Federico Ugolini calls attention to an under-studied collection of material, namely representations of harbours. These form a distinct iconographic corpus and feature detailed depictions of architectural installations, people (including non-elites such as sailors and dockworkers) and ships of various types and sizes. Previous scholarship has focused on individual images, typically for their contextual (pertaining to the decoration of rooms or houses) or perceived topographic value in reconstructing ancient ports (especially Alexandria, Puteoli and Portus). This leaves important questions unanswered. What unique aspects of the Roman Empire gave rise to and popularised harbour scenes? What were the iconographic conventions and chronological and geographical boundaries? What did the representations signify to those who commissioned and viewed them? Throughout the book, U. invites such questions by championing the need to analyse harbour images for their iconographical and ideological significance. Not every lighthouse, he points out, is Alexandria, nor every curving harbour installation Portus. This is a welcome approach to the material.
The book's preliminary discussion introduces the historical ports of Alexandria, Portus and Leptis Magna, with U. arguing that the trio was especially influential for harbour iconography. This iconography is introduced in ch. 3, primarily in wall-painting. In ch. 4, U. discusses harbour representations with (presumed) public commissions: Neronian and Trajanic Portus coins; the series of depicted harbours on the Column of Trajan frieze; and the lighthouse that appears behind the emperor on a relief panel from the Severan Arch at Leptis Magna. U. sees such imagery as imparting a sense of conquest, control and connection over the sea and across the empire, via the providential influence of the emperor. Ch. 5 turns to a series of mosaics found in private residences in various locations throughout the empire. These U. connects to a florescence of mercantile activity and a rising ‘mercantile class’ in the second and third centuries c.e., who celebrated their prosperity with images of bustling, secure ports. The sixth chapter explores and expands themes traced in previous chapters.
Sadly, the promising approach is ill served by the numerous methodological issues that plague the book. It is not transparent how U. defines a ‘harbour’ representation. For example, seaside villas with substantial landing facilities seem not to qualify as harbours, although where the distinction lies — public access? — is not specified. U. also fails to delineate clearly the selection criteria for what representations were included in the study. This is a pressing problem, given that the material covered ranges from Julio-Claudian coins, through Pomepeiian wall paintings, to Severan monumental reliefs in North Africa, to late third-century mosaics in Germany.
This weak foundation is symptomatic of a generally unsystematic and unspecific presentation of information. Interpretations are asserted repetitively, rather than argued with a clear sequence of evidence. An illustrative example is in U.'s treatment of the relationship between depicted and historical ports. He refreshingly interprets the Torlonia Relief and similar monuments as inspired by Portus’ harbour, rather than slavish reproductions thereof. Yet he repeatedly claims, without specific support, that the aforementioned major ports also served as direct models for all sorts of generic harbour representations, such as a mosaic from the Antiquarum Comunale (fig. 5.8) that shows only a nondescript lighthouse, a pier and some ships. The reader is left to wonder how an ancient viewer would have drawn specific connections to the Alexandria or Portus lighthouses; given the close relationship between function and design, most pre-modern lighthouses looked globally alike (a problem evidenced by nineteenth-century attempts to distinguish lighthouses along the Michigan and North Carolina coasts by applying distinctive paint patterns — a solution for which we have no ancient correlation).
Similarly shallow reasoning is applied to questions of patronage and reception. No clear distinction is drawn, let alone explored, between competing Senatorial and Imperial interests in commissioning public monuments. Issues of visibility for the representations in monumental reliefs are mentioned only in passing, if at all. Questions of audience targeting in coins go unexplored. Interpretations of domestic harbour mosaics as elucidating the interests of a growing merchant class are founded on the assumption that such mosaics were necessarily commissioned by such merchants.
The bibliography is scattershot. Three pertinent articles on depicted architecture on the Column of Trajan frieze, a rather specific topic, are missing (J.C.N. Coulston in M. Henig (ed.) Architecture and Architectural Sculpture in the Roman Empire (1990), 39–50; Wolfram Thill in AJA 114 (2010): 27–43 and JRA 24 (2011): 283–312). Methodological problems might have been alleviated through reference to important works on architectural depictions on reliefs (M. D. Grunow, Architectural Images in Roman State Reliefs, Coins, and Medallions, Ph.D. diss. University of Michigan (2002)) and coins (A. Burnett in G.M. Paul and M. Ierardi (eds), Roman Coins and Public Life under the Empire (1999), 137–64; N.T. Elkins, Monuments in Miniature: Architecture on Roman Coinage (2015); S. Ritter in JNG 67 (2017): 101-43). Closer editing could have mitigated the pervasive typographical errors (in numerous instances the same basic facts are given twice in one paragraph), which further obscure the often confusing and opaque text.
U. has hit on an important and overlooked resource, and brings an open and curious consideration to the material. I hope he will revisit the intriguing subject in a more systematic way, so that the archaeological community can benefit from his obviously substantial knowledge on the subject.
