The State not only has greater power to regulate and to police unhoused persons compared to people with access to housing. This chapter argues that the State also has the power to entrench people in the condition of homelessness.Footnote 1 Individuals who are entrenched in homelessness continue to experience the forms of double domination described in Chapter 4. Notably, they depend on others to obey laws that govern public property, and they must make nonegalitarian sacrifices to comply with these laws.Footnote 2
This chapter begins with an overview of punitive entrenchment and the main mechanisms that enmesh individuals in poverty and homelessness: fines, fees, surcharges, and collateral consequences of punishment.Footnote 3 The chapter then discusses the traditional objections to the punishments imposed on unhoused persons who violate laws that regulate public property, namely that these sanctions are difficult to justify according to retributivist and consequentialist theories of punishment.Footnote 4 This chapter’s concluding parts demonstrate that the punishments associated with these laws are objectionable because they cement unhoused persons in the condition of homelessness where they are subject to double domination.
6.1 Punitive Entrenchment
Unhoused persons who violate laws that govern public property can be subject to fines, fees, surcharges, penalties, and collateral consequences, all of which can entrench them in the condition of homelessness.Footnote 5 These punishments result in poverty penalties for unhoused persons who face harsher financial sanctions because they cannot afford to pay their initial fine.Footnote 6 The cumulative effect of these penalties results in a vicious cycle for impecunious and unhoused persons.Footnote 7 The direct and collateral consequences of punishment prevent unhoused persons from obtaining private property rights, enjoying all forms of liberty, and escaping double domination.Footnote 8
6.1.1 Fines
Punitive entrenchment begins when an unhoused person receives a fine because they violated a law that governs public property.Footnote 9 For some individuals, expensive fines can be very difficult if not impossible to pay.Footnote 10 In the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision Jones v. City of Los Angeles, the claimants sought an injunction that would preclude the police from enforcing a law that prohibited sitting, lying down, or sleeping on the city’s sidewalks.Footnote 11 The offense was punishable by up to six months’ imprisonment and/or a $1,000 fine – the same maximum penalty that was imposed for assault or drunk driving.Footnote 12 At the time when the claimants brought the injunction, there were roughly 1,000 more homeless people than available shelter spaces in Skid Row.Footnote 13 The maximum fine imposed for violating the law amounted to roughly four and half months’ worth of welfare payments.Footnote 14 The quantum of the fine was the financial equivalent of approximately three months of rent in a single rate occupancy hotel (SRO) – the city’s cheapest rental accommodation.Footnote 15
Other cities impose expensive fines for violating laws that regulate public property. In the city of Montreal, sleeping or lying down on a subway bench is punishable by a fine between $75 and $500 prior to applicable administrative fees and penalties.Footnote 16 The California Penal Code prohibits individuals from lodging on public property and imposes a minimum fine of $275, a maximum fine of $500, and/or six months’ imprisonment.Footnote 17 Boulder, Colorado, prohibits camping or lodging on public property without consent, which is punishable by a fine of up to $1,000.Footnote 18
Research demonstrates that most unhoused persons do not pay the fines that they receive for violating laws that govern public property. Marie-Eve Sylvestre and colleagues conducted an empirical study that examined the payment rate of fines issued to people experiencing homelessness in Toronto and Ottawa between the years 2000 and 2006.Footnote 19 Their research showed that less than 1 percent of unhoused persons paid the fines that they received when they violated a municipal ordinance.Footnote 20 San Francisco’s Coalition for the Homeless conducted a similar study between 2007 and 2013.Footnote 21 The study concluded that fewer than 10 percent of homeless people paid the fines that they received for violating laws that govern public property.Footnote 22
6.1.2 Administrative Fees, Surcharges, and Penalties
Unpaid criminal justice debts can result in additional surcharges, fees, and penalties.Footnote 23 The State can attach different types of surcharges to fines.Footnote 24 Certain jurisdictions impose administrative surcharges for certain types of offenses, such as traffic offenses or municipal ordinance violations.Footnote 25 The revenue from surcharges funds state-related compensation schemes – such as services for victims of crime – or supports certain governmental programs – such as legal aid.Footnote 26
Beth Colgan notes that various forms of surcharges exist. First, the State can impose a fixed surcharge amount irrespective of the quantum of the fine.Footnote 27 For instance, in Minnesota, each traffic offense includes a $75 surcharge.Footnote 28 Second, the quantum of the surcharge may increase for fines between certain amounts.Footnote 29 For example, in the province of Ontario, fines between $101 and $150 incur a $25 surcharge, whereas fines between $301 and $350 incur a $75 surcharge.Footnote 30 Third, the surcharge may be proportional to the quantum of the penalty.Footnote 31 California imposes a State surcharge that represents 20 percent of the amount of a traffic fine.Footnote 32
The State can also attach administrative fees to fines.Footnote 33 Administrative fees recover the cost of investigating, recouping, and adjudicating fines.Footnote 34 For instance, fees subsidize court costs, pay for public defenders, and recoup post-conviction costs.Footnote 35 Some jurisdictions impose fees even when the prosecution drops the charges against the defendant, or they are acquitted.Footnote 36
Penalties, for their part, are imposed when defendants do not pay the total amount of their fine.Footnote 37 There are various types of penalties: late-payment fees, interest charges, collection costs, and charges to enter into installment plans.Footnote 38 Penalties result in more expensive fines for impecunious persons because they cannot afford to pay their initial fines.Footnote 39 For this reason, some scholars refer to these supplemental charges as “poverty penalties.”Footnote 40 In certain cases, the total amount of fees and surcharges can exceed the quantum of the initial fine.Footnote 41
Although an unhoused person may be unable to pay a single expensive fine, research shows that many people experiencing homelessness receive multiple citations that lead to additional fees, surcharges, and penalties, and result in significant criminal justice debt.Footnote 42 Marie-Eve Sylvestre and Céline Bellot’s research highlights how a 52-year-old unhoused man in Montreal received roughly $89,000 worth of fines that he could not afford to pay.Footnote 43 Another person experiencing homelessness in Montreal was fined so many times that he owed roughly $44,000 worth of criminal justice debts.Footnote 44 In 2015, a social worker at Montreal’s “Droit Devant” organization – an alternative justice organization that helps absolve unhoused persons’ criminal justice debts – explained that she frequently encounters people experiencing homelessness who owe over $10,000 in unpaid fines.Footnote 45
6.1.3 Criminal and Civil Collateral Consequences of Punishment
Unpaid criminal justice debts result in significant consequences. First, courts may issue bench warrants that result in incarceration.Footnote 46 In Bearden v. Georgia, the US Supreme Court decided that the Fourteenth Amendment prohibits the State from imprisoning defendants because they cannot afford to pay their criminal justice debts.Footnote 47 The Court decided that judges must hold a Bearden hearing to assess a defendant’s ability to pay their fines.Footnote 48 These hearings assess, for instance, a defendant’s employment history and their available assets.Footnote 49
However, the Bearden decision held that indigent defendants may still be imprisoned for unpaid criminal justice debts in two circumstances.Footnote 50 First, when they did not make bona fide efforts to pay their fines, such as seeking employment or borrowing money.Footnote 51 Second, even if the defendant made such efforts, they may be incarcerated if alternate forms of punishment are inadequate in the circumstances.Footnote 52 The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has demonstrated that many courts do not conduct Bearden hearings to evaluate defendants’ financial capacities before incarcerating them.Footnote 53 Other research confirms the ACLU’s findings.Footnote 54
Canadian case law and legislation also prohibit the State from incarcerating individuals because they cannot afford to pay their criminal justice debts. In R v. Wu, the Supreme Court of Canada stated that “[g]enuine inability to pay a fine is not a proper basis for imprisonment.”Footnote 55 Imprisonment for debt is permissible only where other alternatives are inappropriate and the defendant refuses to pay their fine without reasonable excuse.Footnote 56 Like in the United States, Canadian courts must assess the defendant’s ability to pay prior to incarcerating them for unpaid criminal justice debts.Footnote 57 For instance, the province of Ontario requires judges to gauge a defendant’s ability to pay a criminal justice debt before they can be imprisoned.Footnote 58 A defendant who cannot afford to pay their fines may also request that the court expunge their fine.Footnote 59
However, in other Canadian jurisdictions, impecunious defendants who cannot afford to pay their fines have been incarcerated. Montreal ended the practice in 2004.Footnote 60 In contrast, in 2017, the city of Val d’Or imposed a moratorium on the incarceration of impecunious persons who could not afford to pay their fines.Footnote 61 Research demonstrated that 100 percent of individuals who were incarcerated for failing to pay their criminal justice debts were Indigenous.Footnote 62 Quebec City ceased incarcerating impecunious persons for unpaid fines in 2018.Footnote 63
Unpaid fines lead to other consequences. They may constitute a breach of one’s parole or probation conditions and result in imprisonment.Footnote 64 Individuals who are incarcerated for criminal justice debts are unable to work and may lose their jobs, which undermines their ability to support themselves and their families.Footnote 65 They are also exposed to various harms and risks during imprisonment, such as violence and psychological abuse.Footnote 66
Criminal justice debt can also result in civil consequences that more deeply entrench individuals in homelessness. Various US states suspend an individual’s driver’s license if they do not pay their fines.Footnote 67 Some forms of employment – such as being a taxi driver, bus driver, long-haul trucker, or delivery person – require a driver’s license.Footnote 68 An individual may lose their job because their profession required a driver’s license.Footnote 69 Or, they may lose their job because their city lacks adequate public transportation infrastructure and they cannot commute to work.Footnote 70 Many individuals who lose their job due to a driver’s license suspension receive a lower salary in their subsequent employment.Footnote 71 Driver license suspensions also tend to disproportionately impact racialized and socioeconomically disadvantaged persons.Footnote 72 Despite these drawbacks, many US states continue to suspend driver’s licenses for unpaid criminal justice debt.Footnote 73
Some jurisdictions convert unpaid criminal justice debts into default civil judgments.Footnote 74 Cities may contract out unpaid fines to debt-collection agencies.Footnote 75 Criminal justice debt can also be disclosed to consumer reporting companies.Footnote 76 Unpaid fines can negatively impact a person’s credit rating, which can make it more difficult to rent an apartment and register for utilities.Footnote 77 A bad credit rating also decreases one’s ability to obtain loans, receive credit cards, or open bank accounts.Footnote 78 Empirical research also indicates that unhoused persons who accumulate greater criminal justice debts tend to experience homelessness for longer periods.Footnote 79 Together, the cumulative effects of fines, fees, surcharges, penalties, and the collateral consequences of criminal justice debt entrench individuals in the condition of homelessness.
6.2 Disproportionality and Punitive Entrenchment
Laws that govern public property may impose disproportionate punishments on unhoused persons.Footnote 80 Proportionality implies that a punishment is commensurate with the offense’s severity and the defendant’s blameworthiness.Footnote 81 In terms of offense severity, conduct that harms others or violates their physical integrity are punished more serious than those that do not.Footnote 82 Crimes that are committed intentionally are punished more harshly than those that are committed as a result of recklessness or negligence.Footnote 83
Proportionality comprises two elements: cardinal proportionality and ordinal proportionality.Footnote 84 Cardinal (or absolute) proportionality refers to the proportionate punishment for a certain crime without having to compare it to other offenses in the criminal justice system.Footnote 85 The notion of cardinal proportionality suggests that certain punishments are inherently appropriate for certain crimes.Footnote 86 Ordinal proportionality, on the other hand, determines the punishments for different offenses based on their comparative gravity.Footnote 87 The concept of ordinal proportionality contains three principles. Parity entails that comparably serious offenses should result in similar punishments.Footnote 88 Rank ordering implies that more serious crimes should receive harsher punishments than less serious crimes.Footnote 89 Spacing implies that that punishments for more and less serious crimes should vary sufficiently to reflect their relative gravity.Footnote 90
Unhoused persons’ punishments for violating laws that govern public property can raise three types of proportionality concerns.Footnote 91 First, the quantum of a fine may be disproportional to the offense’s gravity, such that it violates both cardinal and ordinal proportionality constraints.Footnote 92 Recall that in Jones v. City of Los Angeles, discussed in Section 6.1.1, unhoused persons who slept on a sidewalk could be fined up to $1,000 fine and/or receive a six-month prison sentence.Footnote 93 This same punishment is imposed for assault or drinking and driving, even though sleeping on a sidewalk neither harms others nor endangers others’ well-being.Footnote 94 By treating sleeping on a sidewalk as if it were as harmful as assaulting others or driving while intoxicated, the punishment contravenes rank ordering, spacing, and absolute proportionality requirements.Footnote 95
Second, unhoused persons’ punishments can be excessive because the law ignores their personal circumstances, which results in harsher sanctions for certain individuals.Footnote 96 This second form of disproportionate punishment violates the parity principle because it results in additional poverty penalties for unhoused persons.Footnote 97 All other things equal, even though unhoused persons committed the same offense, they are punished more harshly than people with access to housing because they cannot afford to pay their fines.Footnote 98 For instance, people experiencing homelessness accumulate additional fees, surcharges, and penalties that people with access to housing will not incur.Footnote 99 In some cases, the quantum of the fine becomes so high that it is virtually impossible for an unhoused person to pay it. For this reason, the Supreme Court of Canada decided that mandatory minimum financial penalties can constitute a cruel and unusual punishment because they result in de facto indeterminate sentences for unhoused persons.Footnote 100 Unhoused persons’ punishments can violate the parity principle in other ways. Due to extreme poverty, people experiencing homelessness may also be incarcerated for unpaid criminal justice debts, while those who can afford to pay their fines will not.
Third, unhoused persons punishments are excessive when they ignore the extent of the defendant’s culpability given the circumstances.Footnote 101 Many laws that govern public property are strict liability offenses that impose a fixed fine on offenders irrespective of their moral blameworthiness.Footnote 102 Because these laws do not generally impose a mens rea requirement, the punishments do not generally distinguish between intentional legal transgressions versus negligent or unintentional ones. If an unhoused person takes reasonable precautions to obey a law that governs public property yet violates it, they risk being punished as harshly as someone who intentionally transgresses the law.Footnote 103 Such penalties ignore the defendant’s degree of culpability, which in addition to the severity of the offense, is the other crucial factor when determining the proportionality of an individual’s punishment.Footnote 104 Such punishments are objectionable because they communicate that the defendant is more blameworthy than they are.Footnote 105
6.3 Retributivism, Consequentialism, and Laws that Govern Public Property
The sanctions associated with laws that govern public property can be difficult to justify according to retributivist and consequentialist theories of punishment. Retribution is a backwards-looking punishment theory.Footnote 106 It holds that offenders deserve punishment because of their culpable wrongdoing.Footnote 107 As a backward-looking theory, retributivists value punishment irrespective of whether it produces prospective benefits.Footnote 108 Proportionality is central to retributivism.Footnote 109 The defendant’s desert is calculated according to the crime’s severity and the offender’s level of moral blameworthiness.Footnote 110 Excessive punishments are objectionable because defendants are punished more harshly than they deserve.
Retributive theories of punishment recognize that individuals deserve punishment only when they had the free choice to obey the law.Footnote 111 For instance, H. L. A. Hart famously argued that individuals can be punished only when they had the capacity and fair opportunity to comply with the law.Footnote 112 These requirements aim to recognize the importance of human agency and rationality.Footnote 113 The law instrumentalizes individuals, treats them as scapegoats, and disregards their human agency when they are punished for violating laws that they could not obey even if they tried.Footnote 114
The importance of free choice to obey the law underpins excusatory defenses such as duress and necessity.Footnote 115 Individuals are acquitted when threats, violence, or perilous circumstances undermined their freedom to comply with the law.Footnote 116 In such contexts, law-abidingness is not a reasonable alternative to breaking the law.Footnote 117 For this reason, individuals do not deserve punishment when they lacked a free choice – and thus a fair opportunity – to obey the law.Footnote 118
Scholars contend that retribution cannot justify the punishment of unhoused persons who violate laws that govern public property in two contexts. First, some argue that unhoused persons do not deserve punishment when they lacked a fair opportunity to obey laws that govern public property, especially when laws prohibit urban camping or sleeping in public despite insufficient shelter space to accommodate the city’s unhoused population.Footnote 119 Notably, the lack of shelter space undermines unhoused persons’ fair opportunity to obey these laws.Footnote 120 Second, some argue that unhoused persons’ punishments violate retributivism's proportionality constraint.Footnote 121 Unhoused persons’ sanctions can be excessive for various reasons.Footnote 122 As discussed in Section 6.2, punishments can be disproportionate with respect to the nature of the offense, individuals’ personal circumstances, and their level of moral blameworthiness.Footnote 123 Retributivism’s core tenets are violated in these contexts because unhoused persons do not deserve punishment or are punished more harshly than they deserve.
Others argue that unhoused persons’ punishments cannot be justified by consequentialist theories of punishment in certain contexts.Footnote 124 Consequentialism is a forward-looking punishment theory.Footnote 125 It posits that punishment is justified because of its future benefits – namely, that it prevents the offender and others from committing crimes.Footnote 126 Like retributivism, consequentialism also appeals to the offender’s rationality, agency, and freedom of choice.Footnote 127 The threat of punishment incentivizes individuals to comply with the law.Footnote 128 The prospect of punishment appeals to individuals’ self-interest to maximize their freedom and avoid coercion.Footnote 129
Some note that punishments cannot prevent unhoused persons from alleviating their needs on public property when they lack reasonable alternatives.Footnote 130 According to this argument, since individuals without access to property must alleviate their needs, access to private property – rather than punishment – is necessary to ensure compliance.Footnote 131 The brunt of this argument is that punishment is not an instrumentally rational means to deter unhoused persons from alleviating their needs on public property when they lack other reasonable options.Footnote 132
6.4 Counterproductivity, Punitive Entrenchment, and Domination
The punishments imposed on unhoused persons for violating laws that govern public property are objectionable for another reason: these punishments are counterproductive. Harsh punishments increase the risk that individuals will become entrenched in homelessness, continue to alleviate their needs on public property, and repeatedly violate laws that govern public property.Footnote 133 Punitive entrenchment prolongs and aggravates the double domination that unhoused persons experience.
The relationship between need-alleviating conduct, negative externalities, and punishment highlights the self-defeating nature of unhoused persons’ harsh penalties for violating laws that regulate public property. Need-alleviating conduct that occurs on public property generates negative externalities.Footnote 134 The term “negative externalities” implies “acts that impose unaccounted-for costs on others.”Footnote 135 The previous chapter demonstrated how individuals who alleviate their needs on public property may create public health concerns, decrease the aesthetic value of public space, reduce the efficiency of public ways, deprive others from using certain spaces, and more.Footnote 136 These acts can diffuse negative externalities (or unaccounted-for costs) amongst many individuals who use public property simultaneously.Footnote 137
Private property is valuable because it internalizes unaccounted-for costs that would otherwise occur on public property.Footnote 138 Individuals who can freely access private property can alleviate their needs without creating negative externalities that undermine others’ use and enjoyment of public space. In contrast, individuals who lack access to private property may generate such unaccounted-for costs because they have no alternative but to alleviate their needs on public property.Footnote 139 Since individuals cannot abstain from alleviating their needs, they must access a private place that absorbs these unaccounted-for costs.Footnote 140
Access to housing endows individuals with the greatest liberty to access private property, alleviate their needs in private, and generate fewer negative externalities on public property. Conversely, individuals without access to housing will continue to alleviate their needs in public and generate these unaccounted-for costs.Footnote 141
This explains why punitive entrenchment is morally objectionable for various reasons. First, harsh punishments and their collateral consequences may not only decrease access to housing for unhoused persons, but may also increase the likelihood that they will consistently alleviate their needs on public property.Footnote 142 These punishments can be more than ineffective from the standpoint of deterrence; they can be counterproductive.Footnote 143 Second, punitive entrenchment can cement individuals in the condition of homelessness where they will continue to experience nonegalitarian coercion.Footnote 144 So long as individuals remain entrenched in homelessness, the State will have greater power to regulate and police their basic needs compared to people with access to housing.Footnote 145 Third, individuals who are entrenched in homelessness will persistently suffer double domination, as described in earlier chapters. Notably, others will control their opportunities to obey laws that govern public property, and they will be forced to make nonegalitarian sacrifices to comply with these laws.Footnote 146 Ultimately, punitive entrenchment leads to nonegalitarian coercion and double domination.
6.5 Conclusion
This chapter demonstrated why the punishments associated with laws that govern public property entrench individuals in homelessness. It highlighted why unhoused persons’ punishments can be excessive and violate basic proportionality constraints. It demonstrated why some of these punishments and their collateral consequences cannot be justified by retributive and consequentialist theories of punishment. Its concluding parts explained why these punishments can be counterproductive. The next chapter explains how the State has an overarching fiduciary duty to counteract domination, and three specific fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property.
