientific practice by collecting, experimenting, observing, reading and debating. Possibilities for this kind of participation changed dramatically during the course of this period, a development discussed in the final chapter, but only briefly. Similarly, more could be said about the changing languages of science writing, both literary and visual.
One of the valuable aspects of this book is in its comments, often incidental, on how to get the message about history of science across to wider audiences. It is, after all, a work in which a leading pioneer in communicating the history of science tackles the subject of science communication. Knight's remarks are the fruit of long experience, not only as the author of Natural Science Books in English (New York, 1972), The Age of Science (Oxford, 1986) and many other books on related themes, but also as a broadcaster and public speaker. Anyone who has witnessed one of his well-known extemporaneous lectures – delivered with entertaining fluency and completely without notes – will recognize the true student of Davy and Faraday. ‘Professing should be a performance art’ (p. 36), Knight comments, and it is not difficult to hear his voice in these pages.
