As stated in the Preface (viii), the inspiration for this book came from a colloquium organized at the Institute of Classical Studies (London, March 2007), devoted to the topic ‘Questioning philosophy in Plutarch's Quaestiones Convivales’. It is clear that the editors did careful work in producing the volume, in order to have a coherent book on a quite often neglected or at least not very much studied part of Plutarch's œuvre. The result is a well-balanced volume, with an extensive Introduction (1–31) that provides a sound presentation of the main problems involving the Table Talks (henceforth TT) and of the literary tradition and cultural background in which they are embedded, with special attention paid to the symposium, the literature of problems and the Second Sophistic, thus situating the TT ‘within its cultural context as the first extant miscellanistic text’ (3).
The book has a clearly defined structure and comprises eight different analyses, distributed by four angles of approach. The first block ‘Traditions’ includes two studies devoted to the history of genre and to the history of interpretation. In ‘Plutarch's Table Talk: sampling a rich blend’, Frances Titchener gives a very useful review of past scholarship, showing that research on the TT for their own sake was done only from the latter third of the twentieth century, although they are now receiving much more attention, as is shown by recent conferences held in Quebec, London, Oxford and Coimbra. Teresa Morgan's ‘The miscellany and Plutarch’ presents an insightful analysis of miscellany, whose literary fertility makes it difficult to define as an independent genre. She argues that miscellanies in ‘wide and narrow senses’ were among the most important productions of the Roman Empire and exerted great influence until the nineteenth century, also asserting that ‘no single author contributed more to the genre than Plutarch’ (73).
The second part is focused on ‘Topics and Themes’, concerning mainly philosophical, scientific and medical contents. In ‘Philosophy in Plutarch's Table Talk’, Eleni Kechagia explores the omnipresence of Platonism in the TT, maintaining that it is directed both to ‘beginners’, to whom it provides methodological tools, and to ‘philosophically-versed readers’, involving them in Platonic theology and metaphysics. Katerina Oikonomopoulou (‘Peripatetic knowledge in Plutarch's Table Talk’) turns instead to the core presence of Peripateticism in the intellectual universe of the TT, with special attention paid to the practice of recollecting material within a performative framework of oral reception and transmission of knowledge, where memory plays a central rôle. In ‘Symposium, physical and social health in Plutarch's Table Talk’, Maria Vamvouri Ruffy explores an interesting parallel between philosophical knowledge and medical expertise, arguing that the symposiarch and the physician follow a similar methodology in order to reach comparable goals: to combat anything that may disturb the equilibrium, of a symposium or of a physical body alike.
The third block ‘Voice and Authority’ comprises another two studies. In ‘Imagining the past. Plutarch's play with time’, Frieda Klotz approaches the question of autobiographical information concerning Plutarch. She argues that the narrator's self-presentation is ‘kaleidoscopic’ — throughout the TT Plutarch is presented as a mature person, father, son, and modest student — and that this diversity stimulates a pedagogic impulse towards emulation and intellectual inquiry. Jason König, in ‘Self-promotion and self-effacement in Plutarch's Table Talk’, also explores the multi-faceted portrayal of Plutarch, but from a very different angle: he argues convincingly that, despite being an authoritative narrator who has a central rôle in the TT, Plutarch balances the risk of self-promotion with modesty, in a sympotic atmosphere created not only by the intellectual élite that participates in the meeting, but also by the ‘virtual community’ of the great authors convoked from the past into the discussion.
The last part is devoted to ‘Contradictions’ and includes a single chapter by Christopher Pelling on ‘Putting the -viv- into “convivial”. The Table Talks and the Lives’. He explores the concept of ‘cross-fertilization’ in Plutarch's production of the TT and the Lives, i.e. cases where material read for one of the works was also used for the purposes of the other. Pelling argues that this process can be detected more clearly in the use of Lives-reading in the TT than vice versa, but he also recognizes that the overlap is not very abundant. It provides in turn a clue to Plutarch's self-characterization: the writer avoids hinting at the Lives, in order not to appear before the eyes of his companions or of his readers as a boring narrator who knows ‘about history or about Lives’.
In the final ‘Conclusion’, the editors discuss briefly the issue of Nachleben, taking as reference a work composed some fifty or sixty years after the TT — the Attic Nights by Aulus Gellius, who quotes Plutarch directly as a Greek intellectual authority on this kind of sympotic miscellany. Although the approach is mainly by topic, it is effective in suggesting further inquiry on the TT.
The volume also includes an extensive and up-to-date bibliography (238–57), and in addition three Indexes (259–79) of names and concepts, of Greek terms and of passages quoted, which prove to be quite useful to the reader.
At the end of their conclusion, the editors express the hope that ‘this book will play a part in that process’ of rediscovering the TT. This reviewer has no doubts that their wish will be fulfilled.
