In honor of John Cage's one-hundredth birthday in 2012, the John Cage Trust and the New York Public Library, with support from C. F. Peters and Carnegie Hall, launched two new websites to promote exploration of the composer's life and works. John Cage Unbound: A Living Archive and the John Cage: Official Website are both worth visiting.
Cage's use of indeterminacy, found objects, and environmental sound in many of his musical compositions made him one of the most widely known forward-looking composers of the 1950s and 1960s. But what comes through on these websites is not how innovative he was in his day, but how intellectually and aesthetically progressive his ideas remain. Through video clips, audio streaming, and inventive web apps, his music is made relevant to a new generation of teachers, students, and performers.
The Living Archive is a project directed by the New York Public Library, the repository for most of his music manuscript collection. The online archive is not a static series of web pages but the culmination of ongoing community outreach activities, the results of which are being archived on the website. Curator Jonathan Hiam states, “John Cage Unbound: A Living Archive is an online record of John Cage's work and its evolving impact on music and performance.” The site features several useful reference items: a detailed time line of Cage's life, digital images of music manuscripts and ephemera from the NYPL, and video recordings of performances.
The videos are the most interesting part of the site. Teachers, ensembles, and scholars are invited to upload videos to the archive on any topic related to Cage's music that they choose. Using the “Contribute” tab, users fill out a form describing their video, paste in a YouTube or Vimeo video link, and submit. Videos are then added to the website, where they can be searched and viewed by the public. The NYPL reserves the right not to post submissions considered inappropriate, but it appears that videos are otherwise posted without any formal vetting of content. Video recorded examples of works that use chance, found objects, improvisation, and unusual instrument preparations can all be found on the site, which therefore has the potential to become a performance practice reference. However, potential contributors must consult the library's “Policy on patron generated web content” for information on copyright and permissions
Some of the most interesting videos show Cage's music in K-12 classrooms. In one video, teens at the St. George Center Library gave a performance of his 1985 environmental composition, But What About the Noise of Crumpling Paper…?. I have enjoyed Cage's piano works and find them aesthetically pleasing, but seeing these kids have so much fun using found objects taken from their study space to beat out compelling rhythms reminds me that Cage believed everyone could make music.
Some of the videos have high instructional value. For example, an essential Cage video is one sponsored by the NYPL, in which Margaret Leng Tan talks through a demonstration of how to prepare a piano while inserting spoons, nails, and other objects into the strings. Other videos combine a filmed performance with a talk about approaching indeterminacy and other challenging compositional issues. The University of Kentucky Contemporary Music Ensemble contributed a video of Living Room Music (1940), in which performers talk about selecting their instruments (cups, tables, books), analyzing the indeterminate work between segments of the performance.
There are also several videos of Cage himself, including his enjoyable live rendition of Water Walk for the 1960 television show “I’ve Got A Secret.” Cage used household objects and a stopwatch to demonstrate that he was not a traditional composer but rather a constructive aesthete of sound, for whom all the world was his canvas.
The website is beautiful and informative. However, to a serious researcher, the site as it currently exists will not be of much help. There is simply a limited amount of content to date. There are no complete digitized manuscripts, and because the NYPL owns the John Cage Music Manuscript Collection, which includes autograph manuscripts of nearly all of his musical compositions as well as many sketches and drafts, I find this lack a disappointment. It would be nice to see them available online here in the future. The videos’ utility is limited as well. Only thirty-three of his more than 200 works are represented, and of those thirty-three, most are very avant-garde. The search box shows works by instrument and style period, but a simple list of titles would be helpful. Hovering the mouse over a video brings up a pop-up title, but it takes a few seconds for the name to appear, which slows browsing. In short, the site has much potential for planning a performance or talk about Cage. Even with limited content, college and K-12 teachers who want to introduce Cage or his music to their classes will find useful videos.
The official site of the John Cage Trust (http://johncage.org/) is another online archive with useful content. However, the site's navigation is confusing because the links are not consistently titled, and the page styles vary from link to link. For example, the works list, which is the most important feature of the site, is called the “Cage Database” on one page and the “Database of Works” on another. The list does take advantage of the online medium by including details and comments about the composition, a discography with links to purchase sites, and a link to the published score if one is available.
The site also features several novel online realizations of Cage's works. There is a “performance” of Empty Words by Eddie Kohler that uses a shuffle function to randomly load the text and demonstrate the concept of indeterminacy. Under the link for Reunion (1968), however, I expected to find a performance of this piece for electrified chess game but instead found a page called “How long is a game of chess?” and another title, “Digital Reunion (essay).” My confusion was compounded because the navigation titles were once again inconsistent from page to page. I eventually concluded that there is an HTML5 version of Reunion being developed, which will be added to the site in the future. At that point this portion of the website should be much easier to navigate.
The site includes two entertaining demonstration apps for the iPhone, which can be downloaded via iTunes: the “prepared piano” app and 4’33”. The latter app gives users a chance to capture, share, and archive their own 4’33”–long performance with their phones. Both apps could be used to engage students at all levels.
Several features on this site have room for growth. For example, a section called “Folksonomy” lists names of people associated with Cage and has space for users to contribute memories and content, but most of the space is blank. There is also a “Centennial Archive” with a section for sharing birthday wishes, but its content is limited. Additionally, links between John Cage websites would be helpful, including a link from the Living Archive to johncage.org.
Indeed, both sites have content limitations because both were designed to grow over time. Although both sites currently feel unfinished, this feature is actually one of their more refreshing aspects. Unlike many web sites and online archives, whose typical data life cycle culminates in obsolescence, these sites are envisioned to be active for a long time. I would encourage John Cage enthusiasts, teachers, and scholars to visit them now and in the future.
