In the wake of the 2016 presidential election, several narratives emerged to explain the unexpected outcome. First among these was the idea that Trump's economic proposals won over Democratic-leaning white working-class voters who felt “left behind.” After decades of worsening income inequality, and a surprisingly bipartisan strain of campaign rhetoric attacking economic elites, the 2016 campaign and Donald Trump's victory further fueled assertions that class is an increasingly important dividing line in American politics.
Hajnal's book convincingly demonstrates that this focus on class is misguided. America is indeed deeply divided, but on the basis of its oldest partition: race. Democracy, by definition, produces winners and losers, but Hajnal indicates that “race—more than class, and more than any other demographic characteristic—determines who wins and loses in American democracy” (p. 6). Even more importantly, Hajnal indicates that Trump's victory was not all that surprising in the first place; Trump is the culmination of trends in American electoral politics that make race and immigration central to partisanship, representation, and policy.
Hajnal seeks to evaluate outcomes of the democratic process in the United States, emphasizing patterns in winners and losers when aggregated by demographic characteristics. Given historical precedent, rising income inequality, and an increasingly unfettered campaign finance system, class-focused work (e.g., Bartels Reference Bartels2008; Gilens Reference Gilens2012) has received much attention from researchers seeking to evaluate American democracy. A larger divide between the wealthy and the poor than between Black and white Americans thus serves as Hajnal's foil throughout the book.
After an introductory chapter, Hajnal divides the book into four parts. The first measures demographic variation in who we choose to vote for. Using extensive survey data, including city-level exit polls, Hajnal shows that the gap between Black and white partisan choices, party identification, or even candidate preferences in nonpartisan local elections exceeds class divisions. Even for Latinos and Asian Americans, where differences from whites are smaller, it is impossible to ignore the growing role of race in structuring vote choice.
The second part of Dangerously Divided examines representational outcomes. Hajnal begins this section by examining minority officeholding but moves beyond descriptive representation in two ways. First, he counts winners and losers by examining how frequently each racial/ethnic group ends up supporting the winning candidate versus the losing candidate. Black voters are far more likely to support election losers than whites across all levels of elections, even after accounting for class, partisanship, and many other factors. Second, he examines policy responsiveness by counting how often each group had their spending priorities enacted into law. Using survey data from the 1970s to the present, Hajnal shows that Black voters are dramatically underrepresented in policy outcomes. Class divisions exist as well, but as Hajnal notes, “[c]lass only looks like an important factor if it is not compared to race” (p. 132).
The third part of the book focuses on whites' responses to contemporary immigration. White partisan choices are shaped by their opinions of immigrants, or more precisely, the Latino immigrants that are top-of-mind when voters think about immigration and population change. Again, he demonstrates that his explanation is superior to economic threat-based understandings. When evaluating policy consequences, Hajnal finds that state-level spending and taxation policy is associated with the size of the Latino population. In states where Latinos are a substantial, though not pivotal, share of the population, more regressive fiscal policy appears.
Is there any solution to this seemingly fundamental divide? The final part of Hajnal's book brings the analysis full circle, showing that voters' partisan choices impact which Americans will be full participants in American society. When Democrats are elected, Black-White gaps in responsiveness shrink or even reverse. Substantial improvements in the economic well-being of African-Americans, and to a lesser extent other racial/ethnic groups, are also associated with Democrats holding the presidency. Even after accounting for economic growth or the timing of partisan switches, favored measures in class-based work such as Bartels (Reference Bartels2008), Black well-being declines with Republicans and improves with Democrats in office.
The prescription is deceptively simple: elect more Democrats. Yet this belies a more radical truth regarding representation and the partisan reality of the contemporary United States. Republicans could choose to cater to minority groups going forward, but Democrats could also turn their back on their most reliable, and underrepresented, constituency due to the false lessons learned from 2016. Indeed, one takeaway from Hajnal's book is that American democracy is, and could continue to be, tilted in favor of whites despite demographic change.
Dangerously Divided points to at least two promising areas for future research. The first could clarify what produces and reduces Latino and Asian American underrepresentation. Hajnal notes the limits of his data here, but given the growth of these populations, and their status as more obvious targets for Republican outreach, further exploration is warranted. The second tackles the intersection of race and religion, particularly the growing divide between Evangelical Christian and non-religious (or even non-Evangelical) whites. Hajnal finds that class divisions are nowhere near as strong as the racial divide, but at multiple points in the analysis religion matches, or exceeds, the predictive power of race in structuring electoral preferences. Political scientists should scrutinize these patterns, especially as racially liberal whites consolidate their placement within the Democratic Party.
Hajnal offers both a vastly clearer picture of the inequalities perpetuated by contemporary American democracy and cogent determinations on what it would take to produce more equitable political and social outcomes. With an excellent combination of rigor, accessibility, and honesty about the challenges the United States faces, Hajnal's Democracy Divided is a must-read for anyone who seeks to better understand what ails our political system.
