Scholarly attention to sexual politics in India is important in the aftermath of the Supreme Court of India's reversal of the Naz Foundation decision and ongoing public debates about sexual violence in India today. Sexuality Studies, edited by Sanjay Srivastava, is a timely collection that brings together sociological investigations of sexual discourses and practices in historical and contemporary perspective to ask why and how the study of sexuality can give greater insights into the politics of the present in India. The volume offers important perspectives on contemporary debates in India today, exploring everything from norms of love to contestations about queer rights, to threats against sexual rights in the complicated milieu of Hindu right-wing politics. The collection looks at a range of archives and spaces, from footpath erotica in the city to middle-class consumption of love in social media, to queer sexual identity and sociality in small-town India. The anthology is important for students and scholars working in and on South Asia to gain access to the range of scholarship on gender and sexuality, including Kumkum Sangari and Sudesh Vaid's groundbreaking volume on gender, Recasting Women: Essays in Indian Colonial History (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1990); Patricia Uberoi's Social Reform, Sexuality, and State (Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage Publications, 1996); and Brinda Bose and Subhabrata Bhattacharyya's volume, The Phobic and the Erotic: The Politics of Sexualities in Contemporary India (London: Seagull, 2007). The rich archives highlighted in Sexuality Studies point to the continued need for in-depth treatment of sexuality in India.
The volume begins with important historical investigations of sexuality in India. Sanjam Ahluwalia's article provides necessary historical grounding on the constitution of ideas about sexuality in the 1920s through the work of A. P. Pillay. Ahluwalia demonstrates how a science of sexuality in India was made not only through the transference of ideas circulating from Europe to India, but also in the translocation of that knowledge in relation to Indian notions of caste, class, and gendered difference. Like Ahluwalia in her examination of the exchange of sexual knowledge, Srimati Basu suggests that a powerful and limiting process of exchange and equivalence is key to understanding how sexual practices become legible (and illegible) to the Indian state in contemporary Indian courts. Through ethnographic observation in family courts in Kolkata and Dhaka, she considers the possible occlusions and erasures in mandates to produce commensurability between intimate acts and the language of the law.
Several authors consider the role of the postcolonial state and NGOs in the making of new social and sexual norms. J. Devika suggests that social norms of heterosexuality and maternity are complicit in the making of the developmentalist state in postcolonial India. Women's bodies become key to the collusion of developmentalist paradigms and normative ideas about family. Women who transgress these bounds are occluded and erased in these powerful discourses of developmentalism. Paola Bacchetta addresses the unusual contradictions folded into right-wing Hindu ideologies about queer communities. Svati Shah addresses the way law produces contestations in minority politics based on sexual identity, considering the differences and exclusions produced in discourses of gay rights versus sex worker rights.
Sexuality is key in the making of new consumption patterns associated with changing landscapes of class difference, space, and ideas about romantic love in a rapidly urbanizing India. Sanjay Srivastava considers changing patterns of consumption between the formal structures of the city and the “informal” everyday experiences of footpath literature. Striking in Srivastava's research are the connections in contemporary India of footpath advice manuals and writing on “sexology” that has been popular in different vernacular literature since the nineteenth century. While many articles focus on urban spaces and communities, Paul Boyce focuses on a much-neglected issue, the complicated terrain of homosocial and homosexual practices in rural and small-town India. Christiane Brosius offers a reading of new consumption of Valentine's Day in India. Like Srivastava, Brosius explores how the expansion of the urban middle classes has transformed articulations of desire and romantic love.
From these examples, one gets a sense of the diverse areas of inquiry that emerge in the investigation of sexuality in India. Key themes cut across this volume: the role of law in a limited language of sexual rights, the dissemination of norms of bodily comportment and propriety through popular texts, and the many modes of translation that constitute sexual norms in India—from the translation of European science to the translation of intimacy into the language of the law. Sexuality Studies will be of interest to scholars of South Asia as well as scholars interested in gender and sexuality in comparative perspective. As a result of structural imbalances in scholarly production and publication, there have been more edited collections than manuscript-length treatments on issues of sexuality in South Asia. The diverse areas of inquiry highlighted in this collection testify to the continued need for manuscript-length studies that explore at length the making of norms of sexuality in colonial and postcolonial India.
